Ryan Williams or Jeremiah Smith: Who Would you BUILD A College Football Team Around!?

Phillip Dukes asks Andy Staples who is the better wide receiver? Alabama's Ryan Williams or Ohio State's Jeremiah Smith.

Subscribe to On3Recruits! ⬇️

Welcome to On3 | The best of college football and recruiting

Follow Josh Newberg on Twitter

Follow us on X

Follow us on Instagram

Like/Follow us on Facebook

[BamaRockstar]

Smith is great but Williams just has something special I haven’t seen from anyone else.

[GarrettSmith-dl]

Ryan williams 177 and a TD against Georgia it’s not a debate

[teamtonioadr]

It's things Ryan Williams can do that JJ can't. JJ can't look another 5☆ CB face to face and make him look foolish.

[Dayz]

JJ let see him against actual competition

[Superfreq]

They are both exceptional! I'm a Buckeye, so I'm going with Smith. I played WR, and I watch closely! What a WR class this is. Historic!

[WilliamBrown-xy]

Smith doesnt have the after catch ability like williams. Randy moss like impact

[BAMAMADEMG]

Ryan Williams and the brother is 17 let’s not forget that he just on a different level

[matthewsteele]

Smith is Great but Ryan can make any catch like OBJ.

[txcanesbeliever]

Smith is a man compared to someone that still needs to grow into his body.

[jakobhazeltine]

Jeremiah smith for these reasons:

1. Size
2. JJ is competing with 3 first round picks in the same offense and still outshining them
3. One hand catch ability

[HerbstreitBrokeFSU]

Osu blue chip DBs were food for JJ the moment he got to Osu. It’s like Hartline developed JJ over zoom calls or something…

[melo]

OPTIMUS PRIME IS THE BEST WR IN AMERICA PERIOD 🇺🇸 Exactly compact Megatron. Exactly why he's Optimus

[jamalj]

Smith by far and a better route runner

[ImLikeThat]

Ryan but also I’m biased since I’m a bama fan

[GBamaBoy]

We've never seen a Ryan Williams. We've seen a lot JJ Smiths. Ryan footwork, hands, speed and run after the catch sets him apart.

[kevinchavis]

What are we talking about here? It’s Jeremiah Smith. Smith is the complete wr, has size. strength, speed, can get the 50/50 jump balls, great route runner, and can block much better. Ryan Williams is great but Jeremiah is the total package. Dukes loves the southern schools cause he’s from the south.. we know what it is

[cindyreed]

I go Ryan Williams hes a awesome player and hes so young and just imagine what hes going to be when he gets older im so proud of him ROLL TIDE

[jamesrich]

Ryan Williams is Justin Jefferson

Jeremiah smith is Julio jones

Do what you will

[garyroenicke]

How could you pick any over the other? Let’s break it down— Smith is bigger but 1 or 2 yrs older, Williams is faster and better moves and younger. Looks like a Tie and can’t go wrong with either

[kpperson]

He's the new Dre Day...aka.. HOF...Andre Johnson