filmov
tv
Bob Dylan's Nobel Prize win stirs controversy among critics
Показать описание
밥 딜런 수상 놓고 SNS 양분 가운데 "노벨문학상 귀로"…밥 딜런 음원•도서 '인기
The world is abuzz with the surprise from Sweden - Bob Dylan winning the Nobel Prize in Literature. It would seem to be the last word in a debate but, it's got many around the world divided on the decision.
Do lyrics like "I was so much older then, I’m younger than that now" and "You don’t need a weatherman to know which way the wind blows" put Bob Dylan on par with William Faulkner, Ernest Hemingway and Toni Morrison?
Here's Lee Jiwon.
Bob Dylan's Nobel prize win has set off a buying frenzy around the world,... causing sales of his books and music to skyrocket.
Not long after Thursday's award announcement, his memoir, "Chronicles: Volume One," shot up 15-thousand-412 places on Amazon's best-seller list... and his hit song "Knockin' on Heaven's Door" jumped up to third on Naver Music's Top 100 Global Pop Songs list.
Over in the States, the unconventional winner -- he's the first songwriter ever to win the literature prize -- has generated a controversy among critics.
Some, like Rob Sheffield of Rolling Stone, have expressed delight at his win,... writing that Dylan "won for inventing ways to make songs do what they hadn't done before."
But not everyone agrees.
Critic Stephen Metcalf of Slate praised Dylan as a genius, but says he does not think that a musician should have been awarded the highest prize in literature.
Metcalf says a literary prize should not go to an economist or a political saint -- and it should not go to Dylan.
The debate played out here in Korea, too, with one critic firmly in the "for" camp.
"I think the academy's tried something very new, which is understanding 'literature' in a wider sense. Currently, the definition of literature is widening, especially with technological advancements and new media. And yesterday's decision shows that the Swedish Academy has and will identify any content that can bring out literary inspiration as literature."
The 75-year-old singer-songwriter was awarded the Nobel Prize for Literature on Thursday.
The Swedish Academy's citation said Dylan deserves the award "for having created new poetic expressions within the great American song tradition."
Lee Ji-won, Arirang News.
Visit ‘Arirang News’ Official Pages
The world is abuzz with the surprise from Sweden - Bob Dylan winning the Nobel Prize in Literature. It would seem to be the last word in a debate but, it's got many around the world divided on the decision.
Do lyrics like "I was so much older then, I’m younger than that now" and "You don’t need a weatherman to know which way the wind blows" put Bob Dylan on par with William Faulkner, Ernest Hemingway and Toni Morrison?
Here's Lee Jiwon.
Bob Dylan's Nobel prize win has set off a buying frenzy around the world,... causing sales of his books and music to skyrocket.
Not long after Thursday's award announcement, his memoir, "Chronicles: Volume One," shot up 15-thousand-412 places on Amazon's best-seller list... and his hit song "Knockin' on Heaven's Door" jumped up to third on Naver Music's Top 100 Global Pop Songs list.
Over in the States, the unconventional winner -- he's the first songwriter ever to win the literature prize -- has generated a controversy among critics.
Some, like Rob Sheffield of Rolling Stone, have expressed delight at his win,... writing that Dylan "won for inventing ways to make songs do what they hadn't done before."
But not everyone agrees.
Critic Stephen Metcalf of Slate praised Dylan as a genius, but says he does not think that a musician should have been awarded the highest prize in literature.
Metcalf says a literary prize should not go to an economist or a political saint -- and it should not go to Dylan.
The debate played out here in Korea, too, with one critic firmly in the "for" camp.
"I think the academy's tried something very new, which is understanding 'literature' in a wider sense. Currently, the definition of literature is widening, especially with technological advancements and new media. And yesterday's decision shows that the Swedish Academy has and will identify any content that can bring out literary inspiration as literature."
The 75-year-old singer-songwriter was awarded the Nobel Prize for Literature on Thursday.
The Swedish Academy's citation said Dylan deserves the award "for having created new poetic expressions within the great American song tradition."
Lee Ji-won, Arirang News.
Visit ‘Arirang News’ Official Pages
0:08:21
Bob Dylan speech at the 2016 Nobel Banquet
0:07:56
Why Bob Dylan Won The Nobel Prize
0:08:23
Patti Smith performs Bob Dylan's 'A Hard Rain's A-Gonna Fall' - Nobel Prize Awar...
0:00:30
Bob Dylan's Nobel Prize announcement
0:02:06
The debate over Bob Dylan's Nobel Prize for literature
0:02:36
Bob Dylan collects Nobel Prize award
0:00:43
Bob Dylan's Nobel Prize Speech Controversy
0:01:08
'Greatest Living Poet' Bob Dylan Awarded Nobel Prize In Literature
0:01:43
Leonard Cohen on Bob Dylan Winning the Nobel Prize in Literature
0:27:08
Bob Dylan 2016 Nobel Lecture in Literature
0:03:42
Nobel Literature Prize: US musician Bob Dylan wins 2016 award, Professor David Vann weighs in
0:01:25
Bob Dylan awarded Nobel Literature Prize
0:00:56
Dylan's Nobel prize is 'no surprise' says expert
0:01:13
Margaret Atwood on Bob Dylan winning Nobel Prize for Literature - BBC Newsnight
0:01:28
Bob Dylan Receives Nobel Prize for Literature
0:01:16
Bob Dylan Wins Nobel Prize in Literature
0:00:53
Bob Dylan wins the Nobel Prize in Literature
0:06:50
Bob Dylan honored with Nobel Prize
0:01:03
People from Bob Dylan's hometown react to his Nobel Prize
0:03:13
'Bob Dylan Is the Shakespeare for Our Time' -Penn Jillette
0:00:30
Announcement of the Nobel Prize in Literature 2016
0:01:59
Bob Dylan wins Nobel Prize in literature
0:02:09
Bob Dylan wins Nobel Literature Prize 2016
0:01:42
Bob Dylan wins Nobel Prize
Комментарии