Is 2nd Ave Deli BETTER THAN KATZ's? Who Makes NYC's Best Pastrami?

When most people think of the best Jewish deli in NYC and the best pastrami sandwich in NYC, they will think of Katz's Deli. Katz's reputation is well-deserved, as it not only makes one of the best pastrami sandwiches in New York City, as well as one of the best corned beef sandwiches in NYC, but it is also one of the most famous restaurants in New York. At Katz's, expect to find a long line at any time of day after 10am, and even past midnight there will be long lines of tourists and locals (but mostly tourists) waiting to grab a late snack.

However, there are some who believe Katz's Deli is overrated, or at least overhyped. I am not the former, but I can see the argument for the latter. It is hands down one of the best sandwiches I have ever had in my life, but that being said I am not sure it is worth the crazy line and crowded atmosphere to eat there. Those who do not want to put up with the craziness of Katz's Deli will often flock to Sarge's Deli, S&P Lunch, Pastrami Queen, and Frankel's.

The name that is mentioned the most though of all of them is 2nd Ave Deli. Many pastrami fans and enthusiasts will claim that the new 2nd Ave Deli location, as they moved and are no longer on 2nd ave, is the best pastrami in the USA. Or they will at least say it is more worth it due to the less hectic nature of eating there!

Today we will put 2nd Ave Deli to the test. I am always one for a great pastrami sandwich, so let's see if this is the one that will finally top Katz's in NYC!

Like and Subscribe if you like my vids!

Restaurant Deets:
2nd Ave Deli
162 E 33rd St, New York, NY 10016

[uaeats]

This was the first ever UA Eats 4K video! Took way longer to edit and upload. With just HD I can make content faster, but do you think 4K is worth it?

[stephenfisher]

As Second Avenue Deli is actually kosher, not just kosher style, I am reminded of an old joke. A group of Jews goes to a Jewish delicatessen and the waiter, a Chinese, takes their order in fluent Yiddish. Later, the owner is making his rounds and comes to this table. He asked them how was their meal. They all proclaim, "Wonderful but just one thing; how did you get a Chinese waiter who speaks fluent Yiddish?"'  "Shh", exclaims the owner, trying to silence them. "He thinks we are teaching him English!"

[zzlogic]

You needed some Jewish deli mustard on the sandwich, and some pickles, and coleslaw on the side. I have not been in Katz's in 30 years. But back then you got complimentary (free) pickles put on your table. No way have I have eaten pastrami without mustard.

[SheLuvMeNot]

ua you are a great food blogger, keep going and your channel will eventually go viral

[JYLee-rrsy]

I've now seen several of your steak videos and a few of your sandwich ones, especially as it comes to pastrami and you've become a favorite for me UA. You make very relatable videos, you have a good easy and likeable presence and you do an excellent job describing aspects of your experience, ambiance, flavor, service, tenderness v flavor of the meat, etc. and price, as it would be important to viewers. Well done.

[Hgood]

Was I the only person who was frustrated that he took his time to bite into the sandwich after complaining the other pastrami pieces had gone cold? Eat it already!

[normandea]

Been watching your videos for a while now, and your food commentary has gotten better and better over time, very well spoken, along with an edge of humor. Love pastrami. I also like the 4K video quality as well. Certainly a challenge to eat with one hand and a camera in the other. Next, prime rib at Smith & Wollensky? Basic burger at Joe Junior? Peking Duck in Chinatown? Looking forward to the next video!

[tony-ceqp]

those people there that work hard are very am amazed how kind God Bless them all and you!

[chancefitzgerald]

Bottom line, these are great videos. Thanks for all your hard work.

[markfarrington]

Very good sandwich and very reasonably priced only 139.95 plus tax now that's a great deal.

[KuyaArbee]

DAYUM that looks impressive! there is so much to do and eat in NYC! Also your video vlogs quality is getting higher and higher quality! also love your honest reviews!

[Jeff-piw]

You have to love this guy.
I grew up eating pastrami, and I never saw anyone who could describe a pastrami sandwich like him!
Keep up the good work!

[marciasanguinetti]

I tell you - at the video's 11:35 minute mark, when UA says "Now maybe this is a thumbnail picture....", check out the older gentleman over UA's right shoulder ! What timing ! LOL !!! A great video as always - cheers all ! m.

[Aproductions]

I love your videos and your honest assesments. Sometimes, I feel like I'm there enjoying a plate with you. Keep going. Great reviews. Great ideas for places.

[SuperCatfan]

Love this guy!! Reviews are real and unbiased! Keep it up

[alanharrison]

I have not been back to NYC in over twenty years, but is that the original deli on 2nd. I lived around the corner from Carnegie Deli, but would always take a taxi down to 2nd Ave, when Abe was still around, and I was very happy with them as well as Katz’s.

I usually order the lean corned beef, but pastrami has to have the fatty tenderness and flavor.

Great posting.

[LordLOC]

As someone who grew up in Brooklyn NY, I was spoiled with riches for all the Jewish delis there were at the time (late 70s into the 80s and 90s) which includes in NYC itself. Brooklyn had some amazing Jewish delis back then which I still say were better than Katz's or 2nd Ave. but I digress. I've had the pleasure of eating at all these places before though, and 2nd Ave. is the only place to me that comes close to Katz's overall. First off as you found out yourself UA, the matzo ball soup at 2nd Ave. is top tier and better than almost any other place in the 5 boroughs. Now as for the pastrami. I am of the opinion that nothing beats Katz's still to this day (though it's been a good 18 years since I've eaten at any of these places now) but 2nd Ave. is the closest they come. Piping hot pastrami, cut super thin. Amazing bark and fat streaks in every piece. Terrific bread (though the bread does look different these days, still looks good though) and mustard. THOSE PRICES THOUGH, HOLY COW. (literally) I know NY isn't cheap, but near $30 for a pastrami sandwich is crazy. Katz's at least gives you near a LB of food in every sandwich, and while 2nd Ave. gives you plenty also, not sure it's worth the prices at either place. Either way, I'm glad these places still exist since they are a dying breed of restaurant and an essential part of New York City. I'm glad you do these videos UA to show people all of this great food.

Oh and sorry for the giant block of text :D

[optimizer]

"Oh wow - that's outstanding" - it sure looks like it! This is one of your more enjoyable videos, and they're all good. I haven't found a near-match for Schwartz in Montreal (we live on the West Coast, and I haven't tried Katz in NYC), but this looks really good. You really get into pastrami and your knowledge, taste buds and food obsessiveness shine through. Thanks UA!

[wptcrazyman]

My daughter and I ate at 2nd avenue on our trip to Boston. She had the matzoh ball soup and I the pastrami. Your review was spot on to.our thoughts. As for the prices... When in manhatten!! We also got to park for $10 all day.

Love your videos sir! This one of course is our favorite

[jasonmirabile]

Your reviews are GREAT dude. You have honest reviews, your fun and make me laugh at times and always put a smile on my face. KEEP IT UP please 😊