Audi Q4 E-TRON vs Tesla MODEL Y: Which All-Electric SUV is Better?

The first US deliveries of Audi’s more affordable all-electric SUV the 2022 Q4 E-TRON should be happening soon – With a starting price of just under $44K USD (before $7,500 federal tax credit) this SUV has a lot to like – but just how does it compare to the EXTREMELY POPULAR Tesla Model Y – and is the MODEL Y worth the extra cost?

NOTE: Towing numbers quoted in this video are the MAXIMUM AMOUNT, but the ACTUAL TOWING CAPACITY will vary based on a number of factors. For example, although the Model Y is rated to tow up to 3,500 pounds, the actual towing capacity varies all the way down to 0 lbs and up to 3,500 lbs based on tires and numbers of passengers - see Tesla Model Y owner’s manual for more information. Always follow the manufacturer's guidelines for towing safety.

Financially Support Cleanerwatt:

*** All video and pictures are used with permission or in accordance to the copyright owner's stated policies and use allowance, or applicable fair use laws. ***

Image & Video Clip Sources:

1. Tesla Pictures: Courtesy of Tesla, Inc.
2. Audi Q4 Pictures/Video Clips: Courtesy of Audi
3. VW ID.4 Video Clip: Courtesy of VW

Data Sources:

NOTE: All of the content found in this video is based on my own opinion and should not be regarded as financial advice. I am not a financial advisor and this is NOT in any way a financial recommendation or offer to buy or sell securities. While the information in this video is believed to be correct at the time of recording, no guarantees are being made about the accuracy of the information presented in the video. Please consult a licensed professional, or do your own research before making any financial decisions - including the purchase of a vehicle. As of the recording of this video, I am NOT invested in Tesla (TSLA) or VW (VWAGY) stock or securities.

[Cleanerwatt]

NOTE: Towing numbers quoted in this video are the MAXIMUM AMOUNT, but the ACTUAL TOWING CAPACITY will vary based on a number of factors. For example, although the Model Y is rated to tow up to 3, 500 pounds, the actual towing capacity varies all the way down to 0 lbs and up to 3, 500 lbs based on tires and numbers of passengers - see Tesla Model Y owner’s manual for more information. Always follow the manufacturer's guidelines for towing safety.

[TheCardinal]

Love the look of the Audi but would still go for the Tesla for the tech, range, performance, super charger network and the ease of buying online without haggling with the dealer.

[formerpilot]

I've owned a Tesla Model Y AWD LR for two years. I'm ready to dump it mostly for the very harsh and stiff ride quality. I just test drove a Q4 e-tron and it was smoother and quieter. I'm going to make the switch (are you listening Tesla engineers?).

[ahmedaltekreeti]

I think you forgot to mention one of the major part is the quality control, ride comfort, cabin quality assembly and cabin isolation.which Tesla has Lower score on those compare with Audi

[yellowsnowman]

The Audi is a real car. It's so much nicer inside and out and it's not close.

[vito_fra]

Audi: interior quality, great isolation and fluidity of driving (great experience)
Tesla: technology and efficiency
I choose Audi, real premium for the European standard of quality.
I choose Audi after 2 years of dreaming about Tesla Y…

[KittyRocketButterfly]

I’m an Audi girl. I want to stay with the brand and I’m so glad they have this more affordable EV available. I’ll be making the switch soon to the Q4 etron

[hotlobstahvids]

Being in a community with many EV's and having owned non-Tesla EVs in the past, if you're considering an EV, save yourself a lot of heartache and just get the Tesla.

[jonathansmith]

Can't believe my 2015 4 cylinder X3 can dust the E-tron in both 0-60 and top speed

[johnclaeys]

What bothers me about the Model Y is that it is essentially a “ jacked up” Model 3…it’s not a specifically designed dedicated vehicle. Read up on it.

[pierre.a.larsen]

The German Q4 e-tron pricelist is 106 pages long - that is crazy. It takes two days to buy this car. One day to study the pricelist and one day at the dealer.

[jonpriston]

I have a Q4 and absolutely love it. Having driven all the Teslas I think it's a much better car. Once the superchargers opens up it'll be perfect

[WhyYouAllHabut]

I'm looking into a compact suv EV next year and the q4 etron is getting my attention. For me, having apple CarPlay is a major player and is disappointing that Tesla doesn't offer it on any of their models. And I forgot all about the tax credit! That's a major plus!

Right now I have a 21 tiguan r line and the upgrade to the q4 etron sline would be a big step!

[WashingtonJacksun]

Loved the video. Just wished you had pointed out the fact, that during the range portion of your video, I knew Tesla would have a smaller battery but many viewers would not assume that and come to the conclusion that the two vehicles were almost equal.

Keep up the great work and your attempts to appear neutral are quite well received.

[OrganicStuff]

What blows my mind are youtube shills saying the ID4 is better than the MY

[ndrdst]

13:50 The test results say "3 RECALLS" for the Model Y. All remote over the air software updates.

[CybertuxSpain]

Audi is only nice for people with money and good taste. Not for young people playing iPhone games every minute of the day.

[SirHackaLt.]

I still prefer the Model Y… When it eventually makes it to the UK. :)

[kayakutah]

I'm open to alternatives, and am researching them, so thanks. But the upcoming 4680 battery for Tesla + the extended system of chargers is pretty hard to beat!

[pascalvanpuymbroeck]

The audi Q4 is an amazing car. Talked to a salesperson. Did a testdrive with it. I've placed my order. I once entered a tesla store and left the store after minutes of waiting. They were too busy. They loose. Simple as that.