A Girl Can marry a boy without Father Consent, Dr. Zakir Naik Question and Answer

[AreeeAsh]

Isnt it such hypocrisy that parents use islamic rules just when they are convenient but avoid them when it is inconvenient for them. I see so many forced or pressured marriages in Pakistan while marriage without the permission of parents is highly frowned upon. Hypocrisy to its fullest.

[Adolf_wizzermen]

I am sure some of these girls got excited after hearing that look at the smile on their faces.

[shabeershumsudheen]

The girl can choose and try to convince her father. Willingness of the girl is important

[BilalZafarShow]

He didn't answer the question. We know that the willingness of the girl is important. What we need to know is "is the willingness of the wali a prerequisite to a girl's marriage or not?" Also, if he says yes a girl can marry without her wali's consent, then what about the hadees that means la nikah without wali

[VIPshofol]

Here Dr Zakir Naik Sir, smartly avoid the direct answer. He told only that A girl can reject. But didn't clearly tell that girl can marry without Father Consent.

[shakeelbaloushi]

This permission issue can be sorted easily if these scholars, muftis, ulamas, preachers would start bashing those fathers who force their choice on their daughters without their consent and reject their choice without any valid reasons, 'Muhammad PBUH nulliefied a such marriage' which makes all such forced marriages null and so those fathers are pushing their daughters to commit zina

[soniaparvin]

(With all respect)... He didn’t give proper Answer... Without wali marriage is INVALID.. May Allah give us wisdom and forgive us.

[sheikhhajee]

Islam is Amazing mashallah that is the Power of a Woman to choose a right man❤

[sheikhhajee]

Mashallah prophet muhammad s.a.w know the best&Allah ❤❤

[FruityFarterSG]

j think she asked about permission of wali but u didn't address that aspect

[muhammadalisiddiqui]

Dua kariyega aap sab mere liye, main ek bohot acha ladka hun, Maine NEET first attempt me qualify Kara hai, Rahi baat caste ki jo Islam me nhi hai, woh bhi nhi hai kuch, lekin pata nahi kyu uska rishta pehle se Tai Kiya ja Raha hai jabki woh abhi 12th hi pass Kari hai....we love each other, mtlb hug waghera nahi kra, jitna Pak rkh skte the rkha, uske parents bohot conservative hai aur sunne ko ready nhi hai, plz meri madad karein ❤❤❤dua kriye❤❤

[sanajaved]

Kyaa sirf aik gawah ki mojudi main or koi b na ho 1 gawah lrka or lrki to kyaa 1 gawah k smne wo aik dusre ko qabool kre to nikkah ho jye ga?

[JahannamHellfire]

Nowdays you cant trust noone also never, never and never do a secret nikah. Never marry in secret because your opening the doors to get abused, the person may cheat you, lies, tricking into polygamy marriages, may have other boyfriends and girlfriends. Tell the world who your marrying. Meet her/his family, relatives and friends. If he/she say let's do a secret nikah, say never.

[aqsa]

I did nikkah without my parents permission, they want me to marry in cousin circle because of their respect .now they are not accepting it because they say it is not a valid nikkah. What should we do now?

[shihanpk]

please reply

It was reported from Sälib bin Kaisãn, from Näfi' bin Jubair bin Mut'im, from Ibn 'Abbãs, that the Messenger of Alläh # said:
"The guardian has no command over the previously married lady, and the orphaned girl is asked.
And her silence is regarded as her consent." (Sahih)

Does this interpret that wali is not mandatory for nikah if women is divorcee?

[whocares]

What if her father is Christian and abusive of her because of being a Muslim now, but we want to marry should we need his approval

[foodbeautyandlife]

Not only parents even low is also doing this koi bhi low middle-class log k liye nhi banta ya to ameer ka faida ya to gareeb ka faida only for vote bihar me to bahut zyada

[ImranMostly]

NOT TRUE according to vast majority of scholars, 3 madhabs and ahle sunnah wal jamaa. As Rasul SAW said "Whichever woman married without the permission of her Wali her marriage is invalid, her marriage is invalid, her marriage is invalid." (Jami` at-Tirmidhi 1102). Only the hanafi madhab allows such marriage.

[tanveeralam]

Question is about apple, answer is about orange..Not a good answer I say..

[nofunwithoutfood]

Marrying the same man twice without ever hetting divorced is it permissible?