I Tried The Top 20 Tubing Mascaras And Found the Best One... Tubing Mascara Showdown!

✖ FIND ME:

✖ KEEP WATCHING:

✖ TIME STAMPS:
00:00 Intro
00:11 Blinc
02:05 Velour
03:15 Milani
04:27 Tarte XL
05:42 KVD
06:58 Essence
07:38 LA Girl
08:34 Judy Doll
09:42 Ulta
10:41 L’Oreal
12:00 Merit
13:00 Milk
14:07 Clinique
14:51 Caliray
15:39 Elf
16:28 Heimish
17:33 Hourglass
18:50 Thrive
19:53 Rudi x Beaubble
21:23 Tarte Original

✖ PRODUCTS MENTIONED:

✖ FTC: This video is not sponsored. Products marked with an * were gifted to me in PR. If you decide to purchase any products from this video, it would mean SO much to me if you used my links. This gives me a small commission to continue to purchase new products to review for you all on this channel. Thank you so much for your love & support!

✖ Disclaimers: I am not a dermatologist or medical professional. My channel is a space for me to share product reviews based on my personal experience and/or research, not to diagnose. My videos should never be a replacement for guidance from a medical professional. You should always seek guidance from a medical professional or dermatologist for any and all concerns, questions, and needs.

♪ Storybook (Prod. by Lukrembo)

[CobraDove]

I have been using tubing mascara ( L’Oreal beauty tubes) for about 20 years (before they became trendy), and you have to use the primer if you want to get the volume! It’s not unfair, it’s meant to be used that way, I’ve recommended that drugstore fave to anyone that would listen for decades. And as far as your first place pick, the Maybelline Sky High seems to be exactly the same as that Tartlette first pick you chose, half tubing with a little bit of smearing in the removal, however, the mascara looks beautiful and it’s super cheap. I hope that helps anyone out. I tried the Caliray mascara and I love it

[rachellopez]

The rigor with which you test products is so impressive ❤

[jessicalevina]

Would love to see brown mascara showdown. Just wanted to say thank you for the video and all the effort you put into this ❤️❤️

[melissakearns]

My favorite is the Maybelline New York Lash Sensational Sky High Washable Eyelash Mascara in Brownish Black .. I was recommended this as a brown tubing mascara as Beaubble doesn’t ship to Canada .. it’s great and has replaced my previous faves 💕

[jenniezarna]

To remove tubing mascaras you simply need to wet the lashes for like 15 seconds then swipe down with a cotton pad or wash cloth. It’s the water which releases the hold on your lashes not rubbing around in circles.

[kellyish]

I like the Thrive better than the Tarte. For the price point I have been using Elf.

[cs-yqed]

I tried a mini of the original Tarte Tubing mascara. I wasn't overly impressed, but thought it was just ok. I just tried the Elf and was greatly disappointed. It was dry and so I couldn't layer it. Basically, got no length or volume. My favorite is the Caliray Tubing. I am able to layer it easily. It also holds the curl. Thanks for doing this indepth analysis, Abbey! ❤

[vidatalab]

Glad that the elf tubing mascara made it so high up on the list. I have a hard time paying for a high end mascara when it’s not 50% off 😅

[evonheffken]

Thanks for the good information, Abbey. I would love to see a cream blush showdown with one criterion in the grading system being how long wearing it is.

[MaddMartiee]

I was having issues with transfer from even waterproof mascara so I picked up the Elf tubing one recently and I'm loving it! I'm only seeing this vid now, but I'm so glad to know that mascara is Abbey-Approved! ✨

[Luvfoodfitness]

This might be my favorite video ever!! I have only ever tried the L’Oréal and Blinc tubing mascaras, and have only just discovered Elf! Hated Blinc, L’Oréal is only OK, as I feel like when you use the white primer, it leaves a weird white cast that you can’t totally cover up, and it gets flakey for me. Elf has been a GAME CHANGER! I am not a big fan or user of Wlf products in general because I feel like the products don’t really jive well with my skin chemistry, but the Elf tubing mascara is IT!!! Maybe I should expand my horizons and try some of these other tubing mascaras from other brands. I had no idea there were so many options!!! Thanks Abby!! ❤😊

[tinafriis]

Yup, the Tarte is one of my absolute faves as well! However, I actually prefer the ELF, as the Tarte transfers a tiny bit, whereas the ELF does NOT budge! Great video, thanks! ❤

[fbmbassist]

The L’Oréal NEEDS the primer—it’s not optional. That’s what allows you to get length without it ever clumping. You apply the black mascara while the primer is still wet (do one eye at a time, all coats at once before it dries). It may seem unfair, but they did that on purpose and it makes the formula unique. Glad to keep gatekeeping this one though so it doesn’t sell out or increase in price! 😂

[sunkissed]

I have been using the L’Oréal Double Extend for at least 15 years now- I’m tempted to try out other formulas but I keep going back to this one bc it’s such a tried and true affordable and easily accessible drug store product for me. I even wore it to my father’s funeral and crying didn’t ruin it or smudge it. I agree that the primer does add to the experience of the product - and I love that I don’t have to fuss with 2 separate tubes to get my lashes done in the morning. Last year I tried the KVD one and I agree the brush is AWFUL and it doesn’t wash off well. I also find it disappears throughout the day so your review was spot on! Thanks for this video, I might try one of your top recommendations!

[Fortunekuke]

Please try the Estee Lauder Zero smudge tubing mascara. It’s so underrated under the radar.

[danalichvar]

OMG my favorite mascara made first place!! I have straight lashes that wont hold a curl and this does a pretty good job for something that isnt waterproof. & now they make it in brown too!

[Pinkflo]

I still love my Loreal air volume mega mascara. But it’s nice to see what’s out there and what I may consider trying. Thanks for the review.

[CaliforniaBabe]

Tubing mascaras, yes!!!🙂😍🥳 I love the Thrive mascara.

[LX]

My holy grail is hourglass but I am going to try the thrive 👌 The tarte winner removal is a deal breaker for me unfortunately! The main thing I love about tuning mascara is the removing in tubes and no smudging so the tarte defeats the point for me 😅
Thanks for this helpful review!

[AprilSo]

Love the depth of this video! I think the Ulta Lash Flash is the tubing mascara, and New Heights is a typical mascara. I’d love to hear your thoughts on the Lash Flash!