Is Ninten Ness’ Dad?

#earthbound #nintendo #shorts

[lavagamer]

I’m pretty sure Ness’ dad is just a phone.

[airayamamoto]

Can you talk about the theory that Lloyd is Dr. Andonuts. I don’t think it’s true at all unfortunately because of the timeline but I wish it was.

The fact that Lloyd hides in a trash can in Mother 1 and Dr. Andonuts does the same in Mother 3 has been a fun detail that’s stuck with me. If they were the same person then it’d be cool to have a character who has appeared in all 3 Mother games other than some enemies.

Also wanted to say, thank you for your content and keeping Mother/EarthBound in my mind. I love the series a lot but haven’t been as into it as I was a fair few years ago. Keep up the great work and let’s keep praying that Nintendo will do something with the series in the near future 🙏

[AvatarNeo]

You probably expected this, but I would love to see an annihilation of the Giygas abortion theory. It is by far the worst video game theory I have ever seen.

[Exeggutorking]

Paul and Linda from mother 3 are related to orange kid and apple kid

[ManBird]

I think that since Ninten was so well known and popular due to his victory over Giygas that Ness was simply inspired by Ninten's outfit. It's kinda like the situation in Pokemon Let's Go Pikachu and Eevee where MC took inspiration from Red since he was Kanto's greatest champion.

[fishdubx]

Not really a theory and definitely more of a headcanon, but I've always thought of Hinawa being born in Twoson before moving to the Nowhere Islands. This is because I've always thought the opening part of Mom's Hometown sounds awfully similar to the Twoson theme. But then again no one's ever pointed that out so maybe it's just me.

[madmikefollower]

Can you talk about the Dragon reset and remixed the world of Earthbound and Mother 3 theory into Earthbound beginnings explaining the strange similarities and inconsistencies between both worlds especially since Giegue promises to after Ninten again

[paraaurum]

People are obsessed with video game timelines. It’s like a drug too them.

[trainianAB]

I think Mother 1 actually took place in early 1980 could be wrong tho

[SuperSoupC]

I have a debate you could cover for a future short/video:

Are the starmen mechanical or biological beings?

[daneml]

If you want to make it work you can just assume there were more time travel shenanigans off screen

[pksprite]

199X isn’t even a real year, I think one could be excused for brushing off the age issues.

[Noodlez-zoup]

I like to think that there is a way for ninten to be related just because they both use psi and have magic, but its definitely not through family

[Tatzebea]

Plot twist, Ninten and Ness have the same father x3

[Skypatroller_BenCD]

Try to mistbuff the theory saying that Ness is the hot-dog vender.
Also to my opinion I did believe in this theory at 50% I've never said it was real but maybe it could

[momoplayoor]

I don't think Ninten is Ness' Father, but isn't there timetravel in Earthbound/ Mother? If you'd want to be annoying you could probably come up with an argument in that direction lol

[DolphLOL]

If Ninten was Ness' father, Ana would be her mother but it's not.

[springcheese]

Hmmm… but if the X in 199X is a placeholder for another number then what if the full year is 19930?

[victor_f]

22:49 the moon looks so weird in this shot, is that even the moon???

[maneruloquendero]

I read somewhere that Alec was Ness in adulthood