Is Aaron Rodgers the best playmaker ever? First Take debates

Is Aaron Rodgers the best playmaker ever? First Take debates
Marcus Spears and Dan Orlovsky debate whether Aaron Rodgers is the best playmaker ever.
#FirstTake #NFL

[MarcusTheMvp]

( marcus under his breath ) “ yall was trash “ 😂

[DOWNBAD_Tay]

He’s the greatest talent ever at the qb position

[rashadsmith]

I love these two going at it. Grat job Stephen A and ESPN

[deerinheadlights]

Is this pre-recorded or are they working Xmas evening?

I think it’s pre-recorded. I think that would make more sense.

[semi]

Jerry Rice is the best WR of all-time. He just doesn't come to mind when I think playmaker. He may have been the most consistently great player ever. When I think playmaker I think of wow plays or shocking displays of skill and ability.
I think Deion Sanders, Barry Sanders, Laurence Taylor, and Randy Moss. They made you want to rewind the tape.

[worldtree]

Top 5 Playmakers of All-Time
1. Aaron Rodgers
2. John Elway
3. Patrick Mahomes
4. Brett Favre
5. Russell Wilson or Steve Young

[mattislinx]

Jerry Rice was my favorite player growing up, but I think Marcus has playmaker confused with volume stats. Jerry was so good for so long. No doubt about that. Some of his records will probably never be broken. But as far as a playmaker, I don't think he would be that high on the list.

[ProjctX]

Manning imo, he legit revolutionized how people play QB with the no huddles.

[kerke]

For me, it’s between Prime Time and LT. They pulled stuff that we still haven’t seen to be replicated in any way and they did it so often. Especially Deion. I mean when someone else in his team generated a turnover they would specifically find Deion Sanders for him to make a big play. That’s how amazing he was. I mean the man played offense, defense and special teams at some point.

[MiniatureMorpheus]

Steve Young would like a word with y'all. If Eddie D hadn't given Charles Haley to the Cowboys, Steve Young would have 3-4 rings

[bryantwallace]

Barry Sanders was more of a electrifying player than Jerry Rice, but Jerry Rice is a better playmaker than Barry Sanders tho.

[raman]

the most spectacular QB ever, but not the most successful QB. We all know Tommy Patrick Brady is

[tboss]

Is and always will be a better thrower of the ball than Tom Brady.

[dchenkin]

ESPN completely ignored defense in this conversation. For me the greatest playmaker in NFL history was Lawrence Taylor; he was unblockable without being double teamed in his prime.

[jabari]

Im a packers fan but I hate how they over hype Aaron I wish we could just take a humble route.
He’s an amazing QB but we do this every year and then the trash talking comes when we lose in the NFC championship game.

[henry]

I would say Brady is NOT a playmaker but is surrounded by some

[larrymacgyver]

Wouldn’t the best playmaker ever be good enough to have more than one Super Bowl appearance ?lkke 10 maybe ??? Or good enough to be better than 1-4 in nfc conference title games ? Making the best plays ever ? Doesn’t sound like Rodgers

[Sneakergod]

If you know football brady forgot ab manning and brees

[JohnSmith-tknt]

What's Marcus laughing about? He was on the 2000s cowboys lol. Detroit lost because they had no talent, Dallas lost because they shot themselves in the foot year after year after year after year. Nobody expected the Lions to win, the fact that the Romo Cowboys never won a single big game in his entire career is downright embarrassing and Marcus was there to help!

[luisgarza]

Roger will probably stay if they pay him