I Asked AI To Make Redstone For Me

ChatGPT and Bing chat have been upgraded since the last time I asked AI to make redstone for me, and Google Discord and Snapchat have all made their own AI chat bots too, so I decided to find out if they can do redstone now :P

Need a Minecraft Server?
Get 25% OFF MCProHost using promo code: Purplers

Resource Pack: Vanilla Tweaks

[Purplers]

I've been getting a lot of comments saying I didn't follow the instructions correctly, so I thought I should mention that being a redstoner myself, I could immediately tell the AI had absolutely no clue how to build a simple redstone circuit. It's something that's probably a lot less obvious to people who don't make redstone

Lots of the instructions were very ambiguous, so I had to guess what the AI wanted me to do. Even if I followed the instructions "properly", the redstone still wouldn't have worked. The AI just didn't know how to make redstone xD

[beginneratstuff]

Obviously the discord bot wins because it didn't claim to know how to do something it doesn't know how to do, and when it did explain how to do something, it got it right. Accuracy over quantity, always

[humourlessjester]

Love how Bard answered the redstone question of the minecart station the same way as a minecraft builder who's never touched redstone in his life.

[fgmgNoob]

2:11 "add some automation" is a redstoners equivalent of a builder telling you to "add a little bit of detail"

[MarcusVader]

For the bing ai it’s referring to the tnt canon where the tnt will be dispensed by the dispenser and the slime block and sticky piston will send it flying.

[drowzypollinator]

Ai being able to admit when it doesn't have the answer is more of a win than getting it totally wrong.

[sagitswag]

I think the problem here was how you structure your prompts (especially in the clyde example). Dont ask them to do things for you. Ask them to give you a step by step guide on how you can do that thing instead.

[DragonAurora]

The fact that the clyde AI actually made a functional piston door is insane

[BanditFoxx]

Honestly, I just think your incredible inability to follow instructions is partly to blame here.

[nickberberian]

The google piston door was actually instructions for half of a piston door. The diagram at 9:54 is displaying all of the blocks top to bottom but in reality it’s trying to show it from an overhead view where the pressure plate is connected to a repeater which leads into red stone and powers the piston in front of it. As for the torches it could’ve been an incomplete way to connect the red stone to any top pistons but idk.

[Lampe]

Maybe you should have given Clyde and MyAI a second chance by asking if they can *describe how to build* the thing you wanted in MC.

[justgaming_]

7:03 bro gave me a heart attack for second there

[SlavaArduino]

Sadly Clyde is dead. Rest in Piece, you will be missed.

[thingwithchlorophyll]

I used to think prompt engineering tutorials was stupid, but apparently some people need them

[snipes_]

Speaking to Clyde is a bit of a art. You have to convince it can do what you want it to do most of the time.

[Hlebuwk]

That Discord 2x2 actually brought a tear to my eyes. It's like I saw someone truly worthless redeem themselves.

[justamicrowave]

Bing chat is basically just that one owl meme that goes “step 1. Draw 2 circles
Step 2. Draw the rest of the fucking owl”

[jenniferproctor]

The beginning with the idea of the hamster got me XD😂

[TheBcoolGuy]

You have to specify to Clyde that you want instructions on how to build it, a guide. Not that you want it to go into Minecraft and build it itself.

[wodroow]

for clyde I think it would need a prompt more like "Give me instructions to build ____" rather than just asking it to build it for you.