Do YOU believe everything you hear? WHY have THESE performances disappeared in 2024???

On the agenda tonight we're taking a look at 'Lake Dardanelle' performing 'And I Am Telling You I'm Not Leaving' (I only found out after recording the video her name is Naomi Shure as I hadn't seen the video previously!).
TIME STAMPS -
0:00 Intro
0:46 Performance
2:18 Analysis 1
3:09 Performance 2
4:38 Analysis 2
5:03 The Comparison
9:41 Safety Net?!! (Or kids bowling?!!)

[russshaber]

I'm so glad you're still on You Tube, the way you exposed copyright theft. Fil Forever!

[rossmurray]

At 7:21 Fil says, "For my taste I'd prefer her to have a little bit more ..."
'Silence' is the word I would choose.

[Deedee]

Hits like a beauty pageant talent portion from a poor girl who really can't sing but didn't want to twirl a baton. Loved the bowling analogy!

[JstAntherJhn]

one of the reasons I stopped watching talent searching shows on tv is because I couldnt figure out why judges didnt like a particular singer I thought was good. Turns out what judges hear live on the show is not the same as what is aired on tv, as admitted by the judges themselves.

[lawwdoggdigr]

My poor dog pissed on the floor and knocked herself out trying to flee through the closed glass patio door. Thanks Fil! ❤️

[CarolP]

Thank you for clearly showing the difference, I’m not at all musical but have sensed a difference in current music (vocals) compared to older ones and it was through you channel that I started to understand why. Another observation, you are always kind with your words, it is very much appreciated in this time and age of hostility.

[TheRealDrJoey]

Things like this kinda disturb me. Years ago I worked at a theater where we did occasional live shows. We had a woman rent the theater, put posters around town exalting her "Thrilling three octaves" vocals, she rented a stage flat background, and hired a pianist from the Musicians' Union.
She was FAR worse than this singer here. Far worse. INCREDIBLY bad.
But here's the thing: like this woman you have here, she was SUPREMELY confident in her delivery.
Here's the part that bugs me, as a musician and one-time performer myself: How much of that kind of delusion am I under? If she could be THAT bad and not know it, am I horrible too?

[jamesnylan]

My flatmate doesn't exactly have a great ear for pitch, and he cringed at this one. I even think the pitch correction wasn't quite enough. I feel sad for this woman, because she genuinely seems to be having a great time on stage, but she needs some more singing lessons. Her ear is not there, and I wonder if it's her, or her monitors, or both. I mean, she was way off! If this happened to me, I'd be a wreck, but I'm not a singer.

[lordy]

I thought the first one was the original, imagine the horror!! As my Dad used to say that girl ain't tone deaf, she's tone DEAD

[franneep]

OMG! She lost some kind of bet at local pub.
Kudos Fil! How you do this without cracking up is the mark of a serious and skilled teacher. ❤

[NinerFourWhiskey]

Go dig up some live performances from the mid 1970's of the band, Heart (Ann Wilson). Her voice from that era is absolutely amazing. I can only imagine the destruction of vocals that would have been unleashed on her in today's production environment.

[pobsdad]

In the immortal words of Sean Locke, "Please make it stop!"

[kyrie]

Fil’s poker-face. The struggle is real.

[sjab]

Bravo for managing to sing in so many different keys!

[hrizonsdebbie]

I thought the pitch corrected one was the uncorrected one! 😜 Plot twist! And then I heard the second one.

[pinkthistle]

Wow, that was painful !! Your analysis was so generous Fil, I think pitch correction struggled with this performance.

[HandwhistlerBen]

Your videos are so informational for those who can't hear the difference until you take out the electronic correction. Most enjoyable!

[fsm]

Oh my... when I heard the first one was the one corrected I said to myself "Brace for impact!" 🙂 Great video!!!

[nonavailable]

You're the best real voice pitch expert i can think of !!!, thank you very much for educating others about it 👍

[janegardener]

It was only 1 minute 49 seconds but it felt like forever...