Farm Law Protests - Who is Right? Farmers or Government? 3 Farm Laws Protests and Debate

Hello Everybody, in this Video, I have tried to put explain the major concerns of the farmers and respective government responses. This Video will help you understand the reasons behind bringing the 3 Farm Laws as well as the Reasons behind the ongoing Farm Protest.

Here are some key takeaways:
-The simplest solution against the protest of the farmers with respect to the farm laws can be to include statutory backing to the MSP (Minimum Support Price) and procurement in the new Law to eradicate the fear of the farmers.

- Giving farmers the choice to sell without the help of middlemen will be of great use only if there are roads that link villages to markets, climate-controlled storage facilities, the electricity supply is made reliable and available to power those facilities, and food processing companies who compete to buy their produce.

- Farmers fear that the ordinances will disrupt the mandi system of marketing and also hamper the selling of products at MSP.

- These would serve as an “additional marketing channel” for farmers, even as the APMCs “will continue to function”.

- The freedom of choice to sell outside the regulated mandis should help farmers realize better prices for their produce.

- The ordinance itself does not mention anything, directly or indirectly, to suggest an end or phasing out of MSP-based government procurement.

- No provision enumerated under the new ordinance regarding MSP. Farmers may get a price for their crops below the MSP if selling their produce outside the mandis.

We hope you find this video useful in your various competitive exam preparation! Leave us a comment if you have any doubts or questions. Wishing you ALL THE BEST!

**********************************

[akarsh]

Now this what the national media misses out(unbiased perspective). You are just awesome Priya Mam. Finology is😍😍😊

[bijaypal]

There is a teacher in every class but this teacher has class. Law is simplified by you. I've been watching all your classes. Please take some more classes on commercial laws. Thank you ma'am!

[jay-qtuz]

All the farmers who are doing these protests need to see this video.
very well explained ..!

[ShivamGautam-juwu]

Yes mam that's called spitting facts and am trying to write what I understood after hearing yours and Vikash sir videos,
Clause by clause benefits and harms
1)Farmers produce (Trade and commerce) Act - 1. Freedom of choice of sale and purchase - eg. Outside mandis 2. Barrier free inter and intra state trade 3. No need to pay cess and levies 4. Electronic trading - transparency and tine saving 5. Direct trading at farm gate, cold storage, processing units etc 6. Elimination of middlemen 7. Clarification by Govt - MSP system and Mandis will continue
Issues - 1. Farmers might not get adequate demand for their produce at MSP in local mandi 2. They don't have resources to transport produce over large distances 3. Distress sale of products at lower price at local mandi Farmers
2)(empowerment and protection) agreement on price assistance and farm services act - 1. Enable contract farming - eg. E choupal 2. Price assurance even before sowing 3. If higher MP, entitled to it than one in contract 4. Transfer risk of market unpredictability - due to prior price determination 5. Access to modern technology, better seeds and inputs - due to Investment by private companies 6. Reduced cost of marketing - due to assured sale 7. Effective dispute resolution - with clear time of redressal 8. Impetus to R&D in agri sector 9. Clarification - - farmer will have full power in the contract to fix SP - empowering the farmers - FPOs will help - local DSR and no need to go to court Issues - 1. Farmers not empowered or educated to negotiate with corporate sector 2. Inputs like seeds, fertiliser etc might come under corporate hegemony 3. Corporarisation might bring uniformity - ruining the diversity of agro practices in different parts 4. Exploration of farmers 5. Economy of scale is required - but 85% farmers are S&M
3) Essential commodities amendment act, 2020 - 1. Remove commodities like cereals, pulses, oilseeds, onion, potatoes from list of ECs 2. Liberalising the regulatory env - Remove fears of private investors from excess regulation 3. Drive up investment in supply chain - eg. Investment in cold storage - 35-40% wastage due to lack of storage facilities and cost around 35000 cr to farmers 4. In case of emergencies like war, famine, natural calamity, these commodities can be regulated again - thus safeguarding int of consumers
Issues - 1. Might lead to hoarding and black marketing 2. Issues - 1. Unawareness of farmers about their rights - - eg. Shanta kumar committee says only 6% HH get MSP benefits. 2. This leads to non implementation of schemes - 10281 suicides in 2019 in India despite Various Govt reforms
Farmers given choice to sell directly outside mandis - might harm their interests as they are not educated how to protect their interests 4. Might lead to exploitation by rich businesses and debt trap - as the businesses will be their mai baap 5. Commodificaton of agriculture - might lead to food insecurity 6. Previous steps - APLM Act - more than 15 States adopted it's provisions to give farmers choice of sale outside Mandis but not many farmers reaped it's benefits Swaminathan committee - MSP should be C2 + 50% but not implemented correctly Santha Kumar committee - only 6% farmer HH get benefit of MSP More than 65% paddy and wheat growers don't know about Govt procuring grains 2019 - Maha 3927 suicides - highest in country despite loan waivers and reforms India - 10281 suicides - 28 suicides a day. So, practical implementation is the key.
Reform is the crying need of time with slight changes which govt is also trying to modify but rejecting the bill is going to push farmers in same gutterwhere we will say ki lays to 10 me 2 aloo deta hai aur bechare kisaan 1 kilo ke 5 ka benefit hota hai. Peace ❤️

[gopinathmanjhi]

आपने तो पूरा concept समझा दिया।वो भी बहुत कम समय में।👌
Thanku Ma'am 🙏

[TheB]

News media should be explaining like this instead of re-iterating the statements again and again. Speech without content would just assist in fuelling the anti-centre narratives. Well explained Madam. Very informative, clear and on mark.

[vijaygautam]

By reading comments i came to a conclusion ...हम वही सुनते है जो हमें सुनना अच्छा लगता है.

[ManjeetSingh-qlrj]

All farmers should be understand this law and govt should be ammendment in this laws

[aradhanasingh]

Thank you Ma'am for always making the topic so simple! 💖

[sanskritidhoot]

Damn damn.. it gave me a Crystal clear vision over what's going on.. Indian Media, the tweet fests going on and with everything else it all seemed so vague.. thank you for this video. ✨

[kumargk]

Country cannot run without reforms.... JaiHind

[vikasagarwal]

mam mein bahut se channels ko subscribe kiya hua hai.aise hi informative solutions ke liye.if im writing better word.
par sach mein aapke 2 videos dekhe.
aap bahut achha samjhati ho.
aapki jo bhi edu.hai par aapka vocab/expln excellence.impleccable
jo ek exp. prof.ko suggest karta hai.
aapko dekhke aisa lagta hai.aap khud student ho.
par fir se.
you deserve 💯👍🙏👌👏.
your parents must be honoured.salute.


.

[vineetmishra]

Earlier I was very perplexed about this law...Why there is tussle between Govt and Farmers ? Why farmers are protesting and Why Govt is not revoking this law. But Now I'm happy that all my doubts cleared through your lecture 🙏😊. Really It helped me to understand the crux of the matter 🙏. You r such a outstanding teacher. 🙏❤️

[alokranjan]

At 10:15, Mukesh Ambani be like pta nhi hamesha har dispute me mai kaise aage aa jata hoon 😂🤣🤣

[AkashBharadwaj]

These laws are extremely beneficiary to the farmers if utilised properly and also gives way to huge food processing Industrial infrastructure and employment that provides a exceptional growth in the primary sector which is lacking

[Noturtype-og]

My favorite channel for current updates.
Thanks FINOLOGY LEGAL❤

[naquijilani]

Now I can debate with my friends about the farm bills... Nice analysis.. Thank u mam

[studypoint]

Very true...thus we conclude that these farms law will improve the life of farmers and their income as they won't have to pay any extra tax and money to middle men..and chances of hypothetical risk being promoted by opposition is very less as compared to benefits...

[himadriroutray]

1. New market is already there and why an enactment is needed additionally to avail that.
2. Contract Farming is possible without any acts then why to bring this new regulatory act which looks more beneficial to the affluent contract farmer (Farming Companies).
3. Delisting these from essential commodities will lead to hoarding and market monopoly. This ethically against Competition Act.

[nilotpalsaikia]

Very important video... this will help those people who misunderstood these laws... and without knowing anything only protest against the laws