Boxycharm by Ipsy | Sister VS Sister | October 2024

FTC disclosure: This post or video contains affiliate links, which means I may receive a commission for purchases made through my links

#boxycharm #sistervssister #unboxing

[morganmath]

You both are so gorgeous. Love seeing sister vs sister posts! Just put in my first BOXYCHARM order!

[shelbybroom]

I always make sure to review my items every month and I feel like that has made a difference in better choices

[marlenewalker]

Good afternoon Rachel and Katrina!!! I think you both got very good boxes this time around, but you both tied in my opinion. My favorite items are the lippie in Katrina's box, and the face palette in Rachel's box. Thank you so much for sharing with us, and I hope you both have a Blessed weekend!!!

[mariarose]

Hey Katrina and Rachel, always great to see both of you! You two are my favorite!!!

[michellerebar]

Your boxes were so different from mine! October was one of my favorite boxes so far. I got First Aid Beauty ultra repair cream (that I needed to buy anyway!), Tula ultra hydration serum, Tovegan green glow cream moisturizer, Eloise Beauty Goddess eyeshadow palette (it's gorgeous!), and Ciate London dewy skin tint (absolutely not meant for either of you but perfect for me). With the colder weather coming, I really appreciate all the hydration I'm my box. The last few boxes have been kind of "meh", but this one made up for it.

[mariarose]

Katrina your lip shade you picked looked just like what you had on

[micheleberg]

Love seeing both of you!! You guys make me smile!❤

[lynettealexanderxoxo]

Girl you literally just read eye lash serum 🤣 🤣 🤣 🤣 Rachel needs an all skincare box. She doesn't seem to really like makeup. I love getting great skincare but I just turned 50. Love ya'lls videos! TFS

[ericairish]

I love watching you guys but does anyone agree Ipsy has really gone downhill. Who else misses Boxycharm? 😢

[terriepriest]

I do like the sister VS sister.I don't think I would use the lip scrub either but I like what you both got

[faegrrrl]

Yes, lip scrubs must always have a scent even if it's vanilla. The Kim Chi powder looks really nice!! Good to see you gals!!

[alexashowandtell]

I wish girlactik spray was coconut or something more universal. Rose is just like, you either love or hate it.. and most people hate it. 😢

[PatriciaNorton-ju]

Love when u guys do these videos. Are you guys going to do Universal Yum soon? I can’t remember what was in my box

[louthefrogqueen]

This months box wasn’t great. I resubscribed and wish I would have waited cause I couldn’t pick what I wanted but I did get a few good things. I got the Living Proof hair item which I’m happy about and I got a Tarte blush wand an eyeshadow palette, the same lipstick you got and one other thing I can’t remember. I would have been super bummed with the lip mask and the rose spray if I got them too. Thanks for sharing and have a good day!

[aleigha]

Hiiii! I’ve missed you beautiful ladies! ❤ I have had a lot going on and haven’t been able to watch videos for awhile so I’m catching up. I always love to watch the sis v sis 😊 I liked things from both boxes and really disliked things from both boxes. For me, I would probably use more of what is in Rachel’s box. I think that palette is super cute and I love a good face cleanser. And I use my eye lash serum 2-3 times a week now (at first I used it nightly faithfully for probably two months) and it does work. My favorite one is the L’Oréal lash growth serum. It’s not expensive and works! Love it! I wouldn’t use a lip scrub EVER. I don’t know if it came in blue Hawaiian flavor I wouldn’t use it. Lip masks are the way to go. I use one every single night. Lip scrubs create micro tears in the very thin skin on the lips and cause more irritation. I found out the hard way by a doctor 🤦‍♀️ and in Katrina’s box I do like the Kim Chi powder and the lipstick. I also like the living proof too. I don’t know that I would use the rose spray either. I tend to not like the rose scented products. I. Do feel like Ipsy could’ve done better this month. ….Enjoy your items ladies! Tyfs. Sending much love hugs and prayers your way ❤️🙏

[lisasmith]

I agree you win. Sis has a cute palette. Have a wonderful week ❌️ ⭕️

[maureen]

At least you gals got all 5 items in your box. Mine was missing the Eloise eyeshadow palette I chose😢. I also got the lip scrub & face palette chosen for me like Rachel did & I probably won’t use either one. Not the best month for Boxycharm….

[mariarose]

Katrina 3 out of 5 for $30 nope. Rachel 2.5 out of 5 for $30.00 nope

[tracyfrederick]

As a fellow oily girl I've learned some things. Don't over mattify, you'll just make your skin produce more oils because they're supposed to be there. When you mattify, you make your skin unbalanced.

Try some of the products that add a little moisture. You'll be surprised.

[sheri-annemiller-penner]

i had a hard time making choices this month, i was like there is nothing here i want 🤔 however now that i got my box i’m a little bit more impressed. got a setting spray, clear brow wax, liquid blush & serum skin tint. the only thing I’m meh about is an AHA body lotion just because i’m unsure of how to use it 😂