The Cast Of “The Baby-Sitters Club” Finds Out Which Characters They Really Are

The cast of the new Netflix series “The Baby-Sitters Club” (Alicia Silverstone, Sophie Grace, Momona Tamada, Xochitl Gomez, Shay Rudolph, Malia Baker, and Mark Feuerstein) sat down to take our BuzzFeed quiz to find out which characters from the show they really are…and it seems that for at least a few of them, the casting was spot-on.

BuzzFeed Celeb
Celebs + puppies, kittens, thirst tweets, and more = so much yes.

GET MORE BUZZFEED:

SUBSCRIBE TO BUZZFEED NEWSLETTERS:

MUSIC
Let's Dance_Instrumental
Licensed via Warner Chappell Production Music Inc.
Mars_Main
Licensed via Warner Chappell Production Music Inc.

STILLS
80s 90s background seamless vector pop art pattern wallpaper
chaluk/Getty Images
Illustration for hipsters style.
Fighter_Francevna/Getty Images

[chloe_]

Idk about anyone else but Shay Rudolph is *exactly* how I pictured Stacey reading the books all through childhood.

[eduardamedeiros]

I hope Netflix renew this show, I’ve already binge watched the whole season and it’s great

[Strawberryfearsforever]

Claudia’s fashion is everything on the show.

[siri]

The fact we are all ignoring Mary Ann's hair is just crazy like dude I can't even pull of a ponytail and she can pull THAT off

[maddie-xjru]

omg the girl who plays claudia is so pretty 😌

[MrPandajacks]

I love these girls and this series made me teary every episode. They are great actresses and actors. And the babies so cute.

[evalisia]

I watched this and there was a reference to Clueless in one of the episodes kristy says, she wasn’t totally clueless, and I was like THAT WAS A CLUELESS REFERENCE

[totallypooh]

“Who’s leaving their child with Timothee Chalemet”😂😂ah that had me dying😂😂😂

[jackiebrubaker]

Sophie Grace was the PERFECT choice for Kristy!!! She looks exactly like I envisioned, and does such a good job in the role!

[samiam]

“I love proving people wrong” OMG SAMEEE THO!

[erinpatterson]

Okay I’m just gonna say the girl who played Mary Anne is absolutely gorgeous

[Isabelle-kjmc]

The thing is I’m 14 and I’ve never had a babysitter in my life

[lilarose]

he is right. Nobody is gonna leave their kid with timothy. like if it is a 11 or 12 year old like ik they can be alone but still like that kid would be swooning

[abbigrace]

BRO THE ALICIA SILVERSTONE!! LIKE CHER FROM CLUELESS I-

[mackncheese]

I literally just realized the mom was Cher in clueless and I thought she looked familiar 😽

[tireddaily]

I’ve never watched this show but isn’t that the actress who played Cher in Clueless?
Edit: she is lmfao

[bambisubliminalstan]

Last digit of likes, is who you are!! 1. Claudia 2. Stacy 3. Kirsty 4. Mona Tamata 5. Shay Rudolph 6. Sophie Grace 7. Malia Baker 8. Sachi Gomes
9. A unicorn

[pineapple]

Who else knows about the “Baby Sitters Club” from Raina Telgimer? 😂

[mev]

I watched the whole show in one day.

I couldn't help but notice Stacy though.she was diabetic with type 1 diabetes and was in 8th/7th grade which I thought was cool.cause my BESTFRIEND ever that I know for what...since I was 2? Is the same age as Stacy and is also diabetic with type 1 diabetes so Stacy caught my attention to the show when I found out her diabetes on there.

[avocado]

No one:
Not even the cast:
Alicia: "i already forgot my name.."