Is the NEW Gardein Vegan Fish The Same As the Old? Let's Test! | Review and Taste Test

Gardein recently change their recipe for their vegan fish. It was already one of the best on the market, so today we're doing a comparison between the old and the new!

See what our thoughts are in this 100% honest review!

Have you tried this? Let us know!

❌ Allergens: Wheat, Soy.

Ingredients: Water, Enriched Wheat Flour (Wheat Flour, Niacin, Reduced Iron, Thiamine Mononitrate, Riboflavin, Folic Acid), Textured Vegetable Protein Product (Soy Protein Concentrate, Titanium Dioxide), Canola Oil, Less than 2% of: Potato Starch, Tapioca Starch, Salt, Methylcellulose, Yeast Extract, Degerminated Yellow Corn Flour, Wheat Gluten, Onion Powder, Garlic Powder, Leavening (Sodium Acid Pyrophosphate, Sodium Bicarbonate, Monocalcium Phosphate), Sugar, Natural Flavors, Yeast, Paprika, Spices, Autolyzed Yeast Extract, DHA Algal Oil, Soy Flour, Xanthan Gum, Soybean Oil, Citric Acid, Turmeric, Rosemary Extract, Ascorbyl Palmitate.

🖤 Hey…have a good day, okay? We appreciate you🌈
Thanks so much for watching. We’d love if you could click the “Thumbs Up!” Button, leave a comment below and Subscribe to our channel!

★Products That We Used For This Recipe★
*Affiliate Links for products help us make these videos. Thank you for your support.

[lindsayhudkins]

Almost in every video you diss yourself (your brain is fuzzy or you don't think you are being articulate), but you are clearly intelligent and delightful. Thanks for the videos! I appreciate your research and the time you put into them.

[uuic]

So sad the old ones will be gone! I LOVE them, and had also made the Long John Silvers comparison. I made my sushi with them, and they are the best!! Thank you for all of the information, it helps with the transition. Gardein prices have skyrocketed!

[ladyfashionsoul]

I miss the old products. I don’t love the ultimate line especially considering you get odd number pieces in them and the cost is so much higher.

[cydonia]

I have been buying these for the last month or so and I like them. Just wish they had more of a beer batter/pub style coating. On a side note, I just bought a new plant based calamari from Fresh Thyme and they were INCREDIBLE!!!

[BriannaFitness]

Me and my sister used to buy these as a treat for Fish & chips Friday (A common tradition in New Zealand) and then they disappeared from the supermarkets completely! NZ has a pretty depleted range of vegan foods, but I hope the new ones make an appearance soon, that would be cool 😊

[mikewynn]

I just found the new ones and I will be trying them tomorrow! I’m sure I will enjoy them! Worthington had a fish fillet many years ago that was similar to shrimp boat here in Cleveland Ohio we used to have back in the 70s! It was delicious!

[avgc]

Thanks for the review! Didn’t even know there’s a new version… will have to give it a try as I do really like the original.

[imjustpeachy]

I absolutely love both of these products but my new favorite is the new one. I still buy both❤❤I put old bay seasoning on both and I pair with grits or make a pressed sandwich

[AliciaCatTaylor]

I just tried these!

The older ones taste better just because they were battered, not breaded with crumbs.

[paulaleach]

I just picked up the new Gardein ultimate fish yesterday at Mariano’s (Kroger owned store). I’m looking forward to trying it. I enjoy the older version, so I’m excited to see how this new ultimate product compares. Thanks for your review!

[Kevin-zhho]

God bless y’all! Half these products I would never know about if it weren’t for your videos 🙌🏽 I do enjoy Gardein Ultimate so a vegan seafood option is exciting to see!!

[alysoncocking]

I used to like the Gardein products when it was sold in UK supermarkets. Their fish ones were definitely the ones I'd buy. I miss them...

[maqnthreez]

Enjoyed Captain D's and Long John Silver growing up too. And agree both fast food and 'ol Gardein had similar taste and texture

[melodyshaw]

Thanks guys! Always enjoy your videos. I love your dynamic, your beautiful family, and "sharing" the journey! ❤😊 God bless 🙏 and have a great 4th of July!

[TheeJoieDeVivreGarden]

I used to LOVE LJS! I was hoping that these new filets would be similar! I love the Gardein/Gardein Ultimate brand.

[Katorri]

palette cleansers, when you do multiple products, may help better distinguish taste

[alexsadventures]

Why is it you only get a three pieces in those ultimate so weird like put 4 in there! 🤣💪🏻👌🏻

[tiffanyblack]

This fish product is so good when you deep fry them. I couldn't eat this fish from the oven or air fryer. They are good when fried. The texture is spot on when fried as well as the taste.

[VeganowledgeJJ]

I loved the old fish one I never tried the ultimate yet. I thought the old one the exact texture I loved and could imitate a McDonald’s fish filet I put with Chao cheese helmans vegan mayo mixed with sweet relish for “tarter” sauce on sandwich and it was amazing! I’m kind of sad that it has a new texture although like you said still good seafood imitation I’ll take it when I want to make that

[ncnt]

I like the old ones better too. And I agree it’s reminiscent of long John silvers. I used to love ljs (I wasn’t a huge fish person and theirs kinda tasted like a mix of chicken and fish)