Lady Gaga x Liza Minnelli — New York, New York

#shorts #ladygaga #ladygagafan #ladygagafans #gaga #franksinatra #sinatra #musicaltheatre #broadwaymusicals

[deborahbishop]

LIZA MINNELI GIVES ME THE CHILLS WHEN SHE SINGS !

[maryannehorn]

Gaga is singing more like the Sinatra version. Only Liza, can do Liza!

The song "New York, New York" by John Kander and Fred Ebb was written for the Martin Scorsese film of the same name, starring Liza Minnelli. It doesn't matter that Sinatra's version was more popular, New York, New York was written for the fabulous and never unmatched Lisa Minelli. minelli

[phillipe]

Both of them were amazing each one in their own style and era.

[susanamendez]

Lady Gaga canta muy bonito, pero jamás podrá ser comparada con alguien que es única y extraordinaria como la Reina y la Unica Lisa Minelli❤ Es y Será El Arte, La Pasión y El Talento Junto y eso sólo se da muy de vez en cuando.

[starrlehner]

Sorry lady Gaga no comparison. Liza Minnelli had it. LIZA!

[daisyhagen]

Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery!

[MargaretDangelo]

I can't choose one Of those preferences the song New York. I love them both. Lady gaga and Liza minnelli versions. Im a fan of both of thses ladies ❤❤❤❤❤❤.

[denvance]

Liza Minelli is tops!! ❤
Gaga's voice is too weak and lacks stamina for this golden Minelli hit!
Liza can sing, dance and act. No one can do Liza like Liza!

[LadyIrrigator]

I mean it was writtem for her. Sinatra did his cover. But this is a Liza Original.

[joeypuckett]

Wow, no one comes close to Liza when it comes down to belting out great stage tunes! Her voice has that grandness or majesty like Elvis, just so unique and you can tell she’s singing so loud! I know that comes from projecting your voice on stage. She’s really fantastic!

[natalieinger]

Always has to be Liza.She is out of this world and has earned her spurs in life.Both are fabulous, but has to be Liza.❤

[patrickkenney]

" WRITTEN.FOR A WOMAN / SUNG BETTER BY A WOMAN!" LADY GA, GA, SO MUCH BETTER THAN EVER COULD as; " THEATRICS ADD TO THE SCORE!" Yet, No One Top, " THE THEATRICAL RANGE.of LIZA' with a Z

[guidobrito]

Alright, if I had to choose who takes the crown from both & kings & anyone for the theme "New York, New York, " I’m giving it to **Frank Sinatra**. Here’s why:

Sinatra's version is iconic for a reason. He embodies the essence of New York with his smooth delivery and effortless charisma. When he sings, you can practically feel the city pulsing through his words. It’s not just a performance; it’s an experience. His style captures the laid-back confidence that defines the Big Apple, making you want to grab a drink and hit the town.

Now, don’t get me wrong—Liza Minnelli’s rendition is powerful and full of life. She brings an intensity that’s hard to match, and if you’re looking for drama and emotion, she’s got it in spades. But sometimes, that level of intensity can overshadow the subtlety that makes a song resonate deeply.

At the end of the day, it’s about the vibe you want. If you want the raw energy of a Broadway show, go with Liza. But if you want a classic, timeless interpretation that feels like the heartbeat of New York, Sinatra’s your man.

So there you have it. Crown goes to Sinatra, THE BEST!

[harlemhomme]

LiZa's DNA is all over this song. Love Gaga and she does a nice rendition but com'on Liza all day long! lol

[lynnej.]

I love them both, but.. there's no one like Liza..

[Королева-еп]

Если бы первой была гага, песню забыли бы уже давно! Перепевалка и подражалка! Так исполнить можнет только гениальная Лайза!❤❤❤❤❤

[joaoluizandradetoscani]

Liza minnelli muito melhor incomparável.

[frankiebowie]

Artists today have to smooth everything out. There is no Liza Minnelli, there is no Janis Joplin or Little Richard or Freddie Mercury etc etc etc.
Scrappiness is a thing of the past, but it’s what made great artists.
I prefer to listen to singers who have nothing to lose and who put it all out there.

[lc]

Love them both but this song 🎵 belongs to Liza!