Diagram of Hegel's Phenomenology of Spirit

preview_player
Показать описание

diagram for module 7 (note that this diagram builds on the prior four diagrams in this playlist on German Idealism)
Рекомендации по теме
Комментарии
Автор

Decent summary of my remarks from ChatGPT: 
This summary outlines a lecture that attempts to diagram Hegel's "Phenomenology of Spirit, " providing a simplified visual representation of Hegel's complex philosophical ideas. The lecturer acknowledges the limitations of this approach, as it cannot capture the full depth and detail of Hegel's work.

Sense Certainty: Hegel starts with the basic form of knowledge called "sense certainty, " akin to pre-Kantian perspectives, where objects exist independently and knowledge is gained in an immediate, unproblematic way. However, this form of knowledge encounters contradictions and realizes its inadequacy as terms like "now" or "here" are more abstract than they appear, leading to the understanding that the mind plays a role in mediating knowledge.
Perception: From the ashes of sense certainty, a new shape of consciousness emerges, called "perception." This stage recognizes that objects are mediated by concepts of understanding and by space and time. A dialectic unfolds as consciousness tries to reconcile the unity of an object with its multiple properties, eventually leading to the realization of its inadequacy.
Force and Understanding: The next stage, "force and understanding, " sees consciousness recognizing a supersensible substratum behind objects. This leads to an understanding of the identity of subject and object but still lacks complete self-consciousness.
Self-Certainty: As consciousness evolves, it reaches "self-certainty" or self-consciousness, where the self assimilates objects to itself. It encounters another self-consciousness, leading to Hegel's famous master-slave dialectic. This stage involves a battle for recognition and an eventual realization of a master-slave dynamic, which the slave overcomes by internalizing the dialectic.
Stoicism and Religious Consciousness: The progression leads to stoicism and religious consciousness, where self-consciousness grapples with its division and seeks freedom, eventually leading to the realization that the divine is within oneself.
Reason: The stage of "reason" sees the self-consciousness becoming aware of its unity with nature and the evolutionary process of objects and subjects. However, this stage still needs to overcome itself to reach full knowledge.
Absolute Knowledge: The journey towards absolute knowledge requires social institutions and forms. Hegel emphasizes that this is not just an individual's journey but the journey of absolute spirit, which eventually becomes self-conscious of its own spiritual being.
The lecturer encourages students to read Hegel's "Phenomenology of Spirit" despite its complexity and the potential need for multiple readings.

FootnotesPlato
Автор

this is by far and away the best summary of the Phenomenology of Spirit that exists on you tube!

divinuminfernum
Автор

I was introduced to the Phenomenology of Spirit by Hegel in 1999 at the University of California Riverside. At first I was completely lost, but I read and reread the book. It was the start of my journey into the plethora of ideas that I found in the continental tradition. I believe, especially now that this seminal work is completely under rated given the crisis of our time. Thank you for posting this.

davidtanphilosophy
Автор

For you doing this thankless task, I say thank you.

plastic
Автор

The camera placement makes me feel like I’m close enough to hug you.

The lecture is so good I just might.

lennon_richardson
Автор

Hegel was such a fan of negation that his Preface in Phenomenology of Spirit actually starts out as an explanation about why a Preface to a philosophical work is bullshit. And actually expands his theory out of this ability to claim that a preface is in adequate lol amazing!

KeithMakank
Автор

When you said “the master is seeking recognition from another free being” I finally realized how deep the phenomenology of spirit goes:
All the way from Leibniz to Fichte, it captures the story of philosophy over that period.

primalpatel
Автор

I am a student of nondual philosophy/spirituality, and it struck me how close this seems to be to the teachings of, for example, Rupert Spira and Adyashanti, and of Buddhist philosophers such as Nagarjuna. So helpful, many thanks!

mrnibelheim
Автор

Hegel is essentially providing a developmental theory of human consciousness.

Havre_Chithra
Автор

Hey great video!! I'm reading this book now, I really appreciate that you put all three sections in one concise video with a diagram. It takes a lot of time to understand this book, let alone to summarize in a simple way like you did here. Thanks for this!

courtneydolly
Автор

Phenomenal explanation! No pun intended 😉This explanation is direct, simplified without compromising the integrity of the fundamentals & conveyed wth ease. Well Done! 👏👏👏

Nabiyah
Автор

Probably the cleanest breakdown I've ever seen of Hegel.

mahawk
Автор

I'm blown away by this! I've tried for years to find any resource that would make Hegel make even a little bit of sense to me and this video has helped me understand more than I ever thought I would. Thank you so much, you are a great teacher

lscoverThelegend
Автор

I'm eternally grateful for the clarity of your explanation!

JONAS-cout
Автор

These videos are great man, the diagrams bring some clarity to some of the more complicated thinkers of the western tradition. Keep it up.

wcropp
Автор

that was actually really good! ive been struggling through the Phenomenology for a while now and this has given me a new grasp on it, thanks!

mikethecatcher
Автор

That was absolutelly brilliant! The best summary of the Phenomenology of Spirit I have ever seen! Thank you very much for this video!

Vak_g
Автор

Thank you very much, a very clear explanation of an insanely difficult and fantastic book!

dodetkotob
Автор

i'm trying to catch up on a whole semester worth of history of philosophy classes - this really helps, thank you!

mariabrader
Автор

Excellent explanation!...Hagel is not really that complicated, as long as we are open to his philosophy and not become attached to collective beliefs...you made it very simple...thank you for taking the time to share this!

AdrianaCordovez