Star Trek: Every New Show Ranked Worst To Best

How do the "Nu-Trek" shows stack up against each other? Let's dive in and find out.

Apologies for the few instances you can hear the mic popping. Batteries probably.

#StarTrek #StarTrekPicard #StarTrekSNW #StarTrekDiscovery #StarTrekLowerDecks #StarTrekProdigy #ShortTreks

[shaneblackburn]

Overall accurate ranking. Star Trek: Strange New Worlds definitely deserves the top spot among Modern Trek. Its the best Star Trek show I've seen since TNG and DS9.

[Anduril]

I would probably swap Picard and Discovery around as I think Disco had more absolute duds, but the rest of the list is pretty accurate.

[ArchOfWinter]

I hope they don't give up on Short Trek. It can be the anthology series we wanted. Give writers and directors who are fans a chance to make an episode. Let old cast members return for a one off story. It can be dramatic, a sketch comedy, claymation, an in-universe documentary, ship tour, anything is possible. Use the concept to test out new ideas to further explore upon in the future.

[TheWhaller]

SNW is my 3rd overall favorite series already but if the entire run is as strong as the first season it could knock on the door of DS9 and TNG.

[rullyantowibisono]

Season finale of SNW was SUPERB. the only down is captain kirk, not too convincing.

But how captain pike diplomatic strategy is fantastic. Facing the enemy that literally can dissappear, out gunned, out numbered, but manage to handle it.

I can't praise more to season finale. Can't wait for season 2

[dmanc]

Strange New Worlds and Lower Decks have been great additions to the series. Prodigy is great to introduce younger viewers to the series.

[himerosTheGod]

When I saw the notification for this video I chuckled 🤭 to myself. Real fans already know the order this video is gonna be in from start to finish.

[toonezon]

"and the easter eggs shatter the minds of those manning cetacean opservations" ... um i think you mean manateeing cetacean observations, -ehem-

[AlexFord]

Others are giving their full rankings for fun so here’s mine 😊

1. Strange New Worlds
2. Voyager
3. Deep Space Nine
4. The Next Generation
5. Discovery
6. Prodigy
7. Enterprise
8. Lower Decks
9. The Original Series

No such thing as Kelvin timeline for me lol

[frednich]

Good list, maybe I need to give prodigy a try.

[youcantalwaysgetwhatyouwan]

There’s something to love in all the shows. Good on the higher ups for creating different shows for different audiences

[ryutak]

I never understood why people did not like Star Trek: Enterprise. It was really good. Oh and I completely agree with this list :;

[Shanghaimartin]

I think you'll find it's...

1. SNW
2. Lower Decks
3. Discovery
4. Picard
5. Prodigy
* No idea about Short treks.

[topogigio]

Prodigy gets a bad rap for no reason. It easily carries the weight that Star Trek always has, while being true to the "ship at sea" Trek concept. It's supposed to be "for kids" but handles emotional subjects substantially better than Picard and especially Disco

[dswynne]

There should be a PIC spin-off prequel called STAR TREK: NEW FRONTIER, featuring Jean-Luc Picard's years as the Captain of the USS Constellation. And an ENT sequel called STAR TREK: ARCHER.

[bryandacote]

I haven't caught up on SNW yet, but I'd argue Lower Decks is better.

why? it appeals well with adult newbies.
I have introduced 7 friends into Star Trek largely thanks to Lower Decks. With the exception of one, the others barely would give Trek the time of day until I showed them Lower Decks. Now I'm having fun being their nerdy guide into the Trek Universe since I've pretty much seen all of it.

[t-and-d-productions]

Lower Decks reminds me of a fan series. Alot of the episodes talks about how good Star Trek used to be

[stephenk.]

Exactly how I ranked them before I watched the vid with the exception of Short Treks. I agree with its placement in the list, I just never really considered it as a series to begin with.

[glimmercat]

I haven't seen any of the animated shows yet, and only a couple Short Treks, but with that in mind, my Top 3 are: Discovery at #1, Picard at #2, and Strange New Worlds at #3. Planning to try the others in the next few weeks, but live-action is my preference, so I don't think much of my list will change.

[davidparkinson]

Halfway through Strange New Worlds and I'm really enjoying it. First Trek in a long time that I've been excited for the next episode to air. Felt a little sad that before it came along I could only get the thoughtful, uplifting and episodic Star Trek I liked from the Orville.