Smithey Ironware Cast Iron: Differences between First Gen No. 10 & No. 8 vs Current Model

In this video, I will be showcasing the differences between the “kickstarter” Smithey No. 10 Skillet and the current updated version. Also a brief showcasing of a first gen No. 8 skillet and a current model. For anyone who might be interested in purchasing a Smithey, follow the link below. Thanks for watching and I do hope you enjoy.

Smithey Ironware

[luisj.castironcooking]

One thing I forgot to mention is the finishing of the skillets. The new pans are machined and polished. The first gen is not polished. I will do a follow up on the seasoning and how the older holds up vs the newer polished version.

[Iniamelendez]

Great presentation Luis. I want a Smithey, but I am reluctant to buy one because of all the negative reviews a had read, people talk about how difficult is to maintain the seasoning. They also talk about many other things that I wouldn’t want to deal with if I end up with one of their problematic cast iron skillets. Smithey have a policy of no returns if you use it, so $170 is a lot of money to spend if you can’t return a product you aren’t satisfied with.

[rstumbaugh]

Great video Luis!! I personally like the refinements of the newer skillet. I finally pulled the trigger and ordered the 12” griddle, it came in, and I love it. I never had a gen 1 smithey, I’ve heard the gen 1, were very hard so season/keep seasoned, but not so much any more..

[Doctorartpt]

Awesome video Luis. Thank you for your content. I like how glossy black your smithy is. Have you made a video on the seasoning process you use to get it that gloss black or do you simply just cook a ton with it or both? Thanks!

[ihiohoh]

Do you prefer to cook with Smithey or Butter Pat?

[debbie]

It is a great video the differences is interesting. I would want a newer one.

[adamcreal]

I love the way Smithey cast iron looks. Still stuck between this one and stargazer.

[chimanchoi]

How do you maintain your cast iron cookware? How do you keep them in such pristine condition while using them everyday?

[MrNiceGuyx]

So is the second gen better overall or do you foresee a gen 3 that has the best of both older versions

[WarChortle]

Wondering out of all the pans you've tried which has been the best for smash burgers.

[bigw]

I’m reluctant to but another Smithey. While visually appealing it has been difficult to maintain seasoning. I’m not a casual user either, it’s being used daily.

[gardeningandgrowing]

Great video Louis. How do you like the chefs pan?

[mischiefmanaged]

I must own a generation one Smithey, the seasoning will not stick & I have the same issues with my Field

[Wish]

I've noticed smithey doesn't hold its seasoning well

[cynthiawesley]

Simple genius. They need to put you on a commercial. You really take da time to do an absolutely THERAL EXAMINATION & of a product. I believe you can sell SNOW to an ESKIMO. My guy you're good I was paying so CLOSE ATTENTION & you almost sold me, , , , even on da $10 hike yes EVERYTHING is going up. But you LOST me on da price.🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 I LOVE your modern iron reviews. It's different material for we closed minded ppl. Gre8t job. please. Njoy your day.