OLD vs. NEW 'Follow Me' (Minecraft FNAF Animated Music Video)

___

___

Check out the Behind the Scenes: COMING SOON
__

__

[Funnyjoke]

I love the original, it showed the story of the missing children, and showcased good modeling, and lighting.
The animation wasnt really lacking any, but it wasnt top quality.

The new has phenomenal animation, beautiful light rendering, and a nice look to it overall. I think the model for springtrap looks a bit odd, and the story wasnt told aswell.

In conclusion, both have their strengths, and the second one clearly wasnt story based.
I stand with the popular opinion that the second one is a bit worse.
No hate if you like the newer one better though, everyone has their preferences.

[herobrinegreek]

The Original fits more on the whole "Foxy Song" situation, while the new shows a more realistic POV of what happened, it shows us who Afton really is in a much more "realistic" way

[Nugcon]

The old one has a better plot, the climax is more engaging to watch, not to mention it builds up the story of the Foxy song. What the new one does well is worldbuilding and the general horror feel of fnaf, they aren't afraid to go dark. Since it's presumably a new timeline they gotta give us some exposition and I feel like this music video is more of a set up for what's to come. Of course all the technical stuff like lighting and character animation has improved but that's expected with time.

[yourcool]

The new one has some good parts, emotions as you can see fear a lot better and lighting and animation. The old ones is more “canon” and it tells it pretty well but I can see how he wanted to make it different and still improved in some parts.

[ricardoverse]

2:22 It's really cool they punch at the same time

[lolbitva]

I love them both, I wouldn’t be able to decide which one is better. They both have an amazing touch of animation, whatsoever. (2:29 on the new one lol his reaction when he tried to punch him his fist be bleeding now)

[toriroselife]

which one do you think is better

like-original
commnet-new

[wertzboyz]

New one ending better than others I didn’t think you would do another “Follow me” I like both good job 👍

[PugPugPug]

0:42 please tell me I’m not the only one hearing “tonight he *swear words* again”

[KayFurs]

i still think the original is better...i feel like it tells more of the story

Edit: tysm for

[thatclassclown]

This really shows how much he and his friend's have improved.
(Visual effects, Animation, Lighting, Emotion, Models, Etc.)

[borgan]

Gotta say, like the original better because
1. it was less gruesome
2.The hair was better imo
3. it fit in with the lore better
4.it had a better and somewhat more wholesome ending
Still, amazing job, keep up the good work!

[cindypicadomolina]

Old will always be my favorite but the new one is very interesting and well made!!

[Keira_Akoma]

If you pull pieces from both i think would be good; but I personally enjoy the older one better; but awesome job.

[popsocket]

The old kinda tells the whole story in a one music as much as the new one but the new really have good graphics and unique ideas. Good Job on improving!

[diamondsnowwolves]

I love how both animations both take completely different steps, but still have some basics, like the children.
(Edit: Thanks for the likes)

[dokkoishoo]

i like the old one

At some points the new William Afton looks like someone you would avoid even before you knew he killed kids.

[gamersclanyt]

It's funny how at the end of the old version Afton is crawling like a noob. "3:14"

[acowthatjumpedoverthemoon]

I like them both, but I feel if you took a few things from both the videos and put them together it would be 10000x cooler (in my opinion). I like the concept of a officer looking into the incident, but I also like how the animatronics have more emotion and drive the video forward. But overall they are both really good, keep it up

[laurendyer]

Old! By far my favourite, I watched the old one constantly. The new one is still great though. Still a bit on the fence about the new Afton model though, I like his personality though, you can see his madness better on the new video :b