Durchtrit, the tread through in I.33

preview_player
Показать описание
Talking about a point I made recently that the tread through is possibly another indicator of a circular system. Also that destreza is totally ripped off from I.33;)
  1. London Longsword Academy
  2. I.33
  3. hema
  4. fencing
  5. destreza
  6. movement of conclusion
Рекомендации по теме
Durchtrit, the tread 0:02:56

Durchtrit, the tread through in I.33

I.33: A Hands-on 0:05:54

I.33: A Hands-on Discussion on Durchtrit/Tread-Through

I.33 Sword & 0:12:41

I.33 Sword & Buckler: Durchtreten / Durchtritt / Tread-Through

I.33 Left Handed 0:00:12

I.33 Left Handed - 1rst play : Prima v/s Halpshilt - Durchtritt on the left

I.33 - Durchtreten: 0:04:46

I.33 - Durchtreten: A wide concept.

I.33 Sword and 0:02:58

I.33 Sword and Buckler: Nucken

I.33 Half-Shield Technique 0:00:09

I.33 Half-Shield Technique

I.33 Basics - 0:07:42

I.33 Basics - Defense against a direct cut

I.33 Basics: 3 0:04:57

I.33 Basics: 3 Ways to parry Thrusts

Demonstration of Krucke 0:01:26

Demonstration of Krucke (inside)

I.33 - The 0:04:14

I.33 - The Durchtreten (folio 2v)

I.33 Sword and 0:13:58

I.33 Sword and Buckler - Technical Sparring

Sword and Buckler 0:01:23

Sword and Buckler drill progression

Grappling in Sword 0:01:12

Grappling in Sword and Buckler I.33

SAF - Lignitzer's 0:10:01

SAF - Lignitzer's Stücke with Longsword

Mair’s Poleaxe One. 0:00:19

Mair’s Poleaxe One.

Backyard basics #10- 0:05:54

Backyard basics #10- Lignitzer’s sword and buckler 3-4 with longsword adaptations

I.33 Sword and 0:07:45

I.33 Sword and Buckler - Elbow and hand positions in the imagery

Overbind solodrill 0:01:46

Overbind solodrill

I.33 Langort part 0:08:12

I.33 Langort part I

I.33 Sword and 0:05:42

I.33 Sword and Buckler: Attacking first ward from halfshield

Atelier épée/bocle I.33 0:00:22

Atelier épée/bocle I.33 - stage AMHE La Roche sur Yon

Sword and Buckler 0:03:02

Sword and Buckler drill progression, 3rd

SoCal Swordfight 2020 0:00:42

SoCal Swordfight 2020 - Synthetic Longsword Finals - Highlights

Комментарии
Автор

Very interesting takes!!! Thanks for the share! I hope to post also my own interpretation (which is very similar btw!!) in the next months!

FedericoMalagutti
Автор

I believe you are right about the footwork. The way the buckler is used to defend the sword hand makes little sense if you aren't coming from a base of sword-foot forward. The step though, I believe contributes to some of the odd strike angles depicted (I don't concur with many that they must be thrusts).

I'd like to add, in your first play, your finishing strike could just as easily use the false edge with your hand twisted as in the pictures ("plunging blow"). I believe that arc you made naturally, but with a twist to use the false edge is the proper interpretation of the text, though people have come up with wildly different answers.

DkGaston
Автор

A question regarding I.33: I believe that Nick Thomas over at the Academy of Historical Fencing mentioned in one of his videos that I.33 does not perform favorably against Renaissance sword-and-buckler styles. Is this more the product of the Renaissance styles using longer swords with more hand protection, or is I.33 as a system simply worse? I have no actual experience doing HEMA, but I'm curious nevertheless.

InSanic
Автор

I still feel that wards 6 and 7 feel more natural left foot forward, and I fear that right foot forward keeps my left shoulder back a little far, making it feel awkward to also pull the sword back. Maybe I just need to get used to it though, you don't want to waste time shifting legs to what feels nicer.

EHilgy
Автор

Hi Dave, with your "right-foot forward system" how would you go about 5th ward, I tend to keep a little more distance, with the left foot forward

CapitanCarter