Understanding the pop() Function: Does it Really Remove Elements from an Array?

Dive into the mechanics of the `pop()` function in C++ and discover whether it truly removes elements from an array or simply changes the index.
---

Visit these links for original content and any more details, such as alternate solutions, latest updates/developments on topic, comments, revision history etc. For example, the original title of the Question was: In the following code, does pop() actually removes the item from the array 'num' or the item still exists inside the 'num'?

If anything seems off to you, please feel free to write me at vlogize [AT] gmail [DOT] com.
---
Understanding the pop() Function: Does it Really Remove Elements from an Array?

When working with data structures in programming, one common question that arises is regarding the behavior of the pop() function, particularly in the context of arrays in C++. Many developers may wonder: Does the pop() function actually remove an item from the array, or does it merely change the pointing index? In this guide, we'll explore this question in detail, breaking down the functionality of the pop() method and its implications for data stored in arrays.

The pop() Function Explained

In the code snippet provided, we can see the implementation of the pop() function within a stack structure. Here’s a quick look at the key components of the function:

[[See Video to Reveal this Text or Code Snippet]]

Breakdown of the Code

Check if the Stack is Empty:

The function starts with a check to see if the stack is empty. If it is, it returns a placeholder value of -9999 (which could be improved with better error handling).

Retrieve the Top Element:

If the stack is not empty, it stores the current top element of the array num into a temporary variable called temp. This allows the function to keep track of the element being popped.

Adjust the Index:

The top index of the stack is then decremented (--top), which effectively moves the pointer down to the next element in the stack.

Return the Popped Element:

Finally, the function returns the value stored in temp.

So, Does pop() Remove the Element?

Now, the critical question: Does calling pop() remove the element from the array? The answer is No. Here are the reasons why:

Arrays Have Fixed Sizes: In C++, arrays are declared with a fixed size and do not support dynamic resizing. This means once an array is created, the number of total elements it can contain remains constant throughout its lifetime. Therefore, elements cannot be "removed" in the traditional sense.

Element Still Exists: Although the index pointing to the top element is decremented, the actual value in the array remains intact. This means the item still occupies its space in memory, but it's no longer considered part of the active stack.

Logical Representation: The pop() function simply changes the logical view of the stack by moving the top index. The underlying array still holds the previous values, which can be visualized as follows:

Before pop():

[[See Video to Reveal this Text or Code Snippet]]

After pop():

[[See Video to Reveal this Text or Code Snippet]]

Conclusion

In summary, when working with the pop() function in a stack implemented using an array, it's crucial to understand that the function doesn't remove the element from the array. Instead, it simply alters the index pointing to the stack's top element. This means the previous elements remain in memory, even if they are no longer accessible through the stack's logical structure. Understanding this distinction can help prevent confusion and potential errors when managing data in C++.

By grasping these key concepts, you’ll be better equipped to manage stacks and other data structures effectively, leveraging their potential without running into common pitfalls.