Best Drugstore Brow Pencils

This might not be the most exciting category to review but let's talk about the best drugstore brow pencils. I wanted to make sure that each of these included more than 4 shades each with different undertones. Hopefully, you will find something new from this list!

PRODUCTS:

e.l.f Cosmetics Ultra Precise Brow Pencil (Neutral Brown):

Ulta Beauty Ultra Slim Brow Pencil (Dark Brown):

NYX Fill & Fluff Eyebrow Pencil Pomade (Brunette):

L'oreal Brow Stylist Definer (Taupe):

COME SAY HI:

[cindyt]

Thanks for your review, it was not boring at all! I was especially looking for reviews on eyebrow pencils for Asian skin/hair so it was just what I needed. Going to CVS and Ulta to try them out!

[michellekelly]

My favourite drug store brow pencil is the retractable CoverGirl Easy Breezy Micro-Fine and Define eyebrow pencil. I use the shade Soft Brown which is a medium brown cool toned shade. It has replaced my Anastasia Brow Wiz in the shade Medium Brown. They also have Soft Blond, Honey Brown (warm), and a darker shade, Rich Brown, which is also cool toned. I've been really happy with this brow pencil. It's difficult to find cool toned brow pencils at the drug store. The price is also amazing when compared to Anastasia.

[verysabi]

I needed this thank you brows are definitly not boring to me

[marydanielle]

Loved this, I’ve never bought a eyebrow pencil and this just showed me that my idea to try elf first was a good one. Thank you!

[noellewright]

True, not glamorous but those of us who don't go anywhere without their eyebrows on appreciate the quest for the perfect pencil! Thanks for the comparisons.

[korrinarobinson]

I bought the nyx and woreit for 12 hours at the hospital I work at( I am a respiratory therapist) it wore off at the ends of my brows, I have very sparse brows, but I am so happy I came across this video, I will try the Ulta brand!!!

[dyannamoore]

Thanks so much! You are so cute and helpful! I'm going to try the Ulta Beauty one. I'm tired of paying $26 for the Benefit brow pencil.

[yolandaslade]

Yesterday I just purchased the e.l.f brown pencil and I love it!

[varbie]

U need to try Milani brow pencils! Not too creamy.

[natalietran]

Hi! Great post! Loving your lip colour, may you share what you're wearing?

[zanetwiesman]

Mae, have you tried Ulta's beauty Brow Lift Laminating Gel yet? I watched your video with all the different ones but the Ulta's one is not in there. I did get Ulta's pencil and yes, I am impressed. I love the Huda Beauty one, have been using that for some time and cannot complain. I tried the Covergirl gel, and my brows are not holding up. I am thinking to get the Refy one. You did a review a couple of years ago and it looks pretty good.

[Melycast]

I like the shape of your eyebrows before the pencils. I think you draw them too high, imo.

[Ohkeh]

What foundation and concealer are to wearing here? And what shades?

[petersburgtug]

Tell me you stopped buying from Ulta when they interviewed abbot about what it’s like to be one of us.

[Ohkeh]

I need a dupe for Anastasia Beverly Hills brow wiz in medium brown. Anyone?