Understanding Timer.publish() in SwiftUI Navigation: A Guide to Avoiding Navigation Stack Issues

---

If anything seems off to you, please feel free to write me at vlogize [AT] gmail [DOT] com.
---

Navigating through the intricate world of SwiftUI can often come with its share of surprises—especially for beginners. A common issue faced is when incorporating timers into views, which can lead to unexpected jumps back up the navigation stack. Let's explore a specific scenario related to this, dig into the reasons behind it, and outline best practices for handling timers in SwiftUI.

The Problem: Timer Causing Navigation Issues

Scenario: While implementing a three-level navigation structure using NavigationView and NavigationLink, a user encountered an issue. When they introduced a timer in the second-level view, they discovered that navigation would revert to the second level as soon as they started typing in the text field located in the third level.

This unexpected behavior raised a couple of questions: Why does this happen, and how can it be resolved?

Understanding SwiftUI's Navigation and State Handling

To comprehend the situation thoroughly, it's essential to have a grasp on how SwiftUI manages state and UI updates:

State Updates: When you modify a -Published property in an ObservableObject, any view that uses this object will observe the change and re-render its body.

Nav Stack and Rendering: In SwiftUI, the navigation stack is sensitive to changes in state. Any change might cause views higher up the hierarchy to be recreated, possibly leading to unintended navigation behavior.

Key Observations

Using -StateObject in the root view can lead to unnecessary UI re-renders across the entire view hierarchy. Every time a button or text field modifies the state, the complete UI structure could rebuild.

Implementing a Timer in the view builder is not considered optimal due to its unmanaged nature, leading to ambiguous behavior during the state's update process.

The Solution: Best Practices for Handling Timers in SwiftUI

Having identified the underlying issues, let's discuss how to properly utilize timers in SwiftUI without disrupting the navigation stack:

Phase 1: Avoid Placing Timers in View Builders

Don't Create Timers in the View Builder: This can lead to the timer being triggered upon each state change, causing the entire view to be reconstructed unexpectedly.

Phase 2: Move Timer Setup to Lifecycle Methods

Use .onAppear and .onDisappear:

Start Timer in .onAppear: This ensures the timer is only set when the view is being displayed.

Cancel Timer in .onDisappear: This helps avoid any lingering timers which could trigger unintended behaviors later.

Example:

[[See Video to Reveal this Text or Code Snippet]]

Phase 3: Use Task Handlers for Non-blocking Operations

Leverage .task Modifier: This modifier provides a scope for asynchronous tasks, which can be a cleaner alternative for managing timers when needing more control.

Best Practices Summary

Avoid -StateObject at the root level for complex objects.

Declare only simple types or wrapped state within the view struct.

Focus functional logic in lifecycle methods or task handlers, not inside the body.

Conclusion