Dune live Q&A with Quinn

This stream has spoilers for all six Dune books!

[realisticmgmt]

I completely forgot about Count Fenring being invisible to Paul’s prescience. It makes so much more sense now that they’d keep him hidden from promotional materials. Great stream!

[SpirusOfH]

That idea of viewing the trailers as prescient visions of what could happen or could have happened in the story is one of the most interesting pieces of media analysis I have ever heard. I love that idea so much, even if it's not intentional!

[Sattva]

Whenever your 2+ hour live Q&A's come out I always get so much housework done puttering around & listening. 😊Great episode, two of my favorite voices & content creators! Thank you!

[HamzaBoujelouah]

I'll say this in regards to Dune Messiah. I think for sure it can work as a film it just needs to be restructured a little. Show the atrocities of Muad'Dib, really delve into Paul, Chani and Irulan and their dynamics and end off on the gut punch of Chani's death.

Part of why I loved Messiah was how tragic the ending was. Will it be pleasing to general audiences? HELL NO! Will it be a brilliant piece of cinema? With Villeneuve at the helm- FOR SURE!

[asterozoan]

Woo, two of my favourite youtubers on one stream! Love it!

[pseudonymousbeing]

I get CHILLS thinking about the idea of Paul having visions of the imperial entourage and taking in every face, Shadam, Irulan, the guild... then when it comes to actually happening and there's a similar shot but suddenly Fenring stands where nobody stood and it's terrifying. He could be SUCH a compelling final obstacle. And that's why we wouldn't see him with Margot on Geidi Prime, it would preserve the surprise of his presence and slap even book readers across the face. Just imagine.

[jimmyb]

I can contribute my love for Dune to Quinn. He got me into the books. Read them all in a summer, couldn't stop. Quinn's deep dives and discussions really help reign in this massive story. I feel like Part 2 was always supposed to be a big, explosive, movie. There was so much in the Dune book that was eluded to but not described in detail; many skirmishes and battles that Paul leads that are just a footnote in a long, thought filled, chapter.

[yshwgth]

Please keep inviting Quinn, your conversations are the best!

[tirzahgayla]

I went to a Brian Herbert book reading at Borderlands Books and he talked about the origins you mentioned as well. He said his dad Frank based Jessica on his mom (as is well known) and I asked if he had any experiences of his mom being telepathic or in any other way resembling the character of Jessica. He had such good examples of it including one in a public place with an automatic? hand dryer with other people too. It was so fun and so cool to hear. I know a lot of people hate on Brian but it was a really great book reading. He stayed for hours and there were only like 7 of us so he got really in depth and took time to answer all our dumb questions and we even went way off topic talking about all sorts of things and he was into it and really fun. Nice guy.

[m_ylane]

Oh damn, this is exciting!!! You two together is prime content

[DDR]

Quinn understands Villeneuve and movies in general much more than other Dune channels, especially much more than Secrets of Dune, that dude is always complaining.

[fidanguliyeva]

Oh, that was unexpected but very welcome!! Love your streams/podcasts Shift & Quinn! Meanwhile, Schwifty boy clearly tries to mimic these impeccable streams with Gladiolus, such amateur

[tirzahgayla]

I'm a huge fan of Quinn's Ideas - saw an earlier collab with him on your channel previously. So glad to see you working together again. Love how clever both you gents are and also listen at times to Quinn's buddy David LIghtbringer. Great you all are in contact and please let us know when you're in the bay area again as I would've loved to see you when you were here in Alameda a couple years back. tysm

[robstewartstewart]

Just would like to give a big shout out and thank you to Quinn. A couple of videos of yours I watched some years ago are what sent me down the rabbit hole of ASOIAF/GOT theory videos. Discovering Preston, David, Joe Magician, Hills Alive, Nettles, Greyscale Tim, Glidus, Alt Schift X……was all thanks to you! Thank you!

[jamessmith]

QUINN IS THE OG, love both of you guys!!! ✊🏾 🌈

[agustinorero]

What an amazing Duneverse talk between two of the most knowledgeable people in Youtube.
Please, make this a recurring thing.

[mechtheist]

In Texas we have mushrooms that mostly grow out of cow patties and they trun blue where injured like the stalk where boken. It's usually after a rain that you go looking for them, it's really cool when you find them growing profusely.

[tirzahgayla]

I love all the adaptations of Dune because I love Dune. Seeing other interpretations of it widens my mind to what it means and what I missed. Other difficult to understand books low budget adaptations help me understand them better as well. I fully encourage all low budget interpretations of anything because the creators help me learn and have fun and so do we.

[godofmath]

Quinn's Ideas is such an underrated channel that I got excited when I read the title of this video. Great collab!

[aliud]

I was hoping to see yall collab again!