filmov
tv
Worldview | New regime in Bangladesh | Lessons for India & South Asia
Показать описание
In this episode of Worldview we discuss, what will the changes in Dhaka mean for Delhi and are there lessons for the entire neighbourhood?
As Bangladesh boiled over
Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina fled Dhaka after being in power for 15 years, she is now at an undisclosed location in India after landing at the Hindon airbase on Delhi’s outskirts
- Days of protests and violence, then saw mobs ransacking Hasina’s homes and Mujib’s memorial. Attacks on Hasina’s Awami League supporters and their properties have seen minorities, particularly Hindus being targeted.
- The military moved in to stabilize the situation and a new interim government headed by Professor Muhammad Yunus has now taken charge.
His priority, he said, was “save the country from anarchy”, and warned protestors against attacking any minorities
Hasina’s departure also saw the release of Bangladesh’s biggest opposition leader former PM 78 year old Khaleda Zia, who accused Sheikh Hasina of corruption and being undemocratic- and promised a new future for Bangladesh as thousands joined a BNP rally
All eyes are now on where Sheikh Hasina goes next
1. Hasina is believed to be at a safehouse at the Hindon airbase- the choice making it clear her original plan was to fly elsewhere. Her daughter Dr. Saima Wazed lives in Delhi, as Regional Director for WHO, but said on social media she is unable to see her or hug her- later deleting that post .
In parliament, EAM Jaishankar said she had come just “for the moment”
2. Sheikh Hasina is believed to have applied to the UK for entry- but sources said the UK is not prepared to give her protection from prosecution, and the UK government cited technicalities on an asylum application. Hasina’s sister is a UK citizen and her niece Tulip Siddique is a British MP
3. There’s also Finland, where Hasina’s nephew lives
4. And the US, where her son Sajeeb Wazed Joy lives- but Hasina has had a tense relationship with the US. When asked, Wazed said she was the victim of an internal and external conspiracy
5. Other possible destinations like the UAE, and Saudi Arabia are being discussed, but for the moment, Ms. Hasina remains in India
Apart from those concerns, India does have much to worry about with the changes in Dhaka:
1. About 19,000 Indians in Bangladesh, many of which have been brought back now
2. Worry that those fleeing violence and others could come across the borders- India has cancelled visas for now and stepped up BSF security
3. India’s infrastructure projects in Bangladesh, and in particular, the recently announced Adani power project could be reviewed. More than 10 billion dollars in trade and major connectivity moves also in the balance
4. India’s military cooperation, strategic and defence ties could also be a worry
5. With Bangladesh seemingly caught in the US-China geopolitical rivalry, India will have to work harder to keep its pre-eminent position in the country
Remember, Hasina’s departure is one of a series of political instability and turmoil in South Asia in the past few years:
1. In 2021, the military coup in Myanmar and the Taliban takeover in Afghanistan
2. In 2022, PM Imran Khan’s ouster in Pakistan and then protests forced President Gotabaya Rajapaksa to flee from Sri Lanka
3. In 2023 and 2024, the rapid changes in government in Nepal, and elections that brought President Muizzu to power in Maldives amid an India Out campaign
What now are the main lessons for India – in South Asia
1. Street power, the power of protests should not be taken lightly, even if they are quelled in the short term
2. Joblessness and lopsided unequal economic growth is increasingly a South Asian concern
3. Religious radicalization, and majoritarianism is endemic to South Asia, home to many religious majorities, and will need to be reversed- or there is the risk of spillover
4. Regional groupings are the only way South Asian countries can deal with their common social and economic challenges- if SAARC could be abandoned due to India-Pakistan differences, then what happens to BIMSTEC if India and Bangladesh now develop issues?
5. No change is permanent- Pakistan’s leaders have often gone into exile and returned to power, Rajapaksa has also returned to the country- and so might Hasina, but it is important to learn the lessons of democracy and keeping a finger on the pulse of the people- and for India to keep engaging all parts of its neighbourhood.
WV take: The change in Bangladesh is a setback to India’s interests, both in terms of economic and in terms of geopolitical stakes and even as New Delhi works on helping Hasina remain safe and secure, it must engage the new regime in Dhaka- and show by actions more than words, that when it comes to the neighbourhood, India’s friendship is with a country and people not any one leader or party.
As Bangladesh boiled over
Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina fled Dhaka after being in power for 15 years, she is now at an undisclosed location in India after landing at the Hindon airbase on Delhi’s outskirts
- Days of protests and violence, then saw mobs ransacking Hasina’s homes and Mujib’s memorial. Attacks on Hasina’s Awami League supporters and their properties have seen minorities, particularly Hindus being targeted.
- The military moved in to stabilize the situation and a new interim government headed by Professor Muhammad Yunus has now taken charge.
His priority, he said, was “save the country from anarchy”, and warned protestors against attacking any minorities
Hasina’s departure also saw the release of Bangladesh’s biggest opposition leader former PM 78 year old Khaleda Zia, who accused Sheikh Hasina of corruption and being undemocratic- and promised a new future for Bangladesh as thousands joined a BNP rally
All eyes are now on where Sheikh Hasina goes next
1. Hasina is believed to be at a safehouse at the Hindon airbase- the choice making it clear her original plan was to fly elsewhere. Her daughter Dr. Saima Wazed lives in Delhi, as Regional Director for WHO, but said on social media she is unable to see her or hug her- later deleting that post .
In parliament, EAM Jaishankar said she had come just “for the moment”
2. Sheikh Hasina is believed to have applied to the UK for entry- but sources said the UK is not prepared to give her protection from prosecution, and the UK government cited technicalities on an asylum application. Hasina’s sister is a UK citizen and her niece Tulip Siddique is a British MP
3. There’s also Finland, where Hasina’s nephew lives
4. And the US, where her son Sajeeb Wazed Joy lives- but Hasina has had a tense relationship with the US. When asked, Wazed said she was the victim of an internal and external conspiracy
5. Other possible destinations like the UAE, and Saudi Arabia are being discussed, but for the moment, Ms. Hasina remains in India
Apart from those concerns, India does have much to worry about with the changes in Dhaka:
1. About 19,000 Indians in Bangladesh, many of which have been brought back now
2. Worry that those fleeing violence and others could come across the borders- India has cancelled visas for now and stepped up BSF security
3. India’s infrastructure projects in Bangladesh, and in particular, the recently announced Adani power project could be reviewed. More than 10 billion dollars in trade and major connectivity moves also in the balance
4. India’s military cooperation, strategic and defence ties could also be a worry
5. With Bangladesh seemingly caught in the US-China geopolitical rivalry, India will have to work harder to keep its pre-eminent position in the country
Remember, Hasina’s departure is one of a series of political instability and turmoil in South Asia in the past few years:
1. In 2021, the military coup in Myanmar and the Taliban takeover in Afghanistan
2. In 2022, PM Imran Khan’s ouster in Pakistan and then protests forced President Gotabaya Rajapaksa to flee from Sri Lanka
3. In 2023 and 2024, the rapid changes in government in Nepal, and elections that brought President Muizzu to power in Maldives amid an India Out campaign
What now are the main lessons for India – in South Asia
1. Street power, the power of protests should not be taken lightly, even if they are quelled in the short term
2. Joblessness and lopsided unequal economic growth is increasingly a South Asian concern
3. Religious radicalization, and majoritarianism is endemic to South Asia, home to many religious majorities, and will need to be reversed- or there is the risk of spillover
4. Regional groupings are the only way South Asian countries can deal with their common social and economic challenges- if SAARC could be abandoned due to India-Pakistan differences, then what happens to BIMSTEC if India and Bangladesh now develop issues?
5. No change is permanent- Pakistan’s leaders have often gone into exile and returned to power, Rajapaksa has also returned to the country- and so might Hasina, but it is important to learn the lessons of democracy and keeping a finger on the pulse of the people- and for India to keep engaging all parts of its neighbourhood.
WV take: The change in Bangladesh is a setback to India’s interests, both in terms of economic and in terms of geopolitical stakes and even as New Delhi works on helping Hasina remain safe and secure, it must engage the new regime in Dhaka- and show by actions more than words, that when it comes to the neighbourhood, India’s friendship is with a country and people not any one leader or party.
Комментарии