Someone called 5-Star Arch Manning Overrated? | Arch Manning, Texas Football, Texas Longhorns, SEC

Someone called 5-Star Arch Manning Overrated? | Arch Manning, Texas Football, Texas Longhorns, SEC

Welcome to On3 | The best of college football and recruiting

Follow us on Twitter

Follow us on Instagram

Like/Follow us on Facebook

[jasonbarrientez]

The thing is he didn't do any camps which usually translate to stars bcz the recruiting experts don't have time to go to every hs game. So if u don't go rarely do u get 5star let alone a prefect rating. So his name did contribute to his rating

[markschneider]

Statistics are not everything but you did not even address them. And they are simply not impressive. Not even 2000 yards passing last year?

[AlmightyMauMau]

FYI, Eli, Peyton and Odell Beckham all played at the same school as Arch and they weren’t busts.

[guiltybyproxy]

I love how people say he would be a 3 star if he had a different last name, but they don't see that if he had a different last name but from the same family he would still have access to the best qb coaches, weight coaches, pro qb coaches and trainers, but sure, he'd be a "3 star" with all of that stuff at his disposal. People truly are the dumbest species, I swear.

Not to mention there have only been 6 perfect rated players by the services ever, and his damn sure isn't because of his last name. They don't give perfect ratings based on last names, they give them to who they believe are generational talents. All this nonsense is because he chose Texas and not the school they wanted him to choose.

[eyegetbaked]

Same dude a month earlier was talking about how good he was. Dudes a phony

[bigload]

Did he compare Bronny and basketball to arch manning ha. Look at the tape. He is no 5 star ha

[THEeeCOBRACOMMANDER]

You gotta thank your haters…

Hook’em 🐂

[jimmys]

Everyone in the comments are all professional scouts now talking about film. Pretty comical to say the least

[DavidVolForLife]

He is a good/great player but I don't see him as the number one QB in the class 🤷 Nico > Manning

[smittylamar]

Most former players kid, HAS A EDGE OVER THE REST OF US, BUT ARCH IS NIT A 5 star, AND STOP RIDING THE MANNING NUTS YALL DINT EVEN NO THEM, AND HE IS OVER RATED, COMP WAS TRASH TRASH LIKE TRASH JUICE TRASH.lol

[goinrich]

Mike Farrell likes to get Texas fans riled up. He does it on a regular basis.

[MaxEffortSooner]

Doesn't explain why him and his camp have not be attending the best camps. And people making 5⭐ assessments with that data point is head scratching. His film doesn't pop off the screen to me either.

[ThrowINTS]

The Manning name has nothing to do with 5 Stars with 1.000!!! Kyler Murray was 43-0
3 time state football champion
10, 386 passing yards, 117 TDs, 21 INTs. 4, 139 rushing yards, 69 rushing. Total yards 14, 525 yards and 186 total TDs and was
5 Star (4 star as beginning of Sr year)
0.9855
National Rank 34
State of Texas Rank 5
Manning stats and eye test suggest he is better high school player than Kyler Murray. So what am I missing?? With no names just stat comparison which would you think was the Ranked Nationality 1st and 34th. Manning is good but be real. Who cares what someone else says that watches a lot of football. Look at the facts yourself on paper and video. Kyler is one of the best if not the best high school football player ever.
Rated nat.34th Sr year. Manning is Greatest prospect ever!! It’s not cause he chose TX I’m not a hater. He is good but BOLD BOLD statements leaving people mouth and no one looks at the facts first. Sad and lazy

[blyat]

Bronny James is currently signed with Nike a 1.7 million contract at that lol

[Hollowayshouse]

He looks good on tape. His name got him attention . But he is very polished. 5 stars aren’t given out cause of names. But we will see. Hope he can handle the hype

[reedturner]

What's extremely funny and obvious that no one talks about is how highly touted Peyton and Eli were bc their dad was an NFL QB. Social media is complete garbage just trying yo create click content. If some "expert" makes a ridiculous claim like Arch being a 3 star dumpster fire, it will be forgotten in a couple of weeks but at least he generated clicks for his employer. Arch will be just as good as Peyton, maybe better bc of development.

[jasonprestonATX]

I bet most of these people saying Arch is only getting the hype because of his last name. Wouldn’t be saying this if he chose there school 💯

[kentjackson]

BIAS .. that dude don’t PLAY nobody, he is entitled

[PremiumWater]

Arch Manning is absolutely overrated and it will most likely result in a coaching change at Texas. Rumor out of Alabama and Georgia is that they were not that interested.

[orangetuono]

Arch might only have 1300 yards with 62% completions his JR season, but he's polished and developed and he's got HUGE MANNING HUEVOS! Bevo needs some BIG SWINGING HUEVOS.