BRUTAL MINECRAFT TIER LISTS!!

Tier lists in minecraft.. let me know what you think of my selections in the comments!

📲 SOCIAL MEDIA

💚 MEMBER |

#minecraft

[sweetalyn]

I love how Jimmy just keeps the Ranchers fans on life support with every "My Rancher" when talking about Double Life.

[macadoo]

12:25 I think an 'EVO 2' series would do well, if you guys were interested in doing that. It would be cool to see older versions of Minecraft in more polished modern YouTube videos. And you can ask Martyn, the Watchers lore is still EXTREMELY popular in fan spaces.

[Juniper]

No one can disagree that Last Life was a Goat Tier

[rubyyro]

I've noticed that a lot of the Life Series members (3rd Life) say Last Life is their favorite of the bunch, and from the perspective of a content creator and getting to play this amazing SMP with all your friends, I get why Last Life is a lot of people's fave, but gosh, Double Life was the first one I got to watch as it was being filmed/posted and I will never get over the love I have for that season. I love Double Life so much. It's 100% always gonna be my fave Life Series season (though, honestly, all 4 seasons are GOAT for me tbh)

[pinklover]

I personally like the nether woods, when the colour scheme is right.

[ethanskinner]

Low key, I prefer Season 1 over Season 2 because of the storyline. I'm a sucker for a deep story with lore. But I still hold both dear to me

[Zei_thatoneartist]

Birch is actually a really good wood if you know how to incorporate it into builds correctly

[joyrose]

Jimmy: *put Birtch wood on D and Warped wood on E*
Gem and Scott: So you have chosen death...


(Also, Crimson wood is my favorite, I will fight you bro!)

[Archivst]

1:13 in and he’s already put the birch stripped log in with oak instead of the oak door

Edit: and he just put the stripped mangrove in with the nether woods . . . Jimmy, learn your blocks!

[dawnsoisson]

I was starting to think that Jimmy didn’t remember that much of evo or that it wouldn’t be regarded as one of his top series because he gets confused every time the watcher lore is brought up in his reaction videos, but Jimmy’s experience with evo is proof that lore does not have to define a series. It’s about having fun with friends the lore just makes it more enjoyable for the viewers. And Jimmy just convinced me to go back and watch evo (nope can’t say that word about evo how do I avoid that word) from his perspective even though it’s very long and might take a while

[aquarius]

4:36 "And we like flower fields"
It's not dead guys there is still hope 🎉

[idioticbagel]

for me the auquatic update just brings me so much nostalgia because that’s around the time when i was old enough to really understand minecraft and the updates. before then i just played the game and every once in awhile there was a new update but around that time is when i started really tracking everything and stuff so it’s got a special place in my heart just for that. i’m a junior in hs now.

[gabrela]

I liked 3rd life's story the most out of the seasons. But last life definitely had the best mechanics

[Monster.Under.Your.Bed]

Unpopular opinion: acacia and birch are good woods

[admirerofcreativity]

I remember the evolution series so clearly! It was such a brilliant idea! I was following grian at the time, and it was that series that made me come here. You were such a good laugh in the evo series that I knew I needed to keep tabs on you and your channel.

The evo series would do amazing in the current YouTube environment! Heaven knows I still think about that time Grian blew you up with that TNT house.

[deygn]

Love seeing the Evo love. Personally Evo was how I got into Minecraft YouTube starting with Grian, and still remember Jimmy Martyn Pearl etc from it. Deserves its spot at the top.

[taytaythehufflepuff]

The life series rankings are always hard.
3rd Life is near and dear to my heart as it’s the first series that got me into watching a lot of MC youtubers (at the time I had only watched a handful of Grian videos and was consistently watching Joe Hills and Zombie Cleo (mostly livestreams).
Last Life was the season in which I got heavily involved with the fan community and had my favorite factions
Double Life was amazing, but lacked the storyline that I liked out of 3rd and Last Life. (But on rewatch, it’s my favorite. It’s the one that has stuck with me. Probably because Jimmy and Joel keep referencing the series even though we’re a year removed.)
Limited Life was good, but it felt rushed and confusing. Though team Clockers dynamic was amazing, chaotic, and out of left field.

At the end of the day, all 4 seasons have been great in their own regards. And each of them is special to me in their own unique way.

[DiseasedSqud]

Anyone else realise Jimmy put Stripped Birch wood in A and the rest of Birch in D? lol

[TrueSlugcat]

More life content?? Grian, Bdubs, AND Jimmy in one week, it’s definitely coming back.

[anarchygoose]

Hot take: Birch wood and birch biomes are at least A or B tier