What if Eren’s Mom Survived?!

#attackontitan #eren #carla

[SolLikesStars]

Eren would join the scouts regardless. he wanted to BEFORE his mom died

[L_I_V_E-]

truly a canon moment that cannot be stopped.

[ToygarHaNN]

Tbh you missed a pretty important detail Grisha wouldn't kill the Reiss family if Eren didnt inharited attack titan

[benlife]

Grisha only had one more year when shigashina fell, so he would have to give the attack titan to eren in a few months

[chimmychanga]

He would join the scouts regardless. Y’all forgetting Eren already killed people long before he got his Titan. He was a crazy, rage-driven kid

[pohorex]

The issue is, grisha and Erens mom would’ve been sent out with the thousands who got sent to “reclaim wall Maria” (which was actually just population control)

[emojaapie]

Eren not joining the scouts is dumb. He wanted to join them way before they got attacked

[oimgrn]

Eren is the reason his mother dies anyway in the first place

[omlg]

This is why I can’t hate Eren, it’s a dog-eat-dog world, can’t really blame him for wanting to kill Marley, it is what it is.

[Everythingmedia-by]

Eren had already wanted to join the scouts before his moms death

[cathygrandstaff]

I actually think if Attack on Titan is a time loop story where we only see the last loop there’s probably a previous loop where the smiling Titan eats Bertolt and transforms back into Dina. This gives Eren, Mikasa and Hannes time to get Carla out of the rubble, but it also means the group find out far earlier about Marley and the people outside the walls as Dina explains this. We also have the uncomfortable situation where Grisha has to explain things to his wives. Most likely with the royal family exterminated Dina is taken in as the new queen and is forced to eat Grisha, restoring the Founding Titan to the royal line and most likely forcing Dina under the control of the King’s vow against fighting. This would remove the Founding, Attack and Colossal titans from play and mean that while Marley couldn’t attack the island for a while the scouts also would never gain their decisive weapon against the titans. Eren would go on to join the scouts as a regular human.

[Eldollow-hx]

You cant decide if he would or not. His character is extremely complex. You need to consider " would future eren let this happen " or " what if this or that happens ". The story is made to be so precise its impossible to change any detail at all

[mahmoudayman]

Grisha wouldn’t even kill the Royal family and get the founding, since the only reason why he did that is because of what Eren showed him. We saw that in “Memories of the Future” episode when Grisha found the Reiss family very early on and chose not to kill them and went back to Eren and Carla

[johnjohnson]

"On your feet dad!"

Bro reminded him to avenge his sister as well so he would've still done everything regardless

[stewardappiagyei]

I feel like Grisha would've contacted Keith Shadis to provide an audience with Erwin, then inform them about the truth of their world, the government's true nature, and the vow renouncing war. He could then secretly entrust the scouts with the Attack Titan in the hopes they'll find a way to turn things around. They would be massively more prepared for whats to come this way, most of their flounders with Annie, Bert and Reiner were due to lacking info.

[clintrafaelalfonso]

Erens attack titan is just pure op the fact he fought ARMORED TITAN AND THE JAW TITAN AT THE SAME TIME

[kaitlin]

Grisha also only had like a year left. Maybe not that little but he didn’t have long.

[mvdmubt]

He didn't have a choice when giving the Titan to Eren, his 13 year term was up so he chose Eren.

[_zuma_]

If eren's mom survived the timeline would be different way from before eren was born cuz the current stroyline is in a time paradox

[BiggestPhangirl]

Eren’s dream was always the Scouts, he’d have absolutely joined them. His resolve would’ve been weaker yes, but it wouldn’t be in character for him to back out. And Grisha didn’t give him the Titan to avenge Carla, he gave him the Titan to save Paradis—basically pushing on Eren the same thing he’d tried to push on Zeke, but in a different way.