Old BFDI Theory 9: Loser and Winner's Past

thumbnail by @Nellymellow

[smething.moonlit]

I know this is two months old but I still wanna put my theory!

Loser and Winner had a decent childhood, being friends and all that. The two loved the idea of being famous together, so that’s what they did! Perform, do tours, livestream, etc.
However, gaining fans means also gaining haters. And dear *god* their fanbase was toxic. Winner was incredibly uncomfortable with the fans, but Loser didn’t mind. Or at least, until the paper maché incident.
While Loser didn’t like his art being destroyed, he still kept his cool. However, Winner was done with it all. They told Loser about how they wanna quit, and Loser decides that he could just perform by himself, just for Winner’s mental health. Winner accepts that idea, and they both promised to still hang out with eachother. And uh, they didn’t hang out with eachother after that. Especially after Loser went mainstream.
Winner still wanted to be friends with Loser, they didn’t him as someone to perform or tour with, just someone to eat chicken nuggets with! Loser on the other hand completely forgot Winner. He left his past behind, including his past friend.

[danielmeredith-stein]

I wanna do my theory too!!

Basically my theory is that Winner never really liked being in the spotlight, but they were willing to do it with Loser because they were best friends. It was always worth it to Winner because them and Loser got to spend a lot of time together. But when Loser found out about BFDI and tried to force Winner to join with him, Winner did not want to because they did not like being in the spotlight. They had an argument and Loser went solo without Winner, while Winner faded into obscurity and tried to put their past behind them.

[maryjanedeguzman]

Loser chose fame over Winner, When Loser asked Winner about the Loser-Cake movie contract, Winner rejects it because it could too much, this breaks Loser, ends up going solo, Winner tried to perform with others but it wasn’t the same.

[mytube]

I think it was simply because Winner didn't want to do shows anymore and Loser went along with it and they both went solo

[lindarabot]

in all honesty i like the 2nd theory about loser being taken under winners wing only to completely overshadow sohim. my personal theory is that the reason the 2 of them split up...was because of the runner up.
think about loser and winner
loser= nice and righteous with a hidden ego
winner= polit and soft spoken who focuses on friends instead of fans
the 2 of them sound like lightning McQueen and the king you know whose missing?
we have a loser, a champion all thats missing is the runner up chic hicks meaning he was likely a douche bag.

runner up= kind on the surface but only to his fans and the prez with a humungous ego that fits inside his big fat swollen head.
so here is what happened many many years ago in the early days of bfdis youtube winner loser and runner up where a trio but when they heard about an object show commericial winner chose loser to star with him because he took a liking to the rookie. runner up fueled with jealousy and a lack of spot light managed to do something that would ruin there careers which results in runner up retiring and basking in his glory with everyone forgetting him like a retired rockstar, winner seemingly fading into abscurity aka he flopped his last preformance and quit the business and loser entering mainstream aka getting a dineco sponsorship

[CheekyGrinzz]

5:19 I'm not sure if anybody had mentioned this but Loser and Winner are a certain substance and not just a cube and some icecream/sand thing. In bfdi (season 1) correct me if I'm wrong when the announcer said the losing team will take one from the losers team there are two substances labeled winners and losers. Both Winner and loser are a little chunk of that substance thus far them being named that so Loser's name has nothing to deal with his childhood.

[tabletgenesis]

TPOT 10 explains it. Winner thought Loser was going too far.

[yenda]

therapist: Human looser doesnt exist, he cannot hurt you!
Human Loser: 5:!2

[Spider_Rat]

Theory:
Winner and loser were doing there normal thing doing tours and stuff like that when all off a sudden loser and winner start arguing then the show starts but winner wants to be alone with out loser so winner doesnt go on the show but watches it they see that people like loser more and leaves forever

[dominoteodosio]

Theory about 2,
If you have noticed 2 is a nice guy and has a battle for their power, but as seen at the end of TPOT 1 (or 2) 2 is being beaten up, despite limitless power, and as referring to the start, probably doesn’t want to use it for bad, like 4, and X as seen at the end of The Great Goiakan Bake-Off, and is likely having a battle for his power because he may at least accidentally use it for bad, and so he can see who is worthy to win the power. This is seen in how it is possibly true, in 2, 000, 000 subs, as he accidentally helped 14 cause damage.

[Katey]

Winner explained a little but of that in tpot 10

[MalachiReds]

I think both winner and losers parents hated music and hated them preforming together, so Losers parents moved out away from winner.Winner and Loser miss each other so much.

[Hawkmoth]

here’s what really happened (spoiler alert) in the new episode tpot 10 after the s with clock finally found winner he started to talk about is past with loser they both became famous because of a game named loser cake is the same game as spongy cake but rapresent loser and everyone start cheering winner and loser name loser was happy but winner was just happy for him they also tour together got a job from announcer and do a ride with a cool car together the crown was getting bigger and bigger and loser wanted more he wanted to be with winner in a movie tv paper news i mean everywhere until loser got a contract for making a movie loser was really happy but winner didn’t want this because he wanted a normal life then loser walk away. winner didn’t see him in a while but when he checks online he was shock cause he performed without him and now loser cake wasn’t winner and loser game anymore he was loser game winner try to peform with other people but didn’t work as plan and left in the shadows.

[Whynaut_do_crime]

Loser is named loser cause hes named after whats hes made from which is caller loser

It was a prop from one of the epiodes where there were a pile of winner and loser subtance representing if tl a contestant were in the lowest 2 the wonners could take in a loser

[caratv]

I know this video is 5 months old but here is my theory. Winner and Loser were brother and sisters, they loved preforming together, eating chicken nuggets together and just having fun together in total.
One day, Loser started getting more popular than Winner, this also means the fame got to him. Winner told Loser to take a break from preforming but he wouldn't listen and out of a fit of rage, he pushed Winner aside to continue making videos. At this point Winner had reached her breaking point and had a mental breakdown backstage, packed her stuff and left. A few months later, Loser went to check on Winner to apologise but it was to late, she had already left and she is not coming back anytime soon. Loser now always puts a smile on his face to hide the pain he goes through thinking how he could betray his sister
That is the theory, hope you enjoyed and have a good day╰(*°▽°*)╯😀

[Lolo_]

5:17 What about Cake's dad from BFDI Mini DELICIOUS? huh?

[Reallyroug]

I always thought that the paper kicky thing was the losers kicking the paper to make it take shape

[Smg_simp]

Well, we can finall toss some theories in the garbage thanks to tpot 10 lol.

[garyoconnor]

Here’s my guess (and also a Headcanon)
Winner had anger issues, which made doing shows a hassle over time, as they would get angry over the tiniest change to the script, then loser would decide that he and winner were no longer able to tour together and that he would hit the mainstream

[emulorgamer]

Winner and Loser are probably enemies after Winner faded out of the spotlight