The Big Picture : Centre – State Rights

Some of the opposition-ruled states have declared they will not implement the changes in the Citizenship Act. Kerala, Punjab, West Bengal and Chhattisgarh have claimed they will block implementation of the CAA in their states. Madhya Pradesh Chief Minister has also indicated that his government is against the law. Meanwhile, the Maharashtra government will take a decision on the implementation of the Citizenship Amendment Act only after the Supreme Court hears a bunch of petitions challenging the legislation. On the other hand Defence minister Rajnath Singh said the threat by some states not to implement the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) is a challenge to India’s federal structure as the legislation has been passed by Parliament and is binding on all states after the presidential assent. On this edition of the Big Picture we will analyse rights of the centre and the states in our Federal Structure.

Anchor: FRANK RAUSAN PEREIRA
Guest: Satya Prakash, Legal Editor, The Tribune

J Sai Deepak, Advocate, Supreme Court

Dr. L. Hanumanthaiah, Member Of Parliament, Congress, Rajya Sabha

Sushil Chandra Tripathi, Former Principal Secretary, Uttar Pradesh

[saurav]

70% of the comments are just for praising Deepak sir...his explainations are so clear he deserves this respect. 🙏

[shivodastak]

I search in every episode " where is J Sai Deepak"

[jaihind]

Sai is hope for future India...we need this kind of sane voices...

[gopinathsuryavanshi]

J saie deepak = encyclopedia of indian constitution.

[gabbargabbar]

A debate having J Sai Deepak and Satya Prakash is a must watch video....

[geetanjalisingh]

J Sai Deepak he is so clear crisp in his vision .. his art of expression is adorable. Gem. Can I as a law student have any chance of working under his guidance

[vijayraj-hgbj]

OnlyJ Sai Deepak sir explaination is the best.

[mayankbhupesh]

Sir J SAI DEEPAK u r true beauty....i request rstv to plz bring him in all constitutional and legel debates in big picture...so that we can be more enlightened.

[prasannapandaga]

Satya prakash sir explanation is like a child can understand what is the point. Thank you sir

[shanukumar]

plz don't bring any MP in discussion

[namratapandey]

I m a simple girl.
I see deepak sir and I click on the video.

[jonty]

J SAI DEEPAK IS ROCKSTAR ALREADY I HOPE HE GETS INTO REAL POLITICS NOT DOING FENCE SITTING . WE NEED MORE SUCH MAN

[dishantsharma]

Sai Deepak ... I mean .. Speechless ... Absolutely masterclass !!!

[vickkydude]

Dr.L.HANUMANTHAIAH —> *LIVING EXAMPLE WHY POLITICANS HAVE ZERO RESPECT*

[mayurpatil]

All of us talking around the CAA but NRC is major concern which was not address in this discussion..which is part of the protest..better if this discussion was carried out in holistic manner

[proudindian]

Don't invite politicians....

Because that Will dilute the quality of the


Because the person in this episode itself says the center has to get the permission of states to make law on. Citizenship....

[krishnachaitanya]

J Sai Deepak for future PM of India. Atleast should become law minister

[bharatiya-akp]

Stop inviting such stupid politicians.
These nonsense politicians will not think beyond politics.

[Thepatriotpodcast]

"Sai Deepak is synonymous to Knowledge, Courage and Articulation"

[swastikayadav]

Need to show this video to make understand persons who are doing protest against CAA.