Spider-Man Actors Ranked!

This video does contain No Way Home Spoilers! No Way Home is DESTROYING box-office records. So today we're going to talk the Spider-Men! I'm going to rank all 3 live-action Spider-man actors from the worst to the best!

Share your ranking in the comments!

Movies to Rank:

Spider-man (2002) - Sam Raimi & Tobey Maguire From Sam Raimi
Spider-Man 2 (2004) - Kirsten Dunst
Spider-man 3 (2007) - Topher Grace
The Amazing Spider-Man (2012) - Emma Stone & Andrew Garfield
The Amazing Spider-Man 2 (2014) - Marc Webb
Spider-Man: Homecoming (2017) - Tom Holland
Spider-man Far From Home - Jon Watts
Spider-Man No Way Home in the MCU

Spider-man Synopsis
"Spider-Man" centers on student Peter Parker (Tobey Maguire) who, after being bitten by a genetically-altered spider, gains superhuman strength and the spider-like ability to cling to any surface. He vows to use his abilities to fight crime, coming to understand the words of his beloved Uncle Ben: "With great power comes great responsibility."

The Amazing Spiderman Synopsis
Abandoned by his parents and raised by an aunt and uncle, teenager Peter Parker (Andrew Garfield), AKA Spider-Man, is trying to sort out who he is and exactly what his feelings are for his first crush, Gwen Stacy (Emma Stone). When Peter finds a mysterious briefcase that was his father's, he pursues a quest to solve his parents' disappearance. His search takes him to Oscorp and the lab of Dr. Curt Connors (Rhys Ifans), setting him on a collision course with Connors' alter ego, the Lizard.

Spiderman Homecoming Synopsis
Thrilled by his experience with the Avengers, young Peter Parker returns home to live with his Aunt May. Under the watchful eye of mentor Tony Stark, Parker starts to embrace his newfound identity as Spider-Man. He also tries to return to his normal daily routine -- distracted by thoughts of proving himself to be more than just a friendly neighborhood superhero. Peter must soon put his powers to the test when the evil Vulture emerges to threaten everything that he holds dear.

FIND ME ONLINE

INSTAGRAM @seantalksabout
TWITTER @kirkneverdied

FIND THE SEAN CHANDLER PODCAST:

My Merch Store

Fan Mail can be sent to:

Sean M. Chandler
PO Box 1042
Hutto, TX 78634

VIDEO SUMMARY
This video contains Sean Chandler Talks About's ranks all 3 spider-man actors. // Spider-men ranked /// Spider-man actors ranked

AFFLIATE DISCLAIMER

I may earn a small commission for my endorsement, recommendation, testimonial, and/or link to any products or services from this video.

[estevanlujan]

Honestly, keeping Andrew still underdeveloped is exciting because we could maybe see his story continue in an alternate universe timeline.

[kdean_art]

Personally I loved the slow burn of Tom’s Spidey. More personal development and allowed me to get invested in not only his world, but his connection to the MCU overall. It was brilliant to give him everything only for it to be taken away (or just given up by him in the end) so that his life can progress. Letting the boy die so the man can live. Brilliant!

[Itsastoryteller]

I personally think Andrew was overall the best character and he stole the show for me in NWH

[designateddriveranddragons]

Garfield absolutely stole every scene he was in in NWH. I’ve been saying it for years, and NWH only solidified it: Garfield deserved and still deserves another movie. I know that won’t happen, but man he absolutely crushed every single thing he did

[charsmith]

In terms of raw pure acting talent it has to easily go to Andrew Garfield, his performance in hacksaw ridge elevated him to goat status. As an upcoming actor, Tom Holland probably has the biggest potential and is incredible in the role of Spider-Man. Tobey, I’m my opinion, has a good performance in some movies and then not so good performances in others (Spider-Man being a mediocre acting performance). Tobey has a brilliant performance in the film brothers but overall I have to give it to Andrew

[parthpanwar]

Just got out of theatre few hours ago, and Andrew Garfield again took the charm here for me.

I hope they make TASM 3

[matthewlean]

Andrew Garfield is the best actor to have played Spiderman. His performances in Silence, Hacksaw Ridge and the Social Network prove that but the writing held him back from being the best Spiderman.

[Cody-E]

I will always love Tobey the most, he definitely is my favorite Peter Parker but I also really like his Spider-Man.

[JoeTufanoTheMovieGuy]

Tobey Maguire will ALWAYS be my Spider-Man!

[UlyssesSGrant-bilf]

I have to rank 'Spider-Man' and 'Peter Parker' separately. Tobey is my favorite Peter Parker, Andrew is my favorite Spider-Man, and Tom is a fair balance of both.

[wyattr.]

I love all three of them basically equally. I think If i had to choose it would be Andrew though. He’s the funniest and most comic accurate. Also I like how they gave him redemption in NWH.
I agree with the incomplete story arc but obviously that isn’t Andrews fault really. They did sort of wrap it up at NWH but still needs some work.

HOPEFULLY SOMEDAY!

Edit:most comic accurate minus the dad part

[vinikyks]

I love all of them
NWH changed my mind about Tom, I really really like him as Spider-Man now, and I can't wait to see more of him)

[Mohammed-gcxt]

Best Spider-Man: Andrew
Best Peter Parker: Tobey
A Perfect Mix Of Both: Tom

In My Opinion

[taylorpack]

1. Tobey maguire: grew up with his movies, he played the perfect nerd but stepped up into a serious hero as well. He did well in emotional scene and his movies seemed to really teach you great life lessons.
2. Andrew Garfield: by far the best actor out of the 3, he showed off the great mix of humor and seriousness, nailed every scene he was in. People complain about his movies but I liked both, only reason I have him at number 2 honestly is because I feel he didn’t get enough time to really show off with only having 2 films.
3. Tom Holland: Tom is a good actor and no way home he finally got to show it but unfortunately, we only see flashes of his real serious side and his movies are way too over the top goofy for me. No way home he nailed every scene he was in but in homecoming and far from home we never got to see him be really serious it’s like the mcu makes everything out to be a comedy.

[Scrummy]

Like Sean said, I absolutely adore all three but if I had to rank them:

3. Maguire - A perfect rendition of Peter Parker in his first two movies, and IMO still the best encapsulation of the "friendly neighbourhood Spider-Man" aspect, but he lacks Spidey's usual wit and just turns into a bit of an arsehole in the third movie (even BEFORE he gets the black suit)

2. Garfield - A consistently brilliant Spidey, and I'll be bold and say I think his portrayal of both sides of the character in TASM2 is the _single_ greatest rendition of Peter Parker / Spider-Man in any movie to date. His only downside is that he's not quite so believable as a dorky, bottom-of-the-food-chain schoolboy in his first movie

1. Holland - As many have said before, he's a great blend of Peter / Spidey in every movie he's in. There were certainly some downsides to the character to begin with in comparison to the previous two portrayals, but the slow-burn character arc they've been going for has meant he's shown real growth in every movie, and after NWH virtually EVERY common issue people had with his version has either been improved upon or completely fixed

[ryanmckenna]

Respectfully disagree - Andrew is the best SPIDER-MAN ACTOR IMO - he brings so much more to this role. Perfectly encapsulates what it means to be Spider-Man; Charismatic, Nerdy, Witty, Emotive and more. I may be Bias considering I grew up with Andrew however I personally felt moved by his portrayal more than the other actors (and that’s not to say they did a bad job Tobey and Tom are FANTASTIC!).

[coolguyyy]

Honestly I love all of the Spider-Man Actors they were cool in their own but I was so glad to see them all in Spider-Man: No Way Home
1. Tobey Maguire
2. Tom Holland
3. Andrew Garfield

[DarkAttackYT]

Let's be honest, all three Spider-Man actors are awesome and unique for different reasons. What is the point of competing which one is better when they all got a movie together and kicking ass together? No Way Home made me appreciate Andrew's Spider-Man who I used to not be a fan of in the past decade and after NWH, I wanna watch his films again.

[youngramesh]

I thought you were gonna put Tom as #1 especially after his performance in NWH. So I was surprised when I saw Tobey in first place which I totally agree with. Even though Tom Holland was incredible in the new movie, I still think Tobey was a near-perfect Spidey. Great video, Sean 😃

[YuvrajHaldankar]

Spider-Man (2002) was the first ever superhero movie I saw. It was showed to me by my parents when it came on television. I'm born of 2000, and I saw it when I was around 4-5 years old. So while Tobey's films are not the superhero films of my formative years (those are the MCU), I have a lot of nostalgia for Tobey as he was the one that was responsible for the first superhero movie I saw. I have a similar love for Christopher Reeve's Superman (the second superhero film my parents showed me, and I've loved it ever since). These are the only older superhero movies that though their dated, I love them as they were the ones I saw first.
My ranking:
1) Tobey Maguire (The Spider-Man I saw first)
2) Tom Holland (technically the Spider-Man of my formative years)
3) Andrew Garfield (I respect, but a lacks a unique selling point)