Which FNAF is Scariest? (Ranking EVERY Five Nights at Freddy's)

There have been 8 mainline Five Nights at Freddy's games - FNAF, FNAF 2, FNAF 3, FNAF 4, FNAF Sister Location, Freddy Fazbear's Pizzeria Simulator, Ultimate Custom Night and FNAF Help Wanted. But out of all of these games which is the scariest Five Nights at Freddy's of all and why? In this video we take an in-depth look at each of the eight FNAF games from Scott Cawthon to figure out which is the least scary and which is the creepiest FNAF of all time. So sit back, relax and lets dive in to this complete run down of the top scariest Five Nights at Freddy's games and why...

You've been watching SuperHorrorBro Mike and this was a look at ranking every Five Nights at Freddy's game to see which is scariest. If you enjoyed this video remember to like, comment and subscribe for more horror related content.

Music by Kevin MacLeod

[wzjhrhz]

I feel like Sister Location is one of the scariest.
Having to move around
*Disgustang*

[tonchi]

He ranked FNAF SL at the bottom of the list. Let’s fix that with a controlled shock

[iam.]

“Sister Location is mostly filled with Dorky Humour”

*sees two guys hanging themselves*

[superbarton]

I was playing fnaf 1 in front of my dad once, and he actually brought up a pretty good point, he said "Why do they need a security guard when you have 4 killer robots in the place that will mangle anyone that comes in there?"

[emidwd]

Fnaf SL: *lowest on scary*

The scene where ballora dances right in front of you: *Am I a joke to you?*

[livishowshow]

I’m sorry but I honestly think crawling through Ballora’s vent in Sister Location will go on my list as one of the scariest moments ever in FNaF

[whorememberszestymango]

fun fact:
circus baby is over *7 feet tall*

[skateboardinguitaris]

In terms of jumpscares, FNAF 4 and VR are unbeatable. But overall, none of them gave me more fear than the first one. It just felt so realistic, and since it was the first impression, no other game can really give me that same initial feeling of panic

[fs.kbe]

Remember when people thought that Fnaf 4 was free roam

[Obi-WanGaming]

"and the creepy way springtrap watches us"
*shows a picture of springtrap staring into space*

[zamasu]

Lets all be honest, If we were in that situation all of them would be terrifying

[Warzulu]

For me, I’ve always and to this day found FNAF 3 just so scary. I still can’t work out why it haunted my dreams as a kid and still sends chills down the back of my spine. I’m not exaggerating when I say that some of the jumpscares almost gave me a heart attack. There are so many aspects in the game that are just simply terrifying; Springtrap constantly moving locations, Phantom Foxy’s abrupt and sudden tendency to appear, the way in which Phantom Freddy limps across the window, Ballon Boy’s menacing, unnaturally wide smile before jumping at you.

It’s all just so horrible.

[emma_]

I don’t think SL feels “far less challenging than the other entries.” Every night was very different and had something new to get used to. Not to mention, if you have ever actually played this game, night 4 (when the mini reenas are crawling into spring suit) was by far the most difficult challenge I have encountered in the entire FNAF series. I agree it’s not number one on the list scary wise, but I think it definitely deserves more recognition for its unique and difficult challenges. Just my opinion! :D

[abeanwithintentions]

the main emotions i felt while playing/watching other people play each game

fnaf: anxious
fnaf 2: frustrated
fnaf 3: a n g e r e d
fnaf 4: *absolutely terrified*
fnaf sl: confused
fnaf ps: calm when playing without risk, panicked when playing with risk
fnaf ucn: stressed
fnaf vr: _disturbed_

[hamzaaslam]

Springtrap staring at you is scarier than his jumpscare.

[yderga]

The 3rd game was always the scariest to me, specifically because springtrap felt less like a robot and more like a sociopath murderer with OCD. Theres no doors to lock him out, only distractions from keeping him away.

The more you look into the games story and find out its actually a child murderer piloting a robotic suit thats only distracted by the sound of children laughing is bone chilling.

[Jose-quqk]

I love how you brought up Pizzeria Simulator's backstory as a reason for why it's scary yet completely brush off Sister Location's story entirely LOL

[TobyTarpey]

Don’t worry we all know you didn’t add fnaf world because it’s too scary to comprehend

[yourlocalbeeswarm]

i think the scariest is fnaf world, i peed myself at least 12 times throughout the terrifying journey.

[darienb]

Help Wanted is genuinely one of the most terrifying horror games I have seen. All of the other FNAF games felt like they had their atmosphere and story, but relied too much on jumpscares. Help Wanted still leans into those jumpscares, but with it being VR... The atmosphere is otherworldy. I love the fact that it's basically a remake of older games. Actually seeing the animatronics walk down the hallway to you is a whole new level of fuckery the first time you see it.