Josiah Trelawny IS NOT The Strange Man - Red Dead Redemption 2

Channel merch:

Four Pillars:

Snapchat: cabbagefishd3

Thanks for watching!
Please:
Like
Subscribe
Share
Comment
TELL YOUR FRIENDS ABOUT ME (please?)

NO SELF ADVERTISING WHETHER IT BE OF PRODUCTS OR CHANNELS (if you want me to notice your videos/products then be sure to privately message me)
I hope you enjoy the video!

#RDR2 #RedDeadRedemption #RockstarGames

[LW]

The Strange Man is the Monopoly Man, confirmed

[agayindividual]

He’s not THE Strange Man, but he is a strange man.

[kingqunt]

I gave John a moustache and suit, he’s the strange man now

[ItsBigOnDatChris]

Imagine thinking Trelawny the nicest man in the gang is the devil

[The_StrangeMan]

Thanks for giving me justice my boy. May you be saved from evil

[deffonotdio]

Also from what we hear trelawny didn't know what happened in Blackwater, but strange man knows every little detail

[ronaldtheant]

*any rich person in Saint Denis*
MrBossFTW: What’s up guys, MrBossFTW here and this guy that you see here is ACTIALLY the strange man which could lead to future DLC or Undead Nightmare 2, now if this DLC does happen it could also mean that we’ll be getting an online update including multiple playable characters such as Arthur Morgan, Gavin or even the strange man himself

[ilikemusic]

It's easy to clear up. The Strange Man has an American accent, Trelawny is English.

[Uhhok]

Why would Trelawny go from a con man to the embodiment of death?

[brownleelogan]

I always considered The Strange Man to be God. The response he gives to John's "damn you" (like"God damn you", or Goddammit" or any other variation), and by how he judges John's actions throughout the game, always subtly nudging John towards the righteous path, but ultimately letting him exercise his free will. That and The Strange Man is shown to be omnipotent in how he knows everything about John, something that's normally a trait associated with God/gods, and not normally with depictions of death.

[Venzzii]

The strange man is the physical embodiment of lumbago

[mr.notsocreative]

There is a door in St. Denis where you can hear Trelawny and his wife and multiple kids talking and stuff. Playing as Arthur he asks “Trelawny is that you?!” But is quickly turned away as he also tells his children to go up to their room. He never opens the door but apparently Trelawny is a family man with somewhat decent morals. Impossible for him to be the strange man

[jackfahy]

Probably the stupidest theory ever, something MrBossFTW would come up with

[Hey_its_nyx]

Corrections, he always was a strange man but he’s not THE strange man boah.

[nooneinparticular]

Trelawny is clearly intended to give off Strange Man vibes. They talk in story about him popping up unexpectedly in places, how he just knows things and of course his look, but he just simply is not the Strange Man. He's a strange man, in that he is odd, but not *the* Strange Man, the supernatural entity.

[Schwagg]

I like how people think Trelawny is the Strange Man when there's literally a model for him that you can see in the mirror of the Strange Man's cabin when the painting is complete

[comradenapoleon]

I always thought the similarities between the two were purely coincidental or a joke. I always just assumed the strange man was death, what with him wearing all black, being impervious to bullets and knowing where John would be buried.

[Haistulph]

This is pretty easy to explain, the stange man is most likely death and he knows john because john had near death experiences.

[Mitsurifan]

Only an O'Driscoll would make such an uneducated comparison

[jasoncrawford]

Theres even a camp encounter where Bill comes up to Arthur saying he met the strange man. Not Trelawney