The Governor vs Negan Smith

[puneetsansanwal]

Governor was really a villain but Negan was an antagonist

[fuzzboi]

The governor was way more terrifying than negan. I saw a comment on another video about these two and it was something like "the governor is psychopath wearing a man's mask and negan is man wearing a psychopath's mask"

[V]

The governor was pure evil and broken beyond repair. Negan was able to be saved

[realUlfricStormcloak]

You forget when Governor 1v1ed Merle (who was pretty much a gladiator in Woodbury) and bit his fingers off? Governor is not only skilled in a general combat capacity, but he's also scrappy as hell. He even completely dominated Rick 1v1. Rick was turning blue from strangulation. Rick wouldve been GONE in S4 if not for Michonne's sword. Which it took him a long time to die, the girl had to shoot him in the head. Sword clean through the back and out the chest. So he gets durability points too.

[Sniffed]

I loved the governor he was the perfect villain

[brantleymovieeditsandmore]

I say governor. He legit almost killed Rick if michelle didn’t save the day. Negan had an army and ran from Rick. The governor didn’t give a rats ass to come kill rick. He brought a tank that hardly worked and he brought a few men. Governor underrated af

[aydingharehbaghian]

The governor takes strength, stamina, shooting while negan takes melee fight, firearms, community, charisma, funny

[m.t.d]

Governor was a monster. He nearly killed Rick.

[victorcreed_]

I love Negan but Governor Claps High DIFF

[earnem]

Governor has durability. Got his arm shot, still was using it to punch

[taskmaster]

Endurance governor💀:the bastard received a bullet in the arm, the arm with which he would beat rick in a 1v1 and almost no injuries despite receiving good blows from rick, and after being pierced with a katana he was still alive🗿

[eggman]

Stop overrating Negan man tbh The Governor seems stronger.

[DizzyAkira]

Durability goes to Phillip. Dude got stabbed in the eye, shot and he lost his daughter. He even lost his daughter twice in his sick mind but he still doesn't gave up.

[CHRISTALGIA]

I’m
sorry but after watching the governors performance on the show vs negans on the show, I would say the governor feels way more terrifying to not wanna mess with especially if being alone with him just waiting for him to turn on you and easily get pissed to kill you as he does just getting unhinged around others. Guy can take over a group kill his own and make a new one and manipulate people he just met into getting what he wants for only himself and for pure evil . Dude goes far enough to bit a guys fingers off and stare at walkers heads is just crazy enough . Negan only felt scary when having a shit ton of people in a group that surrounds him to where no one could defend them self from him to where his people would quickly grab a hold of you and put you down for him to deal with you afterwards as he smiles for ig to be that easy when dealing with a new enemy . If it wasn’t for him having that kind of celebrity protection and the numbers in his group people wouldn’t easily fear him that much and would take more chances standing up to him to wanna start attacking and so forth. I know negans way worse overall in the comics over the governor than in the show but I would say the governor’s way worse theh negan just show wise . As what we’ve seen with the governor fighting he kicks ass with holding his own especially with one eye with all he’s done . Has his own music and everything . The name of the governors final episode with him dying was titled too far gone wich he was literally too far gone with how evil and lost of humanity he had become . They got negan still on the show being even lucky to be alive to have changed over time with this negan redemption ark story with him now being apart of the group and trying to be a better human being as the governor was a hand full wich he killed more of our og characters in ricks side then negan did . And considering the governor and negan from the comics are both villains, a lot of people are love hating negan compared to the governor people simply just hated him and got nervous and emotional in intense scene’s when he was about to do something to one of our characters . That’s the feeling you get when you see a villians performance on the show like the governor

[Rcapo]

IQ and Battle IQ goes to the Governor, he managed to defeat Rick multiple times with pretty smart cunning tactics such as the Bread Truck with Walkers in it, or the time when he decisively able to raise and train an army the Saviors under Negan were mostly bad people who had families yes but mostly were bad people who just didn’t care about other lives and were experienced in fighting. Meanwhile the army of Woodbury had regular citizens which were trained pretty damn well, I personally believe plot armor is what made them loose. Other feats the Governor has is able to come back from the loss of his daughter which was turned and ended up running an entire group again taking leadership of it in a cunning way.

Negan is much more charismatic and has more competent lieutenants with micromanage his army and the Saviors, Negan is generally only there for the big things such as what we saw when he was bashing people’s heads in. He has more of a cult of personality to him and his people, his lieutenants controlled groups that joined the Saviors without them he’s nothing. The Governor meanwhile was able to easily manage his town and his army able to do military and domestic affairs while protecting their borders with general success, Milton Mamet helped the Governor with domestic and scientific affairs but mostly it was the Governor’s ideas. I believe Negan also was simply influenced by Eugene’s good old mr smart man Southern talking acting like a scientist but in reality he was playing Negan.

The Governor was able to make use of a civilian army to defeat U.S Military veterans, while being able to keep people in his town and make it prosperous being organized and well developed the Saviors were more or a rough rider organization that followed their lieutenants such as Simon.

We also have to realize that Negan relies more on scare tactics than actual military tactics, as he believes people will submit to him if he bashes one person’s head in or a few spreading fear amongst the people or well the Saviors and their protectorates such as the Hill top or the Kingdom. Generally Negan just has a charismatic personality to him while being a leader makes him form a cult of personality around him. The Governor is a statistics, tactics, and strategic person who knows what he is doing and is able to be successful in how he does it. The battle of the prison was basically a strategic victory for the Governor even though he died, he basically forced Rick to abandon the prison and Rick’s group basically was cut down till they reached Alexandria.

Overall IQ and Battle IQ goes to the Governor.

[akiratrolliyama]

Governor folds negan like a lawn chair.

[lincolntopez]

Bro the way they both move/tilt their heads before earn a point is genius editing

[lancehunter]

Rick was always badass! back when he was at war with the Governor, but wasn't as strong during the era of the governor as he was with Negan. The fight with the governor is what makes Rick stronger, and prepares him for Negan and other villains.

[Quzema]

Bruh Governor is tall and strong. He clapped S4 Rick

[GRsChannel]

Negan is one of the coldest characters in TWD 🥶🥶🥶