Prime Roger vs Prime Garp

[simpledude]

garp does not need a sword or devil fruit he just needs his hands what a goat

[GoodiePlaysWell]

You know your opponent is dangerous when he wears a suit to a fight

[Akechifan]

They're complete equals. Either could win extreme diff.

[vento]

You could argue that from the 3 big ones (4 if you count sengoku). Garp is the strongest because he is the only one using purely his body.
Whitebeard: has a top tier graded wep + OP DF.
Sengoku: OP DF
Roger: top tier graded wep.
Garp: "lol I punch stuff"

[ghislainnguema]

That's my man. He litterally said that before 1080

[shamanth_r]

Op creater: They were equals.

Op fans: Nah.

[wyatt]

Finally, someone who actually picks a side and doesn’t end on “both are equal”

[sychoniems]

Didn't Oda said all the great old gen were equal (WB, Roger, Garp, SenGoku)

[fool]

Strange, but not necessarily wrong take, considering Roger possibly died before his Prime. So I could definitely see Garp, Sengoku, and Whitebeard above him.

[totallynotdeadinside]

W take as I see people putting roger over garp all the time even tho they are stated to be equals so you putting garp over roger is refreshing and not necessarily that bad

[Lost_D.Zoro]

My opinion Roger=Garp(Prime) + Excellent Edit🔥

[kousthubanand]

I'd say Garp= Roger.
Only Whitebeard is slightly stronger, because he's got Haki, Supreme grade weapon and an insane devil fruit combo

[Sage-A]

If you see Garp smiling you know your dead

[ibrahimsurti]

Someone finally gets how powerful Garp was

Man was pulling up with randoms to chase and fight roger and his crew

[edu]

Roger is most underrated character in one piece

[Muxmimi]

i thought he would be one of those people to say roger wins

[Thebestmrbob]

Many many people fully disagree but this is 1000 percent true (my opinion) garp>roger>whitebeard (all mega insane dif)

[guma_den]

can you do three admirals vs trio supernova? ( kizaru akainu and aokiji vs luffy law kid)

[gustavoferoz]

Eae man pode olhar minhas edits e falar em algo que eu posso melhorar?

[outsider]

Spoiler alert









Garp in his eighties destroyed a whole island using ACOC with one hand 💀