Understanding Thread Behavior in pthreads: Fixing Erratic Execution with pthread_join

Discover why your `pthread` threads might not execute reliably and learn how to correctly join threads in C++. Find out how to eliminate the need for `sleep()` with the right implementation.
---

Visit these links for original content and any more details, such as alternate solutions, latest updates/developments on topic, comments, revision history etc. For example, the original title of the Question was: Threads appear to run randomly.. Reliable only after slowing down the join after thread creation

If anything seems off to you, please feel free to write me at vlogize [AT] gmail [DOT] com.
---
Understanding Thread Behavior in pthreads: Fixing Erratic Execution with pthread_join

When diving into C++ and threading, developers often face unexpected behavior, especially with the pthreads library. In this post, we’ll discuss a common issue where threads seem to run randomly, often executing only one thread in certain conditions. This problem might lead to confusion and frustration—after all, a thread's purpose is to execute tasks concurrently, not erratically! Let's roll up our sleeves and disentangle this issue.

The Problem: Erratic Thread Execution

In a provided code snippet, a programmer attempts to create and join two threads using pthreads. However, the execution seemed inconsistent. When the line sleep(1) was commented out, only one of the two threads executed reliably; adding sleep appeared to solve the problem. But relying on sleep in concurrent programming isn’t an ideal solution and can lead to inefficiencies. So, what went wrong?

Code Review: Key Elements to Understand

The primary function of the code snippets below is to create threads that print values and modify parts of a shared structure. Here's a simplified breakdown of the relevant sections:

Initialization of Data Structures: The program initializes an array of structures.

Thread Creation: It creates two threads that attempt to run concurrently.

Thread Joining: It attempts to wait for both threads to finish their execution.

The main focus in the error scenario lies within the pthread_join function, which is crucial for properly synchronizing the threads to ensure both complete their execution.

The Solution: Correcting pthread_join Usage

The error stems from an improper use of pthread_join(). Instead of passing the thread identifier (ID), the code mistakenly passes the return value from pthread_create(). This is a critical mistake. Here’s the step-by-step resolution:

Step 1: Correct the Thread Join Call

Change the code from:

[[See Video to Reveal this Text or Code Snippet]]

To the correct form:

[[See Video to Reveal this Text or Code Snippet]]

Why This Matters

Thread Identifiers: pthread_create returns a status code. To enforce synchronization, pass the thread ID into pthread_join. This tells the program which thread to wait for.

Behavior Fix: When executed with the correct IDs, the threads will synchronize as intended, without the erratic behavior or the need for a sleep delay.

Step 2: Consider Switching to std::thread (Optional)

Since this code is noted as C++, a modern approach is to use std::thread from the C++ standard library. It encapsulates thread management, making it easier and safer to handle than the raw pthreads functions.

Here's a brief snippet using std::thread:

[[See Video to Reveal this Text or Code Snippet]]

Benefits of Using std::thread

Simplified Syntax: Easier to read and maintain.

Safety Features: Better type-checking and destructibility (RAII principles).

Cross-Platform: Works seamlessly across different operating systems.

Conclusion: Threads Made Reliable

If you've ever found yourself scratching your head over erratic thread execution, remember: the ability to join threads properly is paramount in achieving reliable concurrency. By switching from the status return value to the correct thread ID in pthread_join, you'll eliminate unexpected behaviors seen in the initial code.

In modern C++, consider transitioning to std::thread for greater ease and reliability in handling threads. Your future self will thank you.

Happy coding, and may your threads always synchronize flawlessly!