What is a NAKED SINGULARITY and does it exist?

preview_player
Показать описание
We are used to hearing about singularities in black holes... but what are naked singularities? What do they represent, and can they exist? Today, we will discuss this as well as singularities in general.

My video about how we know that black holes exist
My video about black hole alternatives
My video about Black Hole Information paradox

Sources:
Singularities
Penrose’s paper
Cosmic Censorship
Naked Singularity
Models
Рекомендации по теме
Комментарии
Автор

The real naked singularity is the friends we made along the way

milkman
Автор

wouldn't calling singularities infinitely dense be inaccurate? my understanding is that we are waiting for some kind of quantum gravity theory to explain where the limitation of infinitely approaching 0 volume is and that imaginary numbers like 0 or infinity can't exist practically

SuraiHCS
Автор

How could you possibly distinguish between an unimaginarily small volume and a point? And how could it make any meaningful difference to how a black hole works?

protokyuubi
Автор

Good stuff. Succinct, well researched and not dumbed down too much. You have a new subscriber.

benjaminbeard
Автор

How does this video not have more traction

oasisboi
Автор

if it's really infinitely dense, why is not its influence infitnie?

phuyaibankaengkro
Автор

On the face of it, a naked singularity just looks to me like a black hole whose mass is insufficient to restrain light. Obviously this is not so, or our host wouldn't have made this video. Is there a simple explanation of why I am wrong, or am I so far off base that correction would require rewiring my brain?

stephencuffel
Автор

Это как космос просто, только ещё проще, но почему-то на английском и с разъяснениями для тех, кто привык измерять всё в стадионах? И канал с 2020 года, но почему-то ютуб показал эту штуку только сейчас? Странные вещи происходят.... но вообще достойная попытка забранчиться на англоязычную аудиторию, особенно с учётом неясного будущего русскоязычного интернета.

az
Автор

We have singularities in the two quark formations of two up, one down (female) and two down, one up (male).

Those formations are 3 things that are not each other but are one (cannot be divided further). Leibniz called the zero-dimensional space binding our quarks together with the strong force the "Monad" which has two sides Monas (singularity) and Monos (alone).

readyfireaim
Автор

"Singularity" is mathematical smoke and mirrors, a word that mathematicians use when they want to maintain their intellectual standing but are forced to give a word for an object or concept that falls betwween between size and no size, or between object and no object. Mathematics has no concept of absence; It cannot distinguish between presence and absence; so, for example, mathematicians can't realize that a radius of 0 is a contradiction, and quite a foolish one.Mathematicians hate philosophy, but they need it badly.

JohnJones-txrt
Автор

Zero is the most important number in mathematics and is both a real and an imaginary number with a horizon through it.

Zero-dimensional space is the most important dimension in physics and is both a real and an imaginary dimension with an event horizon through it.

readyfireaim
Автор

Nice my favorite youtube channel but in English

levzahaievskyi