200 Clones vs 200 Stormtroopers Who Wins?

The Clone Troopers are supposed to be the premiere infantry fighting force in the Star Wars galaxy, the Stormtrooper Corp was designed to replace them. The question is who would win in a head company sized battle?

Follow our Host
ALLEN XIE
INSTAGRAM AXIEFILMS
TIKTOK AXIEFILMS

[Forcer]

200 clones vs 200 Stormtroopers, you’re just asking for stormtroopers to get massacred like the Genosians

[MurasakiTsukimaru]

"Who would win? Btw, I gave one side a FUCKING STAR DESTROYER SO THEY CAN CALL DOWN ORBITAL BOMBARDMENTS." You really out here going "Could I beat a bear in a fight... if I also had an Abrams?"

[jblockminermc]

The question: ‘200 CLONES VS 200 STORM TROOPERS’

Gen tech: “..well if we give the 200 storm troopers a ISD and all its 30k+ personnel..”

[Walpurgis]

Counting the Jedi is unfair but it's OK to count orbital bombardment from ISDs? Huh? And no Venators to counter the ISDs?

[isaackim]

“In my book, experience outranks everything.”
-CT-7567

[charliebaumann]

I don’t know Allen… I feel like it is a little unfair to give the Storm troopers Star Destroyer bombardment because that is assuming that the Star destroyers somehow beat back Venators loaded with experienced clone fighter pilots against tie fighters. Hmmm, maybe that’s your next video? 5 Imperial Star Destroyers vs 5 Republic Venators? (Or something similar)

[reginaldshort]

200 stormtroopers vs 20 clone troopers while 180 cts stand off to the side laughing at the storm troopers armor and how small their blasters are

[dvaltmeme]

Half the points revolved around the empire having orbital superiority while a 200 vs 200 wouldn't have a single star destroyer or large ship

[woodward]

Including a star destroyer is like giving the storm troopers a nuke to use in case they lose

[rapson]

You're comparing some fanatics with 2 years of academy
vs
LITERALLY BEING BORN INTO A TRAINING FACILITY. 9 years of living and breathing inside of military training facility and constant war simulations as well as 4 years of constant, unending WAR

[LonmaHasan]

Allen, you said Clones vs. Stormtroopers. You didn't say anything about the Navy working with them in your poll.

Remove the ISD and the Y-wings from this equation and the only question left to answer is how long it takes the clones to figure out a way to deal with AT-ATs.

[thedoctordallin]

Don't forget the Clones' special perk that gives them an edge: they're all New Zealanders

[_spooT]

Brother, it's basically saying 200 SWAT vs. 200 Civilians, or no, 200 Marines vs. 200 Cops. While the latter may stand a chance, there's an even higher chance they would get massacred

[KhalilGray-lung]

Let’s be honest the clones would mop the floor with the stormtroopers

[awesomesauceum]

Tell me you want the stormtroopers to win without telling me you want the stormtroopers to win.

[warhammer]

If the clones could call for a Venetor, then the sheer number of fighters deployed from the Venetor could neutralize that ISD...

[LTD-Limited]

Stuck in bed with food poisoning and what comes up, Allen, slightly brightened my day looking forward to the video to take my mind of throwing up 😂

[WeaponizedAutism]

The fact the answer is so obvious makes me think he’s realized something I haven’t lol

[josephbotswana]

Last time I was this early alderaan hadn’t suffered a horrific mining incident

[SplashOfOrange]

The question though, and video title is 200 v 200, which nullifies almost all of the Imperial advantages. So "as worded" I'd pick the clones 9 out 10 battles. But if it was the GAR vs the Imperial Navy then yeah, that'd be a tougher call and would be situationally dependent.