Dog Owner Disagrees with Judge Judy’s Verdict! | Part 1

Rosemary says Sharon's two dogs attacked her 64-pound dog named Jill. Sharon tells a different story!

#JudgeJudy

The Original! There’s only ONE Judge Judy. Visit our website for where to watch, weekdays.

[molamolalaaa]

The older lady sounded like such a sweetheart!
I almost teared up when she described how her dog was attacked.

[leahw]

@1:33
"She did not got them" understatement of the year.

[QAZ-OMEN]

210 lbs of dogs trying to b walked by a 120 lb person is ridiculously irresponsible

[azianotasia]

The way some grown adults just cannot take accountability is baffling

[Guybrush_U_Threepwood]

“Are you afraid of dogs ?” She said she asked the woman who’s walking a dog? She’s so full of it

[SherriLyles]

When the plaintiff described the attack and her voice broke, I felt so heartbroken for her. She is so itty bitty and I cannot imagine the helplessness she felt in that moment trying to get a dog of pure muscle off her's. Owners like the defendant are just infuriating to me.

[vanessamrose]

The plaintiff was so pleasant. I bet she’s a wonderful grandmother ❤️

[jadeinthewoods]

I knew immediately who was telling the truth. The plaintiff’s face was genuinely shocked and floored by the defendant’s story. You can’t fake a reaction like that.

[Set_Free]

Protect Rosemary at all costs. You know she bakes cookies for the borough meetings. I love this sweet lady!!

[DonGrigorianFishing]

Did the defendant just say to JJ, "You weren't there"???? That's the most idiotic thing I've ever heard anyone say to a judge 😂😂😂It's over for her

[Dizzyfingers]

JJ: What kind of breed are your dogs, Ms Gillings?
Defendant: Pit ...
JJ: Judgment for the plaintiff.

[ImThePrs]

The moment I heard that the defendant's dogs were pitbulls, I knew it was over for her lmao

[ceceliamoreno]

I feel horrible and am completely mystified how this woman could think she could handle two huge dogs. So stupid and ridiculous.

[alienlife]

This the elderly woman was the exact kind of litigant Judy likes. Has all her information strait, doesn’t wander off on side stories, is precise and to the point, and doesn’t try any shit.

[robertriggleman]

This woman should have been arrested and taken to jail for not being able to control her dogs. This could have been a lot worse.

[karissakline]

Her case was lost as soon as she said ‘I own two pitbulls’ 😂

[leeleeirv]

People that are guilty are always disrespectful.

[MissPrissy]

Oh my GOSH when the defendant said “you weren’t there” I almost screamed😩😟 how are you that rude and snarky to a judge, much less Judge Judy 🤦🏾‍♀️

[Mia-qtth]

The plaintiff is so cute I love the way she enunciates her words so perfectly.❤

[m.justinelopez]

“Are your dogs friendly? My dogs are friendly” then proceeds to attack the plaintiffs dog.