Minecraft: Bedrock Edition is Garbage, Here's Why – Rero

While I love Minecraft, I find it a shame that Bedrock Edition is inferior to Java Edition in practically every conceivable way. So... I made this video about it.

#Minecraft #Mojang

[Rero]

Hi all, I figured I’d make this comment to address the continued criticisms I get for this video.

First of all, obviously it is my mistake that I did not know you could disable GUI animations in settings.

Secondly, I have some people assuming Bedrock runs poorly because I have a bad PC. In reality, I have an RTX 2060 graphics card, and the supposed “worse-running” version of Minecraft (Java) runs at a consistent ~150fps, while Bedrock struggles to keep a consistent 30fps. Anyone assuming that it was simply my PC holding me back is just wrong.

As for the invisible zombie glitches, just because you’ve never experienced them doesn’t mean they aren’t real. This shouldn’t have to be said.

Input lag is a genuine issue across every version of Bedrock that I’ve played (this also includes console and mobile).

Anyone even trying to defend the micro-transactions kind of baffles me. Enough said.

Nonetheless, I mean no animosity toward these criticisms I’ve gotten. If you enjoy Bedrock, of course continue to do so.

[festering]

Better Together was a great idea, but in practice it ruined all the streamlined things that the individual versions had developed specifically for their platforms. Years of development to make Minecraft as intuitive and quick as possible on their specific platforms were thrown out in favor of what was essentially the mobile version being put on consoles and computers so they could play together. In the end, the trade-off doesn't feel worth it. At least not to me.

[etruscanetwork]

To be fair the only reason why a lot of people play bedrock is because they don't have a pc, because if they had a pc the java version would be way more played

[realPurpleOrb]

It's pretty funny how literally every single console edition (3ds doesn't count, it's closer to bedrock) is better put together than bedrock will ever be.

[JustAnotherYouTubeCommenter]

for most of the history of the 2 editions, Java's performance has been ABYSMAL. Unfortunately, 1.18 was the update that totally ruined Bedrock's performance.

[F_Star]

I used to really like Minecraft on legacy edition, and then they presented bedrock edition to console players, now the game isn’t fair anymore if you’re a controller player. If you really liked playing mini games, but lost legacy edition and can’t get it back, then you have to suffer playing on servers like hive and cubecraft. I want to get better at pvp, but that’s impossible because I’m a controller player, and controller players get treated dirty while keyboard and mouse players are superior. I also kinda find it stupid as hell that we have to buy a skin rather then create one, you used to be able to do this on console but they removed it unfortunately. You can still import skins on mcpe, but it won’t transfer to your console account. One day I hope to get Java edition so I can just have fun, and be on the same level as everyone else and not be at rock bottom as a controller player.

[LOL-gnoh]

Bedrock reeks of modern gaming controlled by dirty corporatism.
Java reminds me of the good old days when indie games had freedom.

[thetheater]

Opening menu makes lag, opening inventory drops frame aswell, sometimes when you sprint it randomly stops sprinting and sprint again 20 times in a row in 1 second, mob spawning in huge hordes everywhere, trash textures and pixel and bad light and shadows, crossbow wont charge sometimes, when you eat it doesn't regen the hp and you get 0 saturation, when you load the world your vharacter and all the entities spawns before the world entirely generates so you can literally die before you can even see it coming. What else? Cheaters everywhere because you have apps from the mobile version to cheat even on public servers realms included (zero anti cheat), lag and bad optimization on everything. The cursor gets stuck between slots because there is some weird and clunky attraction that doesn't allow to move smooth in the inventory without the cursor being slowed a lot, also if you try to go fast it teleports in a random slot for no reason making it even worse. The crafting inventory is laggy too. Loading every fucking entity in the game makes the frame drops even if you set the render distance to 4 chunks and all the settings to the lowest possible. I don't know i could go on like forever

[nosebleedd]

Minecraft bedrock happened because kids of minecraft console edition were asking for infinite worlds and minigames. They could of done better with bedrock and optimized it more, they basically just ported mcpe to console and pc

[RedX]

As a Minecraft bedrock player I’m not here to argue but I’m curious to know what device you used for your vid because yeah I confirm switch bedrock sucks but these things aren’t universal…… well except the marketplace that is universal

[PikaTyIer]

ive thought this stuff for a long time, bedrock has some things that it does better than java but if you ask me the good does not outweigh the bad, i only really use bedrock to play with friends cuz none of us know how to port forward/care enough to figure it out. great video rero

[CountDookles]

I don't like how cheap Bedrock looks. Java and Console edition look more solid than it.

[AidenLampitt]

this video was like 6 years in the making and it hit like crazy

[InaneBlatherskite]

Being a long time Bedrock and Java player, I gotta say. That performance seems like a you only thing. Not the menus, god those are annoying but your footage lagged more than half the time, that never happens to me and a lot of others. What happened 💀

[azuretheharmony]

As someone who plays both versions of MC, I agree with this video. Bedrock edition feels like a mobile game on pc (since bedrock is based off of pocket edition). Playing on consoles and phones feels just fine but the game itself has tons of issues. Managing villager housing and workstations is so much better in Java than it is in bedrock. I have to destroy my friend's property on his realm just so I can rotate my librarian trades and have them assign themselves to the beds in MY base. Java edition will always be my go-to.

[NeonliteMC]

this man's computer hates bedrock edition more than he does, majority of the bugs don't actually happen as often as it feels it does primarly due to the memes surrounding them (prompting people to fake). I also would like to point out that importing 2d custom skins is literally 2-clicks while you make it sound like it's a full blown process: it is not.

anyways, what I wanted to say is that you mention Bedrock remaining in Java shadow in a way that it will never reach the same level as java but frakly everthing im modern Minecraft progress seems to be indicating the opposite, for one, there is no feature in java edition that it pchsically immposible to add to bedrock and seeing as mojang is striving towards parity in the past few years I doubt bedrock will remain irelevant tothe minecraft brand. I also noticed that majority of the "parity changes" always derive off of java and alter the way things were before on bedrock, following this train of logic it would be innevatble that bedrock would outplay java for its forever exclusive features that javascript simply does not support, like RTX or crossplay (to an extent).

I don't want to degrade your video a you make some very valuable points but being primarly a bedrock player I find that too often Java youtubers will play bedrock editiion and repeat its most common flaws in a video but usually don't play enough to find the upsides. not ot mention the initial bias that most people take with them into their first experience of the game forces them to notice the slightest isusse that usually inthemselves not even bugs or shortcomings.

:)

[_YashSawant]

2:10 Legacy Console was easily the worst version of Minecraft, you hate Bedrock because it still exists you love Legacy Console because its gone and the Nostalgia is what making you love it, we dont value something until its gone forever and that's the case with you

[tim]

Even tho i prefer java i still think that bedrock has something that i think the java versions NEEDS and it's the friend system that let's you make multiplayer worlds with your friends or invite them to your singleplayer one

[Austin-qvzb]

ngl, mentioning about the marketplace wasn't necessary, as i don't think anyone would be dumb enough to buy anything there

[axolotl]

90% of issues come from phone I think
they didn't update combat with 1.9 so mobile players could actually fight well, but they used a janky system that doesn't quite feel like 1.8 java when on pc they also let mobile players hit people to their side because you hit whatever you click on mobile
the inventory management sucks because you can't press numbers to put items in that slot, that would be unfair to console and mobile so you move items with your cursor 1 by 1 instead of just pressing the button you want it to go to

anyway hope this comment helps you in the algorithm, bye