What If Every Potential Straw Hat Joined The Crew?

Subscribe :)

[CheddahSlammer]

I would argue with Carrot that her tragic backstory was in real time, basically Pedro sacrificing himself and his enemy still being alive after his sacrifice.

[leisureseeker]

Of all the characters, Smoker joining straw hats doesn't seem to be likely, would be more fitting if he joined the revs imo. And don't forget to consider Bonney.

[MZero-zfio]

1090+ chapters and our man Bon Clay did more things to help Luffy than Dragon.

[defianthound]

It's crazy Yamato an Carrot didn't join the crew but I had to remind myself Pre timeskip is Luffy building his crew and family. Post time skip Luffy is building his empire and army of different nations with commanders that will follow an aid Luffy when he needs them. Like Rebecca, Carrot, Yamato, The Grand Fleet and then Katakuri as conqurer rivals.

[schwarzerse]

I would love to see someone completely unexpected to join, like if Kizaru turned 180° and all of a sudden became a straw hat or something

[Falcovsleon]

I kind of wished Perona joined as the scout/spy. I know she doesn't really fit the requirements but after being sent by Kuma to Mihawk's island, meeting up with Zoro in the aftermath of the Saobody arc after he got sent there too and helping him get back to the Straw Hats as well as helping them escape, I thought she could develop the other requirements for joining as they went along. Maybe we might've gotten a tragic backstory for her later to explain why she joined Moria's crew in the first place.

[Tenroshou]

At the moment Bonney also fullfills all criteria. Bonney could be the Cabin Girl of the ship. I really hope she will become part of the crew, cause Jesus that backstory of hers and Kumas hits hard.

[echidnaburger]

I would have loved it if Katakuri joined the crew if only to see him and Luffy pull off some badass tag-team stretchy combo attacks

[JDubs]

Johnny and Yosaku knew if they joined the crew it would be too easy. They chose to stay back and defend Cocoyashi Village, using their power for a better cause

13:45 something to note here is not only was he bullied, but when he retaliated, one of his siblings, someone he held closer to him than anybody else, was permanently scarred as revenge. Katakuri's backstory is better stated as having the power to defend himself, but needing to hide who he was and isolate himself out of fear for his siblings safety

[geebeepman]

I've only thought of vivi, carrot and yamato possibly joining the strawhats. the rest on this list hasn't once crossed my mind as actual potential crewmates, only temporarily sailing with the strawhats at most.

[jordanhamel]

Bon Clay has the obvious role of Spy for the crew, and i can see that having been useful in many situations. Cant say for certain if he had much of a goal tho

[ethancameron]

Would love to see a “What if luffy continued his journey with the crew he gained in impel down?”

[sungodrj]

I understand why Yamato didn’t join the Straw Hats straight away but it’s still sad. I personally believe 100% that Yamato and Vivi will join before Luffy gets the One Piece since they’ve both been acknowledged by the entire crew already.

Luffy also told them that if they ever wanted on the Marry/Sunny that there’s a seat waiting for them both 😁

[Soress]

Carrot did lose a lot of friends when Kaido attacked their city. She also wanted to go on an adventure so she felt like a perfect fit.

[PrimeTime]

During Skypeia i kinda hoped Wyper would join the crew. He had the backstory, he had a character arc when he almost killed himself to destory the beanstalk, he was similar level to Zoro, and would introduce another race. Only thing he lacked was the motive - there was no real reason to join

[wgs]

Bon Clay could be a spy espionage and disguise is his specialty making information gathering and deception easier he was decently strong and definitely had potential to be on Zoro or Sanji’s level if he also learnt Haki he’s a Mad Lad Giga Chad who definitely deserves a spot

[UnknownDrago]

Yamato will join the straw hats in the future 100%

Source: trust me bro

[mateusfranco]

Fun fact, Oda has confirmed that the plan was to Yamato become a Strawhat, but he changed it cuz it's already hard to write in things for everyone in the crew to do (that's one of the reasons why we almost always get the crew split in groups), so it would have made it worse to have to give more space to someone

[marceloasensiofilho]

I miss Carrot as the lookout and she is the character I am the most dissappointed did not join the crew. I really like her personality and how she interacts with the rest of the crew

[dfootball]

As someone who has just finished the Alabasta, I literally teared up when Vivi decided to stay behind. She got along so well with literally everybody, everyone loved her, and I just felt like seeing another female candidate joining the crew. Perfect candidate to join the crew and I'd put her number 1, but I haven't even seen Yamato yet so maybe I'll change my mind.