Doctor Who Silence in the library Miss Evangelista ghosting scene

[jumpcutfilms]

"She's a footprint on the beach, and the tide's coming in"
Probably one of the darkest lines I've ever heard

[oracleofpelham]

"Dont tell the others they will only laugh"

you can literally see the wave of guilt crash on her "friends"

[ghostpants]

She didn't say "ice cream", she answered The Doctor. "Who screamed?"

"I Screamed."

[Macapta]

“That was the most horrible thing I’ve ever seen”

It’s hits so much harder that it wasn’t some big monster or someone dying. It was the echo of a person blinking out. A quiet and subtler moment.

[anitacalloway]

Terribly sad part of a terribly sad episode.

[thefurrybastard]

Now this was New Dr Who at the height of it's writing. Very moving scene.

[Hex_Glitches]

"Is the nice woman there?"
Still a testament about how the others treated her poorly she felt severely disregarded and it costed her life.

[LilSpookyyy]

I was so pissed when the guy didn’t listen to her when she called for them

[RoseGirl]

Tell me Donna Noble didn't do the most. Connecting mentally with the Ood, this, pulling the trigger WITH the doctor so that Pompeii wasn't all on him to bear, reminding him to stay kind and begging him to save just one person in Pompeii. I love Donna so damn much and her ending hurt.

[TheUnknownhumangirl]

"She's a footprint on the beach and the tide is coming in" my god why 😭💔

[Gabe-oixw]

I’ve watched this episode so many times and yet it always makes me tear up. The music is so sad and it just hurts me when I watch it. Her ghosting is just horrible and Donna’s reaction is one we’d all have in the situation. I have so much respect for Stephen Moffat here. These episodes and this scene shows his brilliant writing style

[ApetureTestSubject]

Donna really did get some of the most harrowing Doctor Who stories, didn't she?
This, Ood slavery, Pompei, Sontarans suffocating Earth, the alternate world in Turn Left, and of course Journey's End. For all her talk of how useless she is, she survives all of that and doesn't let it break her. She is honestly the strongest Doctor Who companion we've had, (with Rory as a runner up.)

[winkinggerbil]

I like that river kept her ghost translator. Makes sense that shes there at the end with her, her actual conciousnious stayed with her I think.

[flargarbason]

This entire premise is absolute genius. The idea of having your consciousness trapped in a machine as data ghost is absolutely terrifying

[nicholaswilliams]

"That was the most horrible thing I've ever seen!"

Oh well strap in. It gets worse.

[azapro]

3:47 One of the darkest moments in the show's history.

[Andy-xipu]

The way everyone (except Donna) treated her disgusts me. They just brushed her aside. The Doctor didn’t treat her _that_ terribly, but I still don’t like the way he interacted with her. It was only until she died did they feel bad. Donna was honestly so amazing to be kind to Miss Evangelista when everyone else was treating her like shit. Just another reason why Donna is one of the best. But fun fact to sort of lighten this comment, Talulah Riley (Miss Evangelista) is actually Elon Musk’s ex-wife :)

[deansmith]

😢😢😭.. the nice Women..is she there.. is that the nice Women.. 😭😭😭

[corvusdove]

"Who turned out the lights" made it into a monster from Fallout New Vegas that had is a suit with a skeleton in it. Shooting one was the day that remembering this scene didn't show up in my dreams anymore lol.

[AbbeyLalor]

This is one of the most horrifying moments in the entire show