How to Make Buckeye Balls | Cookie Recipes | Allrecipes.com

Watch how to make the favorite candy of Ohio State. Peanut butter balls are dipped in chocolate for an irresistible treat!

Allrecipes Magazine is now available!

Facebook

Twitter

@Allrecipes

Pinterest

Instagram

[marettewoods]

Used this recipe for my bake sale at work and one guy bought the whole tray!!!  

[BKDocHoliday]

This has been a dessert staple in Ohio forever.

[allrecipes]

You may change the serving amount to whatever number you choose, Levelup 360. It's easy! You can do it for every Allrecipes recipe. Here's how to do it:
2) Click on the link to open the recipe page, and then under “Ingredients, ” find the line "Original recipe makes 2 cups" (or 6 dozen or 12 cookies, or whatever the finished amount is for each recipe).
3) Just to the right of this line, click on "Change Servings." A box will open where you can type in the number to change the number of servings (the original recipe's amount will automatically show in the box).
4) Type in the number of servings you want, and then click the box to the right that says “Adjust recipe.” All the ingredient amounts will immediately change to amounts needed—more or less—for the new number of servings.
Happy Baking!

[ACHEFBOYIBE]

Love these, and has been far too long since I made any.  My doc would likely disagree, but the key to these is eat sparingly... IF you can actually do that.  tasty!

[racheldeselms]

My mother in law makes these. They are awesome!

[tixslbc]

Allison Palmisciano Loves Buckeye Balls

[Parrtyyxo]

Last time I had there was in 98 and I can practically still taste them and smell them. I gotta make them tomorrow 🔥 🤤

[sarahjanefitemassey]

Very easy to follow I shall enjoy making them

[bonniecobb]

So easy to make great for your grandchildren can help

[slgleaton]

I usually make these at Christmas but don't add butter. None of the recipes I've seen have butter, but I guess it may make it creamier. Then I completely cover them in chocolate.

[jeffkallas]

Thanks for the video!  I just made my first batch for family and they came out GREAT!  Jeff

[debralynnbailey]

Yeah that sounds like a lot better plan just put it in your cookie sheet pan and then pour the hot the hot chocolate over it

[chenda]

how long should the dough ball stay in the refrigerator before dipping into the semi chocolate? thanks a million

[Donkilluminatii]

Just had some buckeyes for the first time couple of weeks ago that my neighbor made for me. I just tried this recipe. Absolutely delicious! I am just trying to figure out why my chocolate seemed so thin. Must have been something I did wrong. Other than that, SOOO GOOOD!

[lucymaze]

What is the purpose of sifting the sugar?

[jimgarrison]

Oooo I like the idea of the time saving way ! Sort of a fudge... The wax paper or parchment paper is probably critical in this recipe?

[leemizah]

Can I use nuttela instead of peanut butter?

[levelup]

Can you give me the recipe for only three balls because I want to try it before i waste my ingredients

[anihazirah]

what do you add in the chocolate chips during the double boils? And after dipped into the chocolate, the cookies already done?

[anthonynguyen]

For the dipping of the balls, could I use Reeses Bars and melt them, so I can get a chocolatey peanut butter dip?