Madden NFL 24 Review - The Final Verdict

Madden NFL 24 is more of what you might expect if you've played Madden 23. While the game certainly boasts improvements over last year's offering including refined player models, visual design, animations, and extended variable controls, there's still a sensation that elements like the narratively bankrupt Superstar mode and the mixture of good minigames with lackluster ones in Franchise mode that spell stagnation for a major sports franchise like Madden.

There's not much that could convince gaming fans to spend their hard-earned dollars on Madden NFL 24 if 23 is already in their library.

[DaStarrchild]

The Only review score we want is " EA please give up the fkn NFL exclusive license "/10!

[XxNINJHOBOxX]

Brought back features that are 10+ years old fans have been begging for and the game still sucks. Hate to see such a prestigious franchise go to trash.

[rashawnrawls]

They need NFL2k to get back on the scene and push them to do better

[jimmangz]

To answer anybody asking the question why fans would buy this year after year. The answer is that we love football more than we hate madden hence why this happens every year.

[DarkwingShadow]

The fact that people still love wasting money buying Madden just blows my 🤯 😅

[raymondbrown]

I remember being all excited when my Lions finally revealed their Honolulu Blue helmets…. Only for Madden 24 to not even acknowledge 🤬

[quintinlee]

I haven't played Madden since Madden 07 and I'm enjoying Madden 24 I guess I would understand all the complaints if I played the past 17 titles

[pdowski-bzty]

Bring back NFL EA has ruined football video games

[doughboy]

I often switch player positions like taking a low rated CB with good athleticism ratings and turn them into a Free Safety. If you do this in the edit roster screen it causes a glitch where the players Bio Info and years of experience turns into 31. No one has discussed this glitch

[iomis]

NFL 2k5 came out 18 years ago it's still the best football simulation ever made. Madden can't even catch up to being as good as a game made 18 years ago. Sad.

[InspireRise]

The game isn't bad if this is your first time playing it in ten years, like me.

[warshark]

Is this game worth buying if you’re not buying every year? Think the last time I purchased a madden game was about 4 years ago perhaps.

[MrGavinmccolgan]

This game sucks, let’s call it what it is

[dubstepflames]

Would this game be worth getting into if you’ve never played a madden before or no it’s not worth the money

[xilften]

GIVE UP THE NFL LICENSE EA. Give someone else a chance to make a better game.

[Katykimmer]

Is it me or does it look like a ps4 game?

[sumandsubstance]

Haven't bought a Madden since 18... Just saw it on sale for $14... Is this game worth buying y'all?

[JohnDoe-zrpc]

2:20, WTF did the tackler just stop, then fall down for no reason, instead of going in for the tackle? Is that just terrible animation, or huge lag?

[DerangedCoconut]

copy and paste last year plus change enough to piss off both sides of the arguments. just live service the thing since the biggest changes are just roster changes. just keep what fans want, live service it, milk the fan base more consistently, then realize to bring back NFL street series. this can also be applied to the other yearly released sports games that change so little you'd think they charged you twice for the same game + "ANIMATIONS"

[maxsnow]

They need to bring back the old Ragdoll physics when tackleing, like in Madden 16