COFFEE OPINION - Flavor Notes Must Be Stopped

As a coffee roaster, a barista, and a consumer I have a lot of thoughts on flavor notes and tasting coffee. It's a topic I deal with daily, but not a conversation thats had in the open. So in this video I'll talk about what flavor notes are, if we should expect to taste them, if some are more of a marketing ploy, and if we should move away from the hyper specific notes.

↓COFFEE ROASTED BY ME↓

↓FOLLOW FOR MORE↓

↓THE MUSIC↓
Needs - Nolai

#flavornotes #coffee #sprometheus

[rampari]

An interesting idea I just had: Broad categories like that Kickapoo coffee and also something like a scratch-off bit at the back with more specific flavours. So you get some idea about the coffee when you buy it and after you've tasted the best the coffee has to offer, you can scratch off that bit to see what notes the roasters and graders tasted.

[davidhunternyc]

I love this rant! The coffee industry has been getting away with hype for too long. Who made the infamous "Andean Red Custard Rambutan" peaberry coffee? That was my favorite. It tasted like coffee.

[SuperSomphon]

This is perfect. I'm so sick of reading the complicated tasting notes on the bag. Especially those that are cultural or regional specific. Roasters should know, not all their customers have the same life experience. It also posting a bit of obnoxious in the label. I seriously doubt if most of us can 100% replicate it in home environment. If they want to claim such notes, they should come and make it for us LOL

[HandsomePuggg]

Thank you for making this video, I’ve been starting to think either my sense of taste is off or my brew method isn’t where it should be as I can rarely taste the flavour notes on a bag. As someone that’s fairly new to specialty coffee, I find flavour notes both appealing (peach notes sounds good) and disappointing (I can’t taste any peach!). You’ve restored some confidence in me, I’ll definitely be taking those notes with a bigger pinch of salt!

[taiglish]

Thanks for making this video and it describes what I have been thinking for the last few years now. I have been a coffee enthusiast for more than a decade, always experimenting with different sources and brewing methods. For the first few years I tried very hard to "find" the flavour notes as suggested by the roasters and probably failed to taste 70% of them. I blamed it on my lackluster tastebuds. I've now come full circle and believe those are mostly marketing tactics and more often than not do nothing to enhance my experience and enjoyment of my cup of coffee!

[ozzyaararon]

Thank you! As home barista that's been really into coffee for 20 years I thought I was a failure. I mean I never tasted these crazy flavours at really good cafes either, but I thought if I just kept tweaking I'd be able to taste these odd flavours but I never could. I think this lets me relax and just appreciate good coffee! Once in a while I make a cup that seems perfect to me, I can ignore now that I didn't get any hints of clementine orange peel coming through ...

[davidf]

I have seen a roaster that uses stars as a guide
Sweet
Acidity
Bitter **
Body *
That so far was my favorite way of coffee description

[abdullahalkhalaf]

I think that some flavor notes are really clear in the coffee such as grapes or berries. But some are really just to get our attention

[fiftythreeeleven]

"At night, when the jasmine blooms, a pretty deck of playing cards dissolves into layers of petals. The petals lie on a table in a tropical grove of papaya and pinapple. Mimosas are served."

[krakencoffeeroasters]

Agree with this SO MUCH. It is like being told that a movie (you haven't seen yet) is the BEST EVER. Your expectations are set so high that you can hardly help but be disappointed. (Odds are, anyway). Also, people don't all have the taste sensitivity, so what a Q Grader might taste and what I might taste are definitely two different things. I think some roasters do what they do on their labels just because they see somebody else doing it and copy it, without thinking it through. Or they mimic the green coffee sellers notes - which may be highly dependent upon the degree of roast. My coffee label (Cottage Food microroastery) is very minimalist. I'd like people to taste it and decide for themselves what they are tasting. The ultimate compliment is when they come back and order more!

[erraticbro]

One concept not mentioned in the video is the roasters using the phrase "this coffee reminds us of...". I really like this style of listing the notes, as it doesn't force the consumer to feel a certain way about their own experience, but rather presents a simple opinion of the roaster, and can lead the consumer in the right direction when purchasing coffee

Great video!

[paropa]

When I worked at a cafe / roaster in Vancouver, we had a coffee with the note, “Burgundian forest floor” hahahahaha

[MattyRocco]

This just in: the diner down the street that says "worlds best diner" isn't actually the worlds best diner. Everything about coffee packaging is a marketing ploy. I totally agree with the points you're making.

[kakaisthecat]

I used to be turned down by some creative notes that I couldn’t taste. I thought it was because of my dumb taste buds or my awful brewing methods. Thanks for your video! Now I think what really matters by the end of the day is whether you like this coffee or not. The notes are just there to guide you to choose your favorite coffee!

[JT-zyft]

I actually find them useful when picking coffee. I prefer more tropical fruit forward coffees and looking at the tasting notes helps me in deciding which to pick. I’m aware that I’m not going to be able to taste everything described but the main flavors are usually there.

[corrda]

I really like Detour Coffee in Hamilton Ontario. They have a label art system where the shapes and colours on the bag roughly represent what the coffee tastes like. Sharper shapes are brighter and brighter colours are more acidic etc

[DavidLikesCoffee]

I recently had some coffee from Kickapoo and appreciated the more general descriptions. After dialing it in I went on their website out of curiosity to find more specific flavor notes and it was fun to see how they compared with what I tasted. At the end of the day, I think general notes are pretty easy to agree upon and beyond that it comes down to personal experiences & memories for the super specific things.

[leroythecoffeegeek]

I’m much the same and that’s good advice really. I will often use flavour notes to choose a coffee to buy, but then do my best to forget them before the first time I brew it. This is usually pretty easy if it’s being shipped to me and doesn’t arrive for a couple of days. I then always try the coffee at least once before going back to check the descriptors on the bag and sometimes I might get through a whole bag without referring to them. It’s interesting to compare, but I never get hung up on it If I don’t taste the same qualities in my cup.

[ganweidi]

I'm frustrated when I can't taste the fruity notes as written on the package, so out of curiosity I added a little orange zest during extraction, and it works superbly well, although I'm breaking the rules but the end result is amazing. Anyway I only use it to salvage coffee that had slightly lost its freshness.

[josuesantanna]

Interesting considerations! Many times I've seen labels on the bag that "go too far". It's hard to be so specific when every customer has personal, cultural, and geographical perceptions for something that's supposed to be the same taste, but they don't feel that on the same coffee.