Leading Philosophers Discuss Free Will

In the 500th edition of the programme, Melvyn Bragg and his guests discuss the philosophical idea of free will. Free will - the extent to which we are free to choose our own actions - is one of the most absorbing philosophical problems, debated by almost every great thinker of the last two thousand years. In a universe apparently governed by physical laws, is it possible for individuals to be responsible for their own actions? Or are our lives simply proceeding along preordained paths? Determinism - the doctrine that every event is the inevitable consequence of what goes before - seems to suggest so. Many intellectuals have concluded that free will is logically impossible. The philosopher Baruch Spinoza regarded it as a delusion. Albert Einstein wrote: "Human beings, in their thinking, feeling and acting are not free agents but are as causally bound as the stars in their motion." But in the Enlightenment, philosophers including David Hume found ways in which free will and determinism could be reconciled. Recent scientific developments mean that this debate remains as lively today as it was in the ancient world. With: Simon Blackburn Bertrand Russell Professor of Philosophy at the University of Cambridge Helen Beebee Professor of Philosophy at the University of Birmingham Galen Strawson Professor of Philosophy at the University of Reading Producer: Thomas Morris.

[osemaricana]

Please post more, it has been very helpful!

[caricue]

The speakers illuminated a point that I felt but could not articulate. They said that even a hard determinist would agree that right up to the moment of decision, the outcome is not fixed. The sticking point would be whether you could have chosen differently. I've run into a lot of determinists in the comments who would not even go this far. They say we are computers, so the decision is fixed in advance. This is the position that I find the most ludicrous and almost religious, as the speakers also discussed.

[RosannaMiller]

How can it be? For man it is impossible, but for God all things are possible.

[dannyvalastro]

In order too have a free will you have too be

[MrJamesdryable]

Use your free will to choose not to believe in free will... good luck.