Why I BOUGHT The Tudor Black Bay 58 Over The 54!

Today I sit down with Drew to discuss why He bought the Tudor Black Bay 58 over the brand new Tudor Black Bay 54. Enjoy!

Chisholm Hunter is Scotland's largest Luxury Watch retailer and one of the largest in the UK with over 29 stores throughout the United Kingdom. With brands such as Omega, Breguet, Vacheron Constantin, Longines, Tudor, Zenith, Blancpain and many more. Multiple Jeweller of the Year - Three years running.

#luxurywatches #tudor #watchcollector
Tudor
Black Bay 58
Black Bay 54
Luxury Watches

[FrankieTech]

Having owned both, I can say the Black Bay 54 is the superior product. Slimmer case, coin edge bezel, t-fit clasp, lollipop second hand, true vintage style. This watch goes full force on the ethos of what black bay wanted to be from the first release in 2012. I loved the 58, but it didn’t speak to me the way the 54 has. It is absolutely PERFECT. And this coming from a guy with a 7 inch wrist. Don’t let this video change your opinion, Black Bay 54 is the BEST Tudor release of the last 10 years. Hands down! 🙌

[marcusedcofficial]

I basically want the dial & bezel of the 58 with the case & bracelet from the 54

[u.u.u]

I have an 8.25in wrist. I'll passed on both and got the 41mm burgundy. That's the show stopper for me.

[simonwright]

Both great watches, trying them on is key. I have had the 58 for 3 years now and it remains to be my favourite in a large collection.

[tonymontana]

Picked up my 54 this weekend after really considering the 58.

End of the day, buy the watch that suits your tastes.

[ianjones]

I bought 58 I liked the 54 but I ❤ the vintage look and red triangle and 39mm is perfect size for me.

[EvanderHolyfieldsLeftEar]

I got the 54 for my birthday last month, and I am absolutely in love with this watch. I have relatively thin wrists and it wears like a dream.

And to be honest, I love the subtle elegance of the watch. The lack of minute indicies on the bezel, and the red triangle at 12 o'clock make it more discreet, and for a daily driver that's what I want.

[tonyboswell]

The Steel Reef on the fly extender for the BB58 has been a game changer regarding comfort

[wittycheetah]

That's the amazing thing with Tudor, you have so many options to choose from and most of them are amazing. I also chose the BB58 over the 54, as I thought it had more character. The fit of the 54 was amazing, but I also thought it was a little bit too small and the dial felt a little too crowded compared to the 58. Amazing watch nonetheless!

[michaelriera]

Wow!! An actual alternative view point. I really appreciate you not echoing the view point of other YouTube reviewers. The 58 is very special with its warm charm coming from the gilt bezel. I also love the elegant and refined matching coin edge bezel that matches the crown. It has a nice pop of color from the red Triangle that is also found on the classic Rolex Big Crown and it borrows design cues from Rolex/Tudors of past without being an exact replica. Also, at 39mm it sits comfortably on most wrists.

[comeonman]

I absolutely love the black bay series but I prefer the 58. Absolutely perfect on my small wrists.

[MikeOBrien]

Yup, totally agree on the 58, no question whatsoever.

[richardsims]

Had the 58 since release and ordered nato later.Have just put it on for the summer having bought fancy tweezers.The tight silk weave and hardware gives it a whole new look and feel.None of the releases since the OG have sent me hotfoot to the AD but at least they are putting out pieces that can actually be bought.

[jermainewilliams]

As the owner of both…the BB54 is more sophisticated, classy and technically superior! Ultimately though it is down you. I am also 6”2 with 7 inch wrist, yet the 54 still looks proportionate on the wrist. If you can get your hands on a 54, go for it!!!

[harrychefitz]

I picked the new red bezel Black Bay with jubilee bracelet over the 54. I tried them both on, side by side, and the 41mm was just nicer looking, and fit nicely with the jubilee. I went in wanting the 54 and left with the 41mm.

[elwynll]

I got the 58 a few months before the 54 came out. At first I was spewing I didn't wait, until I went to see it in person. Reasons why I prefer the 58 over the 54: Gold bezel numbers matches the gold dial, red triangle, the seconds hand matches the hour (snowflake).
I also don't like how the 54 has a lollipop yet still a snowflake hour, the missing 15minute markeres from 0-15, I also don't like the shiney dial as oppose to the matte of the 58. The only thing I prefer the 54 over the 58 is the clasp.

[greatonreviews]

I recently got the Black Bay 58 GMT and absolutely love it, but after watching this video, I’m also really tempted to get the Black Bay 54, haha! I’m drawn to its simple aesthetics and the lollipop second hand. 🥰🥰

[relosapulso]

I have sold my bb54 after 3months of owning it and bought the bb58 blue. And now i am pleased, didn't looked back

[Klavaturdeswahnsinns]

I get the Point With the Charakter.
I own the 58 Bronze, and ordered the 54, its such a perfect watch.
Fell in Love right away. Both Sites fit very good for me but the 54 ticked all the Boxes for a Clean black diver

[derekbrettell]

For me the 58 is a no brainer. The 54 loses some of the charm that the 58 has and it only really works for people with smaller wrists. I think the 58 works for most wrists