How Hadith & Sunnism Destroyed Islam & Rationality

[zaidmuhammad]

Why are people calling him Shia? Dont the Shia have their own hadith? You dont need to label everyone. Allah simply called us Muslims, just say you're Muslim.

[MysticVokkai]

I was amazed at how rational, ethical and accepting the Quran is when I first started reading it.

[AbidNasim]

Islam was completed in March 632 CE (Maida / Chapter 5 verse 3). Hadith collection was a profitable business. Later, shorter the isnād (chain of narration) the more valuable it would be in the market. There is even Hadith whose narrator is a jinn. Interestingly, in the 7th and 8th century, typical chain would be 28 narrators, and then in the 9th century, suddenly we find the chain shortens to 5 narrators. People who point this out are polemicized as Hadith Denier (منکر حدیث). Well, truth is, everyone is a Hadith Denier. There is no one who believes in every Hadith. Even Bukhari collected 600, 000 narrations, but compiled around 4, 500, hence rejecting 595, 000. Here is a simple rule: any Hadith that Quran validates is potentially true, and otherwise false.

[seraphx]

Allah said Quran is a complete explanation for all things, end of discussion right there, no scholar or other man can contest the statement of his god.

[salvitheshiningevil]

This is true, i have been asking where did we go wrong. Then I kept picking up how ideal sunni world is and how realistic quran is. It should be both realistic, not the opposite. You do not need to be rocket scientist to see the flaw of sects and hadith. Quran is the way to go if you are a proper Muslim.

[عبداللهسليمان-عز]

O Allah, I ask you to guide me to the right and true, straight path forever and forever, quickly and urgently in the best way forever and forever! Amin

[shahzarkhan]

Majority of Muslims likes stories, one wear white turban, the others will wear green, black, yellow etc. They will look at each others beards and say mashala yours is longer than mine and lifts their pants up showing their heals some will have long hair that's the religion they follow.

[don_cotti_c]

Beautiful to see Muslims upon the Haqq and leaving behind the hadeeth which corrupts our belief system Alhamdulillah

[Farhadmoh]

I agree, I think Hadith should not be rejected entirely as lots of Hadith matches with Quran and history but it not be treated divine or 100% authentic rather good tool but also put question marks and red line on questionable Hadiths, any questionable sayings should be rejected, like stoning of adultery should be rejected.

[wolfking]

I thank Allah for guiding me here. May he bless you Allahu AKBAR!

[優さん-nm]

The revelation that God gave to Muhammad is not limited to Qur'an.

What the prophet says, does and approves is also part of the faith. This is basic common sense.

Those that reject hadith completely are disbelievers.

Hadith is merely a record of what the prophet said, did and approved/disproved and the belief and practice of the earliest generations of Muslims that were taught by the Prophet himself or his companions.

Anyone that rejects this vast amount of information either does not know what hadith is, or is a disbeliever.

Promoting hadith rejection along with rejection of the 1400 year of Islamic scholarship and create "Qur'an only Muslims" is one way that the enemies of Islam want to create a new Islam that is fully compatible with thier desires and plans for the Muslim nations. In short, it is an intellectual attack on the faith.

[abdulmalik]

I think I found a gem right here with this video. Great summary, great video.

[hussainresearch]

Salaamun Alaikum. Sunnism and Hadith sounds like a Religion out of Harry Potter. I am certain it will make a very entertaining reading and good stories for kids.

[zuzukouzina-original]

The problem with the Sunnis is they stick to the works of old scholars and don’t allow you to review the Hadiths with the knowledge of today. Hadiths are not words of Allah, so we can refute them. 0:05

[Farhadmoh]

Questionable Hadith tells women to bow down to their husband, Aisha RA age when proof shows she was way older, yet people take bhukari or sahi Muslim to be 100% authentic and that’s dangerous.

[alsyed]

Salaam Bro and Sis, it's very unfortunate that despite the overwhelming proof and clear statements from Allah SWT regarding the Hadith, we fell into this trap. The majority of our so-called "Islamic Practices" have little to do with the Quran. Almost all Islamic Practices have clear human content. Our prayers and practices are no longer pure "Khalis" as they should be. They contain humans. No matter how one justifies, they are a form of shirk. Let's see sme of the Quranic statements about the Hadith. "God has sent down the very best "hadith' in the form of a Book, consistent with itself, which makes all those who fear their Lord shudder. So their hearts and bodies become receptive to the remembrance of God. THIS IS THE GUIDANCE OF God with which He guides whosoever He will, but whosoever God leaves to stray, HAS NONE TO SHOW HIM THE WAY: (Sura 39:23). AND WHOSE "HADITH" IS TRUER THAN GOD'S?": (Sura 4:87). IN WHICH "HADITH" AFTER THIS WILL THEY THEN BELIEVE?": (Sura 7:185). "THESE ARE THE REVELATIONS OF God WHICH WE RECITE TO YOU CORRECTLY. IN WHAT OTHER "HADITH" THAN God AND HIS REVELATIONS WOULD THEY THEN BELIEVE?" (Sura 45:6).

[questioneverything]

Hadiths are not necessary or needed for salvation. Allah’s word (Quran) gives enough information for us to practice Islam and make it to Jannah


Non of the Authenticators of these Hadiths were there during the time of the prophet. It’s so easy for them to make up anything.

[TheNiceOne_]

The only thing that made me an apostate at 15 years old were the Hadith and Muslims themselves.

Now, I am relearning Islam again and would consider myself a Hadith sceptic and non sectarian. Alhamdullilah

[rakeshbai]

I am so glad I found this channel. It’s this kind of intellectual pursuit that strengthens my Iman and keeps me committed to the deen. Thank you. Please keep it going brother

[mansurhamidov]

Fun fact: second righteous sunni caliph Umar ibn Al Khattab was Quranist. He punished Abu Hurayra for spreading hadith, he prevented prophet from writing his will by saying: we have Quran and it is enough.