House Impeachment Inquiry Hearing – Feldman, Karlan, Gerhardt & Turley Testimony

[TheRealMake-Make]

*December 4, 2019*
37:28 Order-ish
38:31 *Rep. Jerrold Nadler (D-NY)* - Rules
39:14 Rep. Nadler, Opening statement
49:30 *Rep. Doug Collins (R-GA)* - Opening statement
1:04:37 Rep. Nadler, intro to the witnesses
1:07:17 Rep. Nadler, swearing in
1:09:00 *Noah Feldman, Harvard Law School* Opening statement
1:21:32 *Pamela Karlan, Stanford Law Professor* Opening statement
1:30:34 *Michael Gerhardt, Univ. of North Carolina Law Professor* Opening statement
1:41:10 *Jonathan Turley, George Washington Univ. Law Professor* Opening statement
1:54:08 *Rep. Nadler* first round of questions (1:54:52, Prof. Karlan)(1:55:34, Prof. Gerhardt)(1:56:38, Prof. Feldman)
1:57:54 *Norman Eisen, Democratic Counsel* (1:58:16, Feldman)(1:59:12, Karlan)(1:59:22, Gerhardt)(1:59:46, Feldman, 2:00:03, Karlan, 2:00:08, Gerhardt)(2:00:36, Feldman)(2:02:34, Karlan)(2:05:03, Gerhardt)(2:05:30, Prof. Turley)(2:06:07, Feldman, Karlan, Gerhardt)(2:06:26, Feldman)(2:06:55, Karlan)(2:12:52, Feldman)(2:15:28, Gerhardt)(2:16:13, Karlan)(2:16:53, Feldman, Gerhardt)(2:17:03, Karlan)(2:23:44, Feldman, 2:24:37, Gerhardt)(2:25:46, All Profs. 2:26:12, Feldman. 2:26:53, Karlan. 2:28:28, Gerhardt.)(2:29:57, Gerhardt. 2:30:40, Karlan.)(2:31:03, Feldman. 2:32:19, Pres. Trump. 2:32:37, Gerhardt.)(2:33:42, Gerhardt)(2:35:56, Karlan)(2:37:54, Feldman)
2:39:21 “Humanitarian Recess”
2:59:40 Order
2:59:57 *Rep. Doug Collins (R-GA)* First round of questions.(3:02:57, Turley)(3:16:54, Turley)(3:17:07, Turley)(3:18:20, Turley)(3:19:23, Collins)(3:20:42, Turley)(3:21:37, Collins)(3:22:12, Turley)(3:23:25, Collins)
3:25:25 *Paul Taylor, Republican Counsel*
(3:26:20, Turley)(3:28:09, Taylor)(3:29:50, Turley)(3:32:26, Taylor)(3:33:19, Turley)(3:34:21, Turley)(3:35:15, Taylor)(3:36:41, Turley)(3:37:14, Taylor)(3:39:50, Turley)(3:40:45, Taylor)(3:41:14, Turley)(3:41:39, Turley)(3:42:48, Turley)(3:43:30, Taylor)(3:43:59, Turley)
3:45:24 White House, invitation declined.
3:45:37 *Rep. Nadler* (3:45:43, Feldman)(3:46:47, Feldman)(3:47:08, Gerhardt)(3:48:06, Gerhardt, 3:48:55, Karlan)(3:49:52, Feldman)
3:50:41 *Rep. Collins* (3:51:27, Turley)(3:54:11, Collins)
3:55:45 *Rep. Zoe Lofgren (D-CA)* (3:57:52, Karlan)(3:58:39, Gerhardt)(3:59:31, Lofgren)(3:59:57, Feldman)(4:00:24, Lofgren)
4:00:50 Recess. (4:05:01, Democratic representatives. 4:16:53, call-ins. 4:24:18, Pres. Trump. 4:34:21, call-ins.)
5:14:27 Order.
5:14:54 *Rep. James Sensenbrenner (R-WI)* (5:19:03, Turley)
5:20:11 *Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee (D-TX)* (5:20:59, Karlan)(5:21:50, Karlan: Statement regarding Barron)(5:22:40, Feldman)(5:23:16, Karlan)(5:23:30, Col. Vindman)(5:23:58, Feldman)(5:24:27, Jackson Lee)
5:25:17 *Rep. Steve Chabot (R-OH)*
5:30:23 *Rep. Steve Cohen (D-TN)* (5:31:23, Feldman)(5:32:28, Karlan, Feldman, Gerhardt)(5:32:47, Feldman, Gerhardt)(5:33:01, Karlan. 5:33:41, Feldman. 5:34:03, Gerhardt.)(5:34:44, Turley)
5:35:33 *Rep. Louie Gohmert (R-TX)*
5:40:42 *Rep. Hank Johnson (D-GA)* (5:40:51, Karlan)(5:41:19, Karlan)(5:41:44, Feldman)(5:42:46, Feldman)(5:43:49, Feldman)(5:44:51, Karlan)(5:45:29, Johnson)
5:45:49 *Rep. Jim Jordan (R-OH)*
5:50:34 *Rep. Ted Deutch (D-FL)* (5:51:37, Feldman)(5:52:10, Gerhardt)(5:52:36, Karlan)(5:53:14, Karlan)(5:54:00, Deutch)
5:55:32 *Rep. Ken Buck (R-CO)* (5:55:39, Turley)
6:00:41 *Rep. Karen Bass (D-CA)* (6:00:58, Gerhardt)(6:02:10, Holmes)(6:02:31, Feldman)(6:03:01, Karlan)(6:03:39, Bass)
6:05:15 *Rep. John Ratcliffe (R-TX)* (6:07:09, Turley)(6:07:24, Turley)(6:08:01, Turley)(6:08:21, Turley)(6:10:09, Turley)
6:10:23 *Rep. Cedric Richmond (D-LA)* (6:12:03, Williams, Sondland, Morrison, Taylor flashback footage) (6:12:37, Feldman)(6:13:09, Karlan)(6:14:01, Feldman. 6:14:23, Karlan. 6:14:44, Gerhardt)(6:15:04, Richmond)
6:15:30 *Rep. Martha Roby (R-AL)* (6:15:30, Turley) (6:16:08, Roby)
6:20:33 *Rep. Hakeem Jeffries (D-NY)* (6:21:17, Karlan)(6:21:52, Karlan)(6:22:26, Karlan)(6:22:35, Karlan)(6:22:43, Karlan)(6:22:52, Karlan)(6:23:09, Jeffries)(6:23:44, Taylor flashback)(6:24:08, Karlan)(6:24:31, Karlan)(6:24:43, Jeffries)
6:25:38 *Rep. Matt Gaetz (R-FL)* (6:26:11, Gerhardt)(6:26:53, Feldman)(6:27:33, Feldman)(6:27:41, Feldman)(6:28:04, Karlan)(6:28:29, Karlan)(6:28:41, Karlan)(6:28:58, Karlan)(6:29:19, Gaetz)(6:30:00, all witnesses)
6:31:04 *Rep. David Cicilline (D-RI)* (6:31:04, Feldman)(6:31:38, Gerhardt)(6:32:08, Karlan)(6:33:04, Feldman)(6:33:54, Cicilline)(6:35:07, Feldman. 6:35:49, Karlan)
6:36:16 *Rep. Mike Johnson (R-LA)*
6:41:24 *Rep. Eric Swalwell (D-CA)* (6:41:41, Turley)(6:42:18, Swalwell)(6:43:47, Taylor flashback)(6:44:14, Karlan)(6:44:39, Karlan)(6:45:17, Karlan)(6:46:01, Feldman)
6:46:45 Recess
7:02:51 Order
7:02:58 *Rep. Andy Biggs (R-AZ)*
7:08:22 *Rep. Ted Lieu (D-CA)* (7:09:19, Feldman)(7:10:19, Karlan)(7:11:11, Sondland/Taylor flashbacks)(7:11:47, Sondland flashback)(7:12:12, Karlan)(7:12:44, Lieu)
7:13:27 *Rep. Tom McClintock (R-CA)* (7:14:42, Turley)(7:15:41, Turley)(7:17:01, Turley)(7:17:28, Turley)(7:17:43, Turley)(7:18:14, Turley)
7:19:00 *Rep. Jamie Raskin (D-MD)* (7:19:56, Karlan)(7:20:12, Feldman)(7:20:48, Raskin)(7:21:45, Feldman)(7:22:23, Karlan)(7:23:21, Feldman, Gerhardt, Karlan)(7:23:49, Feldman, Karlan, Gerhardt)
7:24:13 *Rep. Debbie Lesko (R-AZ)*
7:29:26 *Rep. Pramila Jayapal (D-WA)* (7:30:32, Williams flashback)(7:30:44, Karlan)(7:30:51, Karlan)(7:31:12, Karlan)(7:31:59, Karlan)(7:32:15, Karlan)(7:33:04, Karlan)(7:33:49, Karlan)(7:34:11, Jayapal)
7:34:52 *Rep. Guy Reschenthaler (R-PA)* (7:38:50, Turley)
7:40:16 *Rep. Val Demings (D-FL)* (7:42:06, Gerhardt)(7:42:20, Gerhardt)(7:42:55, Gerhardt)(7:43:01, Feldman)(7:43:28, Gerhardt)(7:44:01, Gerhardt)(7:44:29, Demings)
7:45:20 *Rep. Ben Cline (R-VA)*
7:49:51 *Rep. Ratcliffe* (7:49:51, Turley)
7:51:08 *Rep. Lou Correa (D-CA)* (7:51:28, Feldman)(7:51:57, Feldman)(7:52:42, Feldman)(7:53:30, Gerhardt)(7:54:06, Correa)
7:55:54 *Rep. Kelly Armstrong (R-ND)*
7:59:30 *Rep. Jordan* (7:59:30, Karlan)(7:59:35, Jordan)(7:59:56, Karlan)(8:00:04, Jordan)
8:01:02 *Rep. Mary Gay Scanlon (D-PA)* (8:02:42, Gerhardt)(8:03:31, Gerhardt)(8:03:40, Feldman)(8:04:08, Feldman)(8:04:46, Feldman)(8:04:54, Scanlon)
8:07:17 *Rep. Sylvia Garcia (D-TX)* (8:08:51, Gerhardt)(8:09:31, Gerhardt)(8:10:00, Gerhardt)(8:10:21, Garcia)
8:11:45 *Rep. Joe Neguse (D-CO)* (8:14:08, Gerhardt)(8:14:58, Turley)(8:15:14, Turley)(8:15:26, Turley)(8:15:30, Turley)(8:15:39, Turley)(8:15:46, Turley)(8:16:00, Turley)
8:17:02 *Rep. Lucy McBath (D-GA)* (8:17:53, Yovanovitch flashback) (8:18:52, Gerhardt) (8:19:58, McBath)
8:20:49 *Rep. Greg Stanton (D-AZ)* (8:21:46, Gerhardt) (8:22:16, Feldman)(8:23:02, Gerhardt)(8:23:49, Karlin)(8:24:16, Stanton)
8:25:12 *Rep. Greg Steube (R-FL)* (8:28:30, Nadler)
8:28:56 *Rep. Ratcliffe* (8:29:00, Turley)
8:30:18 *Rep. Madeleine Dean (D-PA)* (8:31:45, Karlan)(8:32:17, Feldman)(8:33:17, Gerhardt)(8:34:17, Dean)
8:35:25 *Rep. Debbie Mucarsel-Powell (D-FL)* (8:37:06, Pres. Trump flashback)(8:37:45, Feldman)(8:38:20, Karlan)(8:38:50, Mick Mulvaney flashback)(8:39:19, Karlan)
8:40:28 *Rep. Veronica Escobar (D-TX)* (8:41:34, Feldman)(8:43:00, Pres. Nixon and Pres. Trump flashbacks)(8:43:15, Karlan)(8:43:45, Escobar)
8:45:04 *Rep. Collins* Closing remarks.
8:55:41 *Rep. Nadler* Closing remarks.

*Multimedia Used*
1:59:45 Key Findings of Fact I (Text)
2:01:01 Key Findings of Fact V (Text)
2:01:31 Ambassador Taylor (Video)
2:08:07 Constitution Excerpt (Text)
2:20:20 Ambassador Sondland (Audio/Video)
2:32:19 President Trump (Audio/Video)
5:23:48 Colonel Vindman (Audio/Video)
5:41:59 Quote, Mayor Randolph (Text)
6:02:10 Holmes (Audio/Video)
6:12:03 Multiple Testimonies (Audio/Video)
6:23:44 Ambassador Taylor (Audio/Video)
6:34:05 George Washington (Text)
6:43:02 President Zelensky (Photo)
6:43:46 Ambassador Taylor (Audio/Video)
7:11:11 Amb. Sondland, Taylor (Audio/Video)
7:11:47 Ambassador Sondland (Audio/Video)
7:21:47 ABCs of Impeachment (Text)
7:30:33 Williams testimony (Audio/Video)
7:31:28 Col. Vindman testimony (Text)
7:32:04 Amb. Volker deposition (Text)
7:41:50 “Categorical Blockade” (Image)
7:52:00 Judge Jackson opinion (Text)
8:01:48 Pres. Trump behavior (Image)
8:08:55 Mueller Timeline (Text)
8:09:12 Mueller Timeline (Text)
8:12:33 Attacks on Whistleblower (Text)
8:12:50 Attacks on Witnesses (Text)
8:13:18 Attacks on Witnesses (Text)
8:13:38 Praise for non-cooperation (Text)
8:13:46 Praise for non-cooperation (Text)
8:17:53 Witness intimidation (Audio/Video)
8:18:36 Witness intimidation (Text)
8:37:08 Investigate Bidens (Audio/Video)
8:38:50 “Get over it” (Audio/Video)
8:43:00 Nixon/Trump (Audio/Video)

[brianrich]

This is what we get when we don't vote. What a clown show...

[jikachu]

I admire anyone who took the time to watch this 9 hour video. I salute you

[RodneyCrater]

Good to see a more comprehensive video than all the biasing sound bites on here [youtube] today

[stormfireimastarcitizen]

No political official has the right to as the question that was asked starting at time 7:13: "who did you vote for?"
That question has no bearing on this inquiry and is down right insulting. Some of these political official should be sued for character assassination which is exactly what that GOP person tried to do!

[epikmantherd]

Who the hell downvotes C-SPAN? They are literally as unbiased as possible.

[babablue]

As we watch this old Rudy is on his way to Ukraine.

[BoSSClanQS]

Wow what a circus, just a couple more years till these boomers retire...

[lady]

I watched the entire 9 hours and am watching again using fast forward.

[Sploogee]

Democrats need to be held accountable for all this BS and spending all the moneys of the taxpayers. Vote them all

[computerrockstar]

Me when my mom won't let me have more ice cream:


6:29:52

[Blissiel]

Why did the federalist society remove some of Jonathan Turleys past events from their website?

[doloresmoralescaro]

Why only asked only 3 professors and not the last professor mr that’s not fare

[carolinacoonhunter]

These are the probably the people who threw that man's fish back 😂😂😂😂

[clintmiller]

I can’t wait to see the fisa report on December 9th from AG Barr.

[akmalkortam]

Now it is neither abut republicans nor abut Democrats … it is about values, constitution, laws, people and democracy. Let us see who is who

[matt]

We really just need to get this over with get rid of him the attempt was more than enough it shouldn't even be questionable

[whackbag]

If you need clarification on how things work in that room, then you shouldn't be in that room.

[jamilarice]

Dr. Strange Is testifying. Strange world we live in.

[endlessxaura]

6:29:00 The chairman should have let them answer the questions fully. That got seriously out of hand.