BTS Can’t Sing (With Proof)

[yaa]

So the only thing I didn't like about the video was the comparison to jk, I don't think it was necessary, but about his voice I mostly agree. Jimin is my bias, and I'm saying this because I want to see him improve. I think the problem is not only jimin, but big hit too, like even when they record in studio, the producers and the ones who work there, they seem to give to ignore the mistakes he makes or how he struggles. I mean, if you see your artist having problems singing or using the wrong technique, you should tell him, it's not a bad thing, you only help him. Jimin didn't get the vocal lessons he needed, and it also seems that even the members give him some advices on how to sing, which shouldn't happen, like, if it's an advise on how to sing a verse ok, but on how to sing in general nope. It's like they ignore this problem, it's 2021 and, yes from the debut, he really improved, but not how someone should have improved in all those years. I'm sad sometimes, because when I see a performance, and jimin's it's coming, I always hope he doesn't make any mistakes. Usually no one talks about it, but there is one youtuber, I'm not going to say his name, who always says the truth, not only about jimin, but if he heard someone making mistakes, he is going to tell you. One last thing is that we had this covid pandemic and unfortunately that means, for them, no concerts or other things, and I'm not saying they didn't do anything during that period, because they did a lot of performances in various shows, but, as they said, their schedule was a little more lighter, so they had more time for themselves, and someone practiced and other things, and I'm wondering why during that time jimin didn't have any vocal lessons(or maybe he did, I don't know), like it was the perfect occasion, they had this kind of pause( more time), I really don't understand. I hope this "problem" is going to be fixed. I really want to see jimin more proud and secure about his voice, because he has such a beautiful and unique voice.

[marr]

'BTS cant sing' is a crazy conclusion because the video is TWO MINUTES long and they exist for ELEVEN YEARS. Think again

[Meeekuuuu]

It seems kinda wrong to compare the members with Jk, they all have strengths and weaknesses but Jk is the main vocalist and the only member who actually auditioned to sing plus got good training

[sarahomar]

Imagine being 10 years into your career with thousands of LIVE performances with very complex choreos, doing them sick and with sound issues, and insane schedules behind you, and all of your mistakes can only add up to 3 minutes! Of course this video is made by a solo stan who has no idea what vocals or vocal techniques are or how they work.

[hellozm]

me who thought the title was being sarcastic 💀

[desiredesire]

As a former singer, it’s not easy to maintain your voice when you constantly singing from one stage to another stage..and they are not only singing, but also dancing..it’s normal when you have days when you losing your voice especially when you have to hit high notes in almost every songs like Jimin and Jin..and there could be technical issues when your earphone didn’t work so you can’t really hear your voice…my advise, pls don’t judge someone unless you have experienced what they gone through..all bts vocal lines have unique vocal characters that compliments each others..every members worked hard for their group and their fans..there will be no bts without the vocal lines and rap lines..that’s all

[nohinzachariahvarghese]

Your channel's name explains your problem

[user]

Ok im here in 2024 coz i was missing them... And the fact that out of their 11 yr career, we could only find 2min of clips with mistakes 😂 proves how great they are.
Ps: for haters who are saying that these aren't all of their bad clips, show me just 1hr or even just half an hour clips of them giving poor performance.

[nusmkpopdance-mhiw]

I'm here in 2024 and wondering. Jimin, and in fact, most of BTS members were never meant to be singers and dancers. JK is the only original vocalist in the whole team. Jin and Jimin had to LEARN singing. RM, and Suga had to LEARN dance. Jhope had to LEARN rap. Literally all of them had to LEARN to be the magnificent all-rounders they are today. Hence, they are the biggest boy band in the world. So, I'll take your all of 2min of vocal mishaps because...11years later and they still remain on top.

[eden]

i’m not even a singer, i play the drums, but i’ll let you know my stance on this video. i think that people forget that bts do so many performances and tour all over the world. like with any frequently performing groups, there will always be a few performances that aren’t performed as they were recorded on the tracks that we hear on spotify and stuff. whether this is the members’ intonation (pitch accuracy) their timbre/tone (the characteristics of their voice) or even their energy or enthusiasm, i feel that we should understand they are still only humans who aren’t computers that recreate sounds on command. just an example of this - no matter how amazing you are of a musician/dancer/performer, if you do 200 performances you are definitely going to have at least one that isn’t as amazing compared to the other 199 technique wise. i think it’s healthier for us as fans to be aware of this because if we don’t, it puts an unrealistic amount of pressure on the musicians we love, especially bts. also, i don’t know if it’s right of us to compare the members in such a way because as musicians and performers i can assure you they already criticise themselves and compare enough.

i hope this communicates my view well, take care army and everyone else in this comment section💜

[lacramitus]

As a singer myself. I know that this is not the result of bad technique.
firstly, In loud environments, its hard to sing in Pitch because there so much of chaos in the Background. its not bad technique.
People who sing know that everyone has those days when they dont perform as well.
I Salute Artists who Tour. its not easy to sing while moving or Dancing.
You cannot Judge someones Singing Based on a Few clips of their Worst perfomances.

[kimyoung]

when the name of your channel just implies you are a solo stan

[leekyungmin]

the last video is in the middle of the tour concert. jimin carried after that song because he was disappointed by himself. that season he was sick at throat. but jimin always tries to be improved himself. so Don't compare to JK

[prystsjtstsjs]

"im an army since debute" ass

[Somii_]

Haha, this is the problem of solo stans. Not a new thing, we know jungkook is so good, he's the main vocalist and has to work more for his singing but it doesn't mean other members are talentless. showing some videos of voice cracking and not in good condition doesn't prove that they're not good singers. it's not easy to sing live and also while dancing. But the problem is that you (so-called solo stan) can't understand how much they invest their time into singing and bcz of their diets and all they lack in singing. You are not at that stage to judge them. I have a suggestion for you to find their hard work, watch their best vocals Instead of praising one by showing others wrong. but no why would you watch their best vocals 🤣these videos can prove you wrong right!?🌝

[amnanafeesa]

2:05 why are you comparing Jimin with Jungkook? I'm sorry if I sound rude but you sound like a solo stan..

[Wow]

Ok? So you’re saying they can’t make mistakes they’re humans to everybody makes mistakes. Jimin has a beautiful voice actually all of them do..

[joyc]

Jimin is my bias, and I do agree on parts that his voice is the one that easily gets strained especially when they are having world tour, in case you don’t know he talked about it already and it has something to do with his tonsils saying that its really bigger than the normal size which causing his voice to easily get strained, and recently he has been doing vocal lesson which I’m hoping that would help give him a better technique. His voice for me is really the most captivating unique and healing, besides being a genius performer on stage. He shines in everything he does these mistakes for me are just normal can’t even bring down on how great he is. Now that they are having solo projects I’m looking forward of what he can bring cause all of his songs are masterpiece. His charisma, stage presence, performance level, persona and passion will always be his strong points which can carry anysong given to him… looking forward to Park Jimin the performer only hyper critical, jealous, and bitter person will say he is not good and lacking. Park Jimin is more than enough.

[airabenitez]

fans have to change mindset about the idols, they are total package and not just best singer, best dancer...i completely stan JK but to compare his skills toward other BTS member is inappropriate, for me they shine all on their own ways. Aa a new army and a former local band vocalist, im not surprised that i immediately picked out JK among the rest but looking back, i cannot see any other member less deserving of the group fete since they all work very hard and as said contribute to the fame of BTS

[sarah]

Truth untold jimin was sick and they was messing about on the encore stage.... and no ones voice is going to be perfect when they perform as often as they do and they song live! You say theres been no improve yet dont post anything recent.... and there was many good performances of ON and all the songs you posted but you expect them to be perfect all the time.... definitely not an army